Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Judi Lynn

(160,526 posts)
Thu Feb 28, 2019, 10:59 PM Feb 2019

Walmart, local stores hit with $12 mn price-fixing fine in Chile

Source: Agence France-Presse


Date created : 01/03/2019 - 03:09

Santiago (AFP)

A Chilean anti-trust court on Thursday fined two homegrown supermarket chains and the local branch of Walmart $12.4 million for colluding to fix the price of fresh chicken.

The Court for the Defense of Free Competition found that Walmart, Cencosud and SMU had worked together to set prices from 2008 to 2011.

The three chains, which control 92.5 percent of Chile's grocery sector, said Thursday in separate statements that that they would appeal the ruling to the country's Supreme Court.

The case is the latest in a long line of similar price-fixing schemes to plague Chile, including over toilet paper and cement.

Read more: https://www.france24.com/en/20190301-walmart-local-stores-hit-with-12-mn-price-fixing-fine-chile

4 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Walmart, local stores hit with $12 mn price-fixing fine in Chile (Original Post) Judi Lynn Feb 2019 OP
Chilean supermarkets fined $12 million for chicken price-fixing Judi Lynn Feb 2019 #1
This is how it's done in Chile? Honeycombe8 Feb 2019 #2
The greedy sadists at the top seem to go after the products people use the most. Judi Lynn Mar 2019 #3
Thanks for all that information. Honeycombe8 Mar 2019 #4

Judi Lynn

(160,526 posts)
1. Chilean supermarkets fined $12 million for chicken price-fixing
Thu Feb 28, 2019, 11:01 PM
Feb 2019


FEBRUARY 28, 2019 / 7:32 PM / UPDATED AN HOUR AGO
Aislinn Laing
1 MIN READ

SANTIAGO (Reuters) - Chilean supermarket chains Cencosud, SMU and the local unit of Walmart Inc were fined $12.1 million on Thursday for participating in a scheme to fix the price of fresh chicken, according to court documents.

The companies, which have a combined market share of more than 90 percent, said they would appeal to Chile’s supreme court.

. . .

The TDLC fined Censosud $5.14 million, Wal-Mart Chile $4.1 million, and SMU $3 million.

Antitrust regulator the FNE brought the case in 2016 after Chilean paper manufacturer CMPC and a division of Sweden’s SCA were fined and ordered to compensate consumers for colluding for a decade to fix toilet paper prices.

More:
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-chile-supermarkets-chicken/chilean-supermarkets-fined-12-million-for-chicken-price-fixing-idUSKCN1QI3AK?rpc=401&

Honeycombe8

(37,648 posts)
2. This is how it's done in Chile?
Thu Feb 28, 2019, 11:43 PM
Feb 2019

Where I expect people are poor, so the price of chicken is critical? Since there's a long line of price-fixing schemes plaguing Chile, I am guessing that all stores have to go along to get along. That's how it works, I hear. If the others do it, you have to, or you're out of business.

And the ordinary people suffer. But..chicken? Why chicken? Is it the main source of protein? And toilet paper? Because it's a necessity?

Judi Lynn

(160,526 posts)
3. The greedy sadists at the top seem to go after the products people use the most.
Fri Mar 1, 2019, 12:20 AM
Mar 2019

George H W Bush invested in Bechtel, which owns a subsidiary which managed to get control of Bolivia's water. This was during the dictatorship of Hugo Banzer, a real Nazi who hired a German WWII Nazi war criminal, Klaus Barbie to assist him in his dictatorship. The Aguas del Tunari, the Bechtel subsidiary, hiked the prices for the people so wildly people couldn't afford water at ALL, and, of course had no choice but to take their lives into their hands and protest.

From a Wikipedia:

Cochabamba Water War
Main article: Cochabamba Water War

In early 2000, protests against the raised price of water due to privatization had been growing, and martial law was declared. In April 2000, Víctor Hugo Daza, a seventeen year old student, was shot in the face by the Bolivian Army while protesting the increase of local water rates due to privatization. The man who killed him, Captain Robinson Iriarte, was trained as a counter-insurgent in the United States; he was acquitted of all responsibility for the murder in 2002. No civilian criminal-justice system would take the case on, so a military tribunal had final jurisdiction. Upon his acquittal, he was
promoted to major.[2]

Thousands of people captured the central plaza in Cochbamaba and surrounded the fountain where Daza's body lied. Protestors were made up of peasant irrigators, retired factory workers, union members, pieceworkers, sweatshop employees, street vendors, students from the University of Cochabamba, coca-leaf farmers and residential children.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_privatization_in_Bolivia


In 2000, after closed-door sessions, control over Cochabamba’s water supply was given to Aguas de Tunari, a coalition of foreign companies dominated by the USA’s Bechtel. Water supply was (and continues to be) a difficulty for the city; a large proportion of residents lack steady access, or only have dirty water unsafe for consumption. In 1999, as a prerequisite to further loans, the World Bank insisted on privatization of Cochabamba’s water, and the cash-strapped Bolivian government was quick to bend over.

The way in which Aguas de Tunari went about their business was astoundingly deaf to the realities of life in Bolivia. Soon after operations began, water bills were jacked by over 200%. Households which only made about $70 a month were suddenly being billed $20 for water: more than their monthly food budget. The company even claimed homemade wells and devices which collected rain water as their property, and charged for their use. Of course, people freaked out. Bolivia is famous for its strikes and roadblocks, but the intensity of the reaction in Cochabamba took everyone by surprise. Poor Bechtel! Corporations are used to trampling on a domesticated, complacent people.

For four days, students and even the middle class joined campesinos and cholitas in the streets, completely shutting down Cochabamba. The primary demand was simple: Aguas de Tunari must leave. The government declared a state of siege and sent in troops to quash the riots, and Cochabamba became a war zone. This was the era of Hugo Banzer, a former dictator who had been toppled in 1978, and returned to power as the leader of a legitimate, and starkly conservative, political party.

When an army captain was filmed shooting and killing a young protester, Víctor Hugo Daza, the riots reached fever pitch. The executives of Aguas de Tunari were airlifted out of Cochabamba, and when the dust settled, the protesters were surprised to learn they had won. Unequivocally. A well-organized grassroots movement, started by some of the world’s poorest and most humble people, had defeated both a deep-pocketed corporation and their own hostile government.

More:
http://bolivia.for91days.com/the-cochabamba-water-wars/

When the water people heard some people were trying to collect rain water in barrels they started work on legislation to be able to charge people for the rainwater they collected, too. Who on earth could sit still for that kind of greed?


Oh, yes, it should be noted that George H W Bush's friend, Taiwan's Rev. Sun Myung Moon moved a horde of his followers and bought a vast tract of land in Paraguay, right above the world's largest body of underground fresh water, the Guarani Aquifer:

The Guarani aquifer - a vast subterranean aquifer located in Southeastern South America - has recently become a contested site for resource management.

Lying beneath four countries and holding the possibility to sustain humanity’s basic need for potable water for generations to come, the delineation between national, regional and international jurisdiction, profit and sustainability, remain worryingly unclear and uncertain.

. . .

"The Guaraní Aquifer... is one of the world's largest aquifer systems... It is said that this vast underground reservoir could supply fresh drinking water to the world for 200 years."

"US President George W. Bush allegedly has recently purchased a 98,842 acre farm in Chaco, Paraguay atop the aquifer. The Reverend Moon has also purchased 1,482,600 acres in Chaco, Paraguay."



https://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/sociopolitica/sociopol_globalwater20.htm

Largest in the world.

I hadn't taken time to consider the article well enough, as the hoarding and price-fixing on Chile's huge common use products fit exactly into the scheme. So glad you mentioned this. Thanks.

Honeycombe8

(37,648 posts)
4. Thanks for all that information.
Fri Mar 1, 2019, 04:03 AM
Mar 2019

I recognize some of those names, so they must have been in the news. That's just horrible. Horrible! Water, of all things.

That's a good reason for regulation and control of such things by the govt. Assuming the govt is a decent one.

At least in Chile, they caught the price fixing. I bet it wasn't easy to get the evidence for it.

I'm disappointed in WalMart for doing that. I thought it had sort of turned a page from its ruthless ways. Maybe it was "either you do it this way, or its the highway for you"? Walmart wouldn't have as much clout there, being an outsider. Or maybe I'm giving WalMart too much benefit of the doubt.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Walmart, local stores hit...