America’s clear choice: Franklin Roosevelt or Ayn Rand

[riverwalker]

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:blogs.ft.com/the-a-list/2012/08/13/americas-clear-choice-franklin-roosevelt-or-ayn-rand/?
Simon Schama
August 13, 2012

This much you have to give Mitt Romney: by choosing Paul Ryan as his running mate he has made it impossible to avoid turning the presidential election into a genuine and long overdue debate on the nature, extent and responsibilities of American government. By doing that, whatever the outcome, he will have rendered a service to the American people, who deserve to be drawn into in an all-out contest of principles rather than the usual beauty-pageant cum pratfall-watch that consume most autumn campaigns.

Because Mr Ryan (unlike the top of the ticket), is in the habit of actually attaching numbers to his budget proposals, there is a faint possibility that the debate between Americans who want to retain the institutions of the New Deal and the 1960s (such as Medicare), and those who believe that under Franklin Roosevelt and Lyndon Johnson the country took a fatal step towards collectivism, will actually have to consider evidence rather than collapse into the usual exchange of uninformed abuse that gets confused with argument.

<more>

[Z_California]

1. Wishful thinking

"...will actually have to consider evidence rather than collapse into the usual exchange of uninformed abuse that gets confused with argument"

Hate to say it but, wishful thinking IMO. This election, like every other, will be decided by morons. The best ad campaign will win.