Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

WiffenPoof

(2,404 posts)
Tue Nov 24, 2015, 08:55 PM Nov 2015

Novels not made into movies...

I've always wondered why no one has made a movie based on the great American novel...."A Catcher in the Rye". I think it would make a great film.

I would also like to see a follow-up of "Taxi Driver".... With an aging Travis Buckle.

Do you have any movies that were never made?

36 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Novels not made into movies... (Original Post) WiffenPoof Nov 2015 OP
I always wondered that myself TorchTheWitch Nov 2015 #1
J.D. Salinger explains why “Catcher in the Rye” shouldn’t be a movie, 1957 pinboy3niner Nov 2015 #2
Thank you.... WiffenPoof Nov 2015 #5
Salinger wouldn't let Hollywood touch Holden Caulfield... First Speaker Nov 2015 #3
Thanks WiffenPoof Nov 2015 #6
A Confederacy of Dunces... Tom Kitten Nov 2015 #4
The Monkeywrench Gang movie has long been rumored but never materialized NightWatcher Nov 2015 #7
There was a knock off Mendocino Nov 2015 #20
Max Barry's "Jennifer Government" Aristus Nov 2015 #8
PKD's Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch. PufPuf23 Nov 2015 #9
This right here is the correct answer. Dr. Strange Nov 2015 #10
While I wasn't a reader of Phillip K, I've always loved the movie Blade Runner. aidbo Nov 2015 #14
Every PKD movie I've seen is broken. hunter Nov 2015 #30
Wow. Thank you. PufPuf23 Nov 2015 #31
Lord of Light by Roger Zelazny, so infamously not a movie they made a movie about it not being made CBGLuthier Nov 2015 #11
A full-length version of Springtime for Hitler, please jmowreader Nov 2015 #12
Steppenwolf should be re-made. Joe Shlabotnik Nov 2015 #13
I'm still waiting for any book by Neal Stephenson to be made into a movie. aidbo Nov 2015 #15
Chuck Palahnuik's "Survivor" Initech Nov 2015 #16
Catcher in the Rye was terrible. bigwillq Nov 2015 #17
Houlden Caulfield is every self-absorbed young teen that thinks themselves all-knowing alphafemale Nov 2015 #28
Still waiting for "The Stars, My Destination" sarge43 Nov 2015 #18
I'd love to see Jonathan Franzen's "The Corrections" as a movie. Paladin Nov 2015 #19
How about one that should *not* be made into a movie: malthaussen Nov 2015 #21
Heinlein's libertarianism on screen? Yeah, I'd skip that one, for sure. Paladin Nov 2015 #22
That's an amazing movie, on the surface all popcorn over-the-top sci-fi, underneath sly satire. hunter Nov 2015 #26
Big credit to the director, Paul Verhoeven. (nt) Paladin Nov 2015 #27
It would definitely need a tech update IDemo Nov 2015 #34
I agree about "The Corrections" mentalsolstice Nov 2015 #23
Good idea, re the TV mini-series. (nt) Paladin Nov 2015 #24
Player Piano by Kurt Vonnegut OrwellwasRight Nov 2015 #25
Atwood's The Handmaids Tale and Tim O'Brien's Going After Cacciato - nt KingCharlemagne Nov 2015 #29
The Handmaid's Tale was made into a movie TexasBushwhacker Nov 2015 #32
Thanks! - nt KingCharlemagne Nov 2015 #35
Got pretty good reviews too! n/t TexasBushwhacker Nov 2015 #36
my answer is different skippercollector Nov 2015 #33

TorchTheWitch

(11,065 posts)
1. I always wondered that myself
Tue Nov 24, 2015, 09:14 PM
Nov 2015

One novel I wish had been made into a film was "The Charm School" by Nelson DeMille. On one of the pages in the front of the book (my old copy anyway) it says something like "soon to to be a major motion picture" except it never got made.

Though there are probably loads of books I've read that I'd love to see in film, that's always the one that sticks in my mind and still bothers me that it never got made.

First Speaker

(4,858 posts)
3. Salinger wouldn't let Hollywood touch Holden Caulfield...
Tue Nov 24, 2015, 09:18 PM
Nov 2015

...there's a story--which may be apocryphal--that a famous director offered to make a movie of it, and he--the director--would show it just to Salinger, and if J.D. didn't like it, the movie would be destroyed. Needless to say, Salinger refused...

Tom Kitten

(7,347 posts)
4. A Confederacy of Dunces...
Tue Nov 24, 2015, 09:33 PM
Nov 2015

one of the funniest books I've read.

"The Crying Of Lot 49" by Pynchon.

"Amerika" by Kafka.

"Death Kit" by Susan Sontag

NightWatcher

(39,343 posts)
7. The Monkeywrench Gang movie has long been rumored but never materialized
Tue Nov 24, 2015, 10:02 PM
Nov 2015

The original pitched cast has gotten too old to play. I don't know who has the rights but I wish they'd shit or get off the pot.

Mendocino

(7,495 posts)
20. There was a knock off
Wed Nov 25, 2015, 10:23 AM
Nov 2015

Last edited Wed Nov 25, 2015, 10:53 AM - Edit history (1)

called Night Moves that was actually released a few years ago. The movie rights owners of TMWG sued them, not sure what the state of that litigation is now. That is likely keeping them from moving forward on their own proper version.

I don't know if a film could due it justice, too much good story for a two hour movie. I think I would rather see a miniseries type, maybe 6-8 segments shown on AMC or HBO.

Who would you cast? My choices:

George- Aaron Paul, not quite right physically and getting long in the tooth for playing a 25 year old, but attitude would go a long way. Shame that Joaquin Phoenix is too old.

Bonnie- Ashley Green

Seldom Seen- Ethan Hawk

Doc- Liev Schreiber or JK Simmons



Aristus

(66,381 posts)
8. Max Barry's "Jennifer Government"
Tue Nov 24, 2015, 10:37 PM
Nov 2015
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jennifer_Government

George Clooney and Brad Pitt optioned it a few years ago, but the option lapsed. I imagine that even under fair use laws, this would be a very difficult film to make. What with prominently-featured corporate names and logos painting their respective companies in a very unflattering light.

It's a devastating satire on free-market capitalism and would make a killer film. But I don't think it will ever get made...

PufPuf23

(8,785 posts)
9. PKD's Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch.
Tue Nov 24, 2015, 11:10 PM
Nov 2015

Last edited Fri Nov 27, 2015, 09:17 PM - Edit history (1)

John Lennon had a movie option at one time (prior to Bladerunner or any other PKD sourced movie).

That said though a major long term fan of PKD and liking the movies in general, there has never been a movie yet made from PKD fiction that I have found satisfying as a PKD reader.

Dr. Strange

(25,921 posts)
10. This right here is the correct answer.
Tue Nov 24, 2015, 11:27 PM
Nov 2015

I'd love to see something done with Stigmata. Probably my favorite Dick novel (slightly edging out Do Androids Dream..).

 

aidbo

(2,328 posts)
14. While I wasn't a reader of Phillip K, I've always loved the movie Blade Runner.
Wed Nov 25, 2015, 01:23 AM
Nov 2015

I'm somewhat hesitant to read Do Androids Dream.. to avoid messing with my feelings about the film.

I saw the movie in theater when I was way too young, (about six) and it is the first movie I can remember seeing in a theater.

As an adult though, I fell in love with the director's cut.

Also, while I dug A Scanner Darkly, I wasn't a big fan of either Total Recall.

hunter

(38,317 posts)
30. Every PKD movie I've seen is broken.
Fri Nov 27, 2015, 08:44 PM
Nov 2015

PKD was a very dangerous fellow, in a way bigger money cannot tolerate.

In a similar bit of movie making, more successful in being truer to the artists, I first saw Terry Gilliam's Brazil with a mess of people from an affluent "assisted living" community. One elderly and mildly demented gentleman climbed up onto the stage at the end of the movie and gave it his double "fuck you" rating, two single fingers raised high for the fade-to-white ending. I let him be, trying not to be rolling on the floor laughing. Everyone in the theater that afternoon was weird in some way, including myself. A most awesome Senior Tuesday discount movie ticket.



Those days I was a paging-Doctor-Strong-Man, a day-tripper, someone elderly women could flirt harmlessly with, and someone who could knock an elderly man in full-hard-on-dirty-old-man-dropping-his-pants-mode to the floor without breaking him so badly that his privileged offspring would complain. Flipping off a movie was nothing. It was funny.

My unusually late adolescence and young StrongMan furniture moving, truck loading, young adulthood was rather twisted. I occasionally found myself attracted to some very, very dark women, and from there situations frequently got complicated. I had a girlfriend who thought Eraserhead would be a good date movie, and her girlfriend and my grandma had taught me to cope, somewhat, with the danger-to-oneself-and-others-crazy, but not without me suffering a big dose of PTSD.

My worst Thanksgiving holiday ever, my grandma got to be too much for me, a Thanksgiving at home with my parents, so I fled, long drive to the apartment I shared with other artistic sorts, all gone home for the holiday. I was visited by the Jehovah's Witnesses, a church my mom had been kicked out of, and a few hours later my girlfriend's girlfriend stumbled to my door covered with her own alcohol-and-drugs vomit, and then she tried to kill herself in my bathtub, at least half her blood running down the drain. As an autistic spectrum sort I have zero "listening skills" in this life, but the "too quiet" always creeps me out.

She was the first door lock I ever broke, and the first naked woman I ever touched as an adult.

A few days later I decided to drive to a happy place of mine, to cheer myself up, or at least meditate a bit, and ended up in nasty car wreck, not entirely my fault. No fault. But I wasn't entirely focused on driving at that moment. Parts of me still hurt. A few days later I got kicked out of university for fighting with a teaching assistant in a discussion session. My words to him were cutting, I have my grandma's and mom's skill for cutting words, but he was the only one throwing things, starting with chalk and escalating to big fat textbooks. When the campus police showed up, everyone else had fled.

PufPuf23

(8,785 posts)
31. Wow. Thank you.
Fri Nov 27, 2015, 09:32 PM
Nov 2015

A number of PKD oriented folks I have known over the years favored Gilliam to direct a PKD sourced movie.

I had a girl friend who took me to see a double feature of Eraserhead and Freaks at the original Rialto Theatre in west Berkeley when I was a student at Cal.

http://cinematreasures.org/theaters/5239

Rialto 4 Cinemas

841 Gilman Street, Berkeley, CA 94710

Closed

Previously operated by:
Renaissance Rialto

Rialto Theatre Berkeley November 1972

Viewing: Photo | Street View (Note: neat photo at link.)

Essentially assembled in a West Berkeley warehouse from salvaged parts and ornamentation from demolished or renovated older theaters (its seats, for example, came from the Oakland Paramount), the Rialto Theatre opened in 1972, and was the first theater in what would eventually become the Renaissance Rialto chain—–“the rebirth of the Rialto”, according to Allen Michaan (who had named it after an old theater he had attended as a child).

Initially a single-screen rep house, the cinema was expanded into what would eventually become a fourplex showing foreign and independent films and achieving a cult following among aficionados of those films.

Eventually changing trends, among them the then-recent arrival of the Shattuck Cinemas, took their toll, however, and Michaan eventually closed up shop at the cinema that began it all in 1989.

CBGLuthier

(12,723 posts)
11. Lord of Light by Roger Zelazny, so infamously not a movie they made a movie about it not being made
Wed Nov 25, 2015, 12:24 AM
Nov 2015

Lord of Light was the novel they were pretending to adapt to rescue the hostages as depicted in the movie Argo.

Still would love to see a version of it someday.

jmowreader

(50,559 posts)
12. A full-length version of Springtime for Hitler, please
Wed Nov 25, 2015, 12:48 AM
Nov 2015

The Life and Times of Hugo Stiglitz could be fun too. "Everybody in the German Army has heard of Hugo Stiglitz!"

How about remaking Soylent Green, but start at the instant Thorn tells Lt. Hatcher what Soylent Green is actually made of.

I would say no on The Catcher in the Rye, mainly because the only guy in the world who could properly portray Holden Caulfield is Martin Shkreli. You're not supposed to leave the movies wanting to beat the hero half to death, and Holden is the single most irritating fuck in all American literature.

Joe Shlabotnik

(5,604 posts)
13. Steppenwolf should be re-made.
Wed Nov 25, 2015, 01:21 AM
Nov 2015

That 70's version is un-watchable, but a new version shouldn't be an over the top, CGI, action movie either.

 

aidbo

(2,328 posts)
15. I'm still waiting for any book by Neal Stephenson to be made into a movie.
Wed Nov 25, 2015, 01:30 AM
Nov 2015

But would hope the first be Snow Crash.

Initech

(100,080 posts)
16. Chuck Palahnuik's "Survivor"
Wed Nov 25, 2015, 01:50 AM
Nov 2015

That book kicked ass, and after Fight Club found cult success on DVD, people were clamoring for it to be made into a movie, but now there's nothing that's ever been said about it. I wish I knew how to write scripts, I'd totally create a script for it.

 

alphafemale

(18,497 posts)
28. Houlden Caulfield is every self-absorbed young teen that thinks themselves all-knowing
Fri Nov 27, 2015, 04:01 PM
Nov 2015

Capturing that mentality was brilliant in a way.

If a person keeps that mentality to adulthood they would be what we would call a sociopath.

sarge43

(28,941 posts)
18. Still waiting for "The Stars, My Destination"
Wed Nov 25, 2015, 08:55 AM
Nov 2015

If done right (big if), it could stand along side 2001.

Paladin

(28,264 posts)
19. I'd love to see Jonathan Franzen's "The Corrections" as a movie.
Wed Nov 25, 2015, 08:56 AM
Nov 2015

But only if---and this is a helluva big "if"---it was done right.

malthaussen

(17,202 posts)
21. How about one that should *not* be made into a movie:
Thu Nov 26, 2015, 01:30 PM
Nov 2015
The Moon is a Harsh Mistress. Can you imaging what Hollywood would do to that book?

-- Mal

Paladin

(28,264 posts)
22. Heinlein's libertarianism on screen? Yeah, I'd skip that one, for sure.
Thu Nov 26, 2015, 01:58 PM
Nov 2015

True confessions time: I'm a big fan of the original movie version of "Starship Troopers." Gotta love any movie that puts Neil Patrick Harris in a black SS uniform......

hunter

(38,317 posts)
26. That's an amazing movie, on the surface all popcorn over-the-top sci-fi, underneath sly satire.
Fri Nov 27, 2015, 02:48 PM
Nov 2015

I thought I'd hate it, (Roger Ebert thought it was shallow) so I avoided it for a few years, but things like Neil Patrick Harris in a black SS uniform, yeah, you gotta love that.

IDemo

(16,926 posts)
34. It would definitely need a tech update
Sat Nov 28, 2015, 10:54 AM
Nov 2015

The tellers of the Bank of the Moon would likely not have to rely on abacuses (abacusi?) in the event of a central computer failure.

mentalsolstice

(4,461 posts)
23. I agree about "The Corrections"
Thu Nov 26, 2015, 07:33 PM
Nov 2015

From what I understand it has been attempted, but never got off the ground. It would have to be done right, and with the best cast. It's perhaps better suited as a mini-series, rather than a 2 hour major move. Netflix, are you hearing me?

OrwellwasRight

(5,170 posts)
25. Player Piano by Kurt Vonnegut
Fri Nov 27, 2015, 11:27 AM
Nov 2015

Update the technology and it is a perfect commentary on our economy, which doesn't seem to want or need average people to be involved at all. And it could be the first adaptation of Vonnegut that didn't suck.

skippercollector

(206 posts)
33. my answer is different
Sat Nov 28, 2015, 10:39 AM
Nov 2015

As usual, my answer is different.
The Diamond in the Window, by Jane Langton.
This is a children's novel originally published in 1962. It's still in print.
I first read it in fourth grade in 1970. It was the first fantasy novel I'd ever read. I was always checking it out at the library and as an adult I bought my own copy.
It's about a boy and girl who learn about an aunt and uncle who disappeared when they were children. The protagonists receive clues in a series of dreams as to where they might have gone.
I've been wondering for 45 years why this was never made into a movie!

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Novels not made into movi...