Latin America
Related: About this forumCompare and Contrast: Human Rights Watch on Mexico and Ecuador
Compare and Contrast: Human Rights Watch on Mexico and Ecuador
By: Joe Emersberger
HRW statements about Ecuadors policing are out of proportion compared to their statements about the disappeared students in Mexico.
The following two headlines are from news releases by Human Rights Watch (HRW) about two incidents that took place in September:
1) Mexico: Delays, Cover-Up Mar Atrocities Response
2) Ecuador: Police Rampage at Protests
The headlines suggest very similar events are described, but thats not the case at all.
In Mexico, police fired on student protesters, killing three, and then disappeared 43 others by handing them over to a gang. Those basic facts are not disputed by anyone. In Ecuador, the allegations are vastly less serious and far more contested. There were no deaths, but police are accused of beating protesters, some of whom HRW concedes were violent.
Mexico is a close US ally, so HRW instinctively pulled its punches with the national government, which HRW accuses of actions that only mar i.e. impair the quality of its response to the atrocity. But the governments failure to produce the missing students (alive or dead) over a month after their arrest does not simply mar the response. It has raised reasonable suspicions that the entire Mexican establishment is complicit in the crime. As Spanish singer-songwriter Joan Manuel Serrat put it, They need to demonstrate that they are not accomplices of this barbarism, and of other barbaric acts the country has been enduring; this is a great opportunity for Peña Nieto to show it. The atrocity has sparked protests all over Mexico and a great deal of international attention.
Ecuadors left wing government, under Rafael Correa, is a member of ALBA, an alliance of left of center governments that includes, among others, Venezuela and Cuba. HRWs statement about the much less serious allegations against Ecuadors police was four times longer than the statement about disappeared students in Mexico, who, according to state-directed gang members admissions, were killed and incinerated. HRW officials rushed to Ecuador in September, immediately after the protests, to carry out a fact-finding mission. In addition to describing claims made by several alleged victims, HRW accused Correas government of harassing the private media in ways that foster impunity for police brutality. HRWs evidence for this last allegation is very weak. For example, a private TV station was obliged to broadcast a seven-minute government rebuttal to a show about the protests that had aired the previous day.
HRWs statement about the atrocities in Mexico, in contrast, says absolutely nothing about the governments media policies. Even a very lengthy report (from last year) that HRW cited in their statement said nothing about the Mexican media. However, HRWs 2014 World Report summary for Mexico does, very briefly, list some facts that show why the media is an important part of Mexicos human rights disaster: At least 85 journalists were killed between 2000 and August 2013, and 20 more were disappeared between 2005 and April 2013
. HRW said that Journalists are often driven to self-censorship by attacks carried out both by government officials and by criminal groups, while under-regulation of state advertising can also limit media freedom by giving the government disproportionate financial influence over media outlets.
More:
http://www.telesurtv.net/english/opinion/Compare-and-Contrast-Human-Rights-Watch-on-Mexico-and-Ecuador-20141124-0046.html