Israel/Palestine
Related: About this forumMax Blumenthal's 'Goliath' Is Anti-Israel Book That Makes Even Anti-Zionists Blush
Theres an unpleasant little debate sloshing around the Web lately that tells you all you need to know and perhaps more than you want to hear about the current state of relations between Israel and the left....
...The hottest debate, though, isnt over the book itself. Its about a magazine column devoted to the book. It appeared October 16 in the left-wing weekly The Nation, whose publishing arm put the book out. Its by Eric Alterman, the magazines sharp-tongued media columnist. Its title: The I Hate Israel Handbook.
A prolific author, academic and liberal pundit, Alterman is regarded as a chronic Israel-basher by the Israel-right-or-wrong crowd, while devoted Israel-bashers call him a member of the Israel lobby. He stipulates that Israels brutal occupation inflicts daily humiliations on the Palestinians, but says Blumenthal proves a profoundly unreliable narrator. The book, he writes, shows selectivity toward truth. Its chapter titles are juvenile, its accounts often deliberately deceptive.
Alterman elaborated the next day in a blog post. Thats when things heated up. He said the magazine had asked him to write about Goliath, but hed hesitated, wary of the avalanche of personal invective that comes whenever he writes about BDS types, meaning those engaged in the Boycott, Divest, and Sanctions campaign against Israel. He finally decided to proceed, wanting to be a team player.
Then the book arrived. I expected to disagree with its analysis, he wrote. I did not expect it to be remotely as awful as it is
. It is no exaggeration to say that this book could have been published by the Hamas Book-of-the-Month Club (if it existed).
The left-wing blogosphere erupted. Alterman was called an ignoramus, a smearmeister and, repeatedly, a liberal Zionist. One blogger, writing at the anti-Zionist group blog Mondoweiss.net, where Blumenthal is a regular contributor, questioned Altermans right to call himself a critic of Israel, since he sometimes defends it. Another, also at Mondoweiss, questioned The Nations judgment for assigning the review to a liberal Zionist known for impassioned devotion to Israel.
Read more: http://forward.com/articles/186557/max-blumenthals-goliath-is-anti-israel-book-that-m/?p=all#ixzz2juwMHC00
shira
(30,109 posts)Blumenthals writings and videos are extremely valuable in the study of Jewish extremism, as he is not shy about using his Jewish name and looks to gain access to Jewish extremists in order to document the ugliest side of Zionism
as it pertains to Israel.
http://blogs.jpost.com/content/cheering-new-%E2%80%98i-hate-israel-handbook%E2%80%99