Cooking & Baking
Related: About this forumHow electric stoves are poised to dethrone the mighty gas range
Link to tweet
Professional and home cooks are embracing induction cooktops as a more sustainable and healthy alternative to gas.
How electric stoves are poised to dethrone the mighty gas range
By Meg St-Esprit McKivigan
February 17, 2022 at 7:00 a.m. EST
Tanuj Deora works in the energy industry specifically to decarbonize energy systems. Thats the technical term for efforts to reduce the reliance on fossil fuels. Its a vast and complex problem, but Deora and his family try to do their part. At their home in Northwest Washington, they have solar panels, LED lightbulbs and a hybrid minivan. In the kitchen, though, the issue of fossil fuel usage was more personal. Their natural gas cooktop was making Deora sick. ... I would get a headache whenever the gas was running, he says, so he started looking into replacing their gas stove.
But first, he had to sell his wife, Amy, on the idea. The two of them love to cook and make meals from scratch most nights. Amy believed that gas cooking was superior in performance. When they remodeled their kitchen in 2021, though, she agreed to try an induction stove. Five months later, they have no regrets. This cooktop isnt just adequate for cooking its better than the gas stove was, Deora says.
Gas cooktops do have some advantages. With gas, you can control the flame, and its easy to get the temperature you need, which has made it a preferred choice for those who consider themselves to be serious cooks. An estimated 90 percent of professional chefs still use gas.
Is it really that much better, though? The fossil fuel industry wants you to think so. Since the 1930s, it has targeted consumers with well-placed ads. It embraced the term natural gas to increase consumer confidence in indoor combustion. It even created a catchy rap in the 1980s, all in an effort to increase gas usage. The industry also flooded the market with images of massive gas ranges as the keystone of aspirational kitchens. But as new data emerges about health concerns, and as more Americans rethink their use of fossil fuels, the mighty gas stove might be facing dethronement.
[Gas stoves in kitchens pose a risk to public health and the planet, research finds]
{snip}
Meg St-Esprit McKivigan is a freelance writer in Pittsburgh.
hlthe2b
(102,283 posts)shows and blogs, I suspected it to be short-lived given the toxic byproducts in an enclosed home environment from burning gas. I'd bet a lot of people are feeling really regretful--especially those with kids.
I really don't care what the most elite of the culinary world thinks is the only way to cook. Sometimes practicality wins out. This is one such instance.
hippywife
(22,767 posts)Throughout my 50+ years of cooking and baking, I've used both. I wouldn't give you a plugged nickel for an electric range.
hlthe2b
(102,283 posts)I grew up with gas stoves. You can get used to induction or electric stoves. It really is not that difficult and far safer. You want to sear with gas? Get a good gas grill and cook outside. Much safer.
hippywife
(22,767 posts)in all the years I've been cooking and baking with gas, which has amounted to most of those years. I only ever had electric when I was in my 20s and renting so had no choice.
MANative
(4,112 posts)And decided to go with induction for our cooktop and convection ovens. Precision control, excellent results, and better safety. (My husband occasionally forgets to shut off burners and if the pot is removed, the element turns off automatically in less than a minute.) The energy efficiency was a big plus in our decision. A big pot of water boils in less than two minutes. It was also a great excuse to buy all new pots and pans.
Gas had its benefits but we're happy with the switch.
mahatmakanejeeves
(57,464 posts)MANative
(4,112 posts)With Hestan Cue. Not the least expensive version, but impressive results. I had two private cooking lessons with one of their chefs and that's what he used.
HUAJIAO
(2,386 posts)reason for me to detest my electric stove.(No gas available where I live.)
Try cooking Chinese dishes on an electric stove some time.
multigraincracker
(32,685 posts)I really like gas on the top.
Solution might be hydrogen gas.
HUAJIAO
(2,386 posts)multigraincracker
(32,685 posts)Id think that could be solved. For me a small 20 lb thank could last for a long time. No indoor pollution.
Chainfire
(17,542 posts)That doesn't mean that I would reject the gas as fuel in my home or auto. What I wonder, is how much of the hydrogen gas being produced in the United states starts as natural gas or coal.
Chainfire
(17,542 posts)Since that time I have eliminated all of the gas appliances with the exception of the oven. I like cooking with gas. And, by the way, where I live, the electricity is produced by burning natural gas, so swapping is no environmental advantage... When I built my home, a good part of our electricity came from burning coal in a plant a few miles away. That plant has now switched to natural gas.
I live in a hurricane prone area. The last time we were out of electricity for two weeks, it was nice to still be able to cook and heat water to bathe in on the gas range.
hlthe2b
(102,283 posts)I think it almost blew up my house with a leak in the basement not far from the gas flame water heater.
Never again, thank you. Gas central heat and water and fireplace I'll risk, but the rest is electric/induction. I have a great OUTDOOR gas grill if the need arises. Even big enough for a wok for the person upstream mentioning the difficulties sans gas.
Chainfire
(17,542 posts)I have a lot of respect for fuel gasses, but I am not the least bit afraid of them. You just can't let fuel gas free to run around the house unsupervised.
hlthe2b
(102,283 posts)incidents with that particular dryer over a decade, including one house fire. So, you might not be afraid of gas-- and I feel comfortable lighting my own pilot lights and inspecting my remaining gas water heater/fireplace starter/heater-- but I'm sure as hell not nonchalant about them. And yes, gas fumes are toxic so I'll stick with an electric stove and a gas barbeque OUTDOORS.
Kali
(55,011 posts)that runs through the property. I guess we will switch to electric when the NG line becomes defunct. this house is so drafty I am not worried about toxins. LOL
I would love to be self sufficient and "off the grid" but I know what kind of $$$ and work that involves, I know many other ranchers that HAVE to live that way. My Grandparents and GreatGrandparents worked hard to bring these conveniences (that urban areas long enjoyed) to their rural communities.
Chainfire
(17,542 posts)Kali
(55,011 posts)but I don't have an account number, it is just called "_____'s Tap"
AndyS
(14,559 posts)Temp control is so precise and absolutely repeatable. I can bring a pot to heat quickly because modern electric uses a combination of radiant heat and conduction. The cooking area glows red transmitting infrared heat directly to the pan and maintains it with conduction If I need to cool the pan quickly I simply slide it to the side and the conduction goes the other way cooling the pan faster than just turning the gas lower.
I've had an induction cook top in the past and long for it again but that particular MFG went belly up and I replaced it with a ceramic top--not as good as glass. Induction is soooo cool both in the way it works (with the right pans) and in the fact that no heat is lost to the atmosphere.
Gas will boil water faster and that's the only difference.
Gas is, for me, way over rated. YMMV