Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

hotellanai1986

(119 posts)
Wed Mar 6, 2024, 05:07 PM Mar 6

Just Completed "Dinosaurs at the Dinner Party" by Edward Dolnick

Let's face it, most historical accounts possess the same soporific qualities as an elderly professor's droning lecture. Edward Dolnick however, in his work "Dinosaurs at the Dinner Party," proves a delightful exception. This historical adventure dives into the fascinating era of early paleontology, when Victorians stumbled upon evidence of a world so fantastical, it defied their carefully constructed worldview.

Dolnick's prose is a captivating blend of scientific rigor and delightful wit. The tales of eccentric (and at times egotistical) paleontologists such as Mary Anning, William Buckland, and Richard Owen are not merely informative, but immensely entertaining. One might easily envision this trio as characters in a particularly quirky costume drama; Anning, a woman defying social expectations with her sharp eye for fossils, and the flamboyantly zealous Buckland, whose gastronomic experiments on the animal kingdom are almost as unsettling as the strange creatures his science reveals.

What truly excels in this work is Dolnick's ability to convey the profound ripple effects these discoveries sent through the bedrock of Victorian society. The concept of extinction, of an Earth not meticulously designed for its current inhabitants, was both bewildering and unsettling. Yet, the sheer grandeur of these vanished prehistoric beasts ignited a flame of wonder, a sense that the planet's history stretched far beyond human comprehension.

Naturally, as with any scientific endeavor, the road is riddled with missteps and false leads—and Dolnick doesn't shy from these either. There's a subtle humor in witnessing once-revered scientists cling to theories that appear comically inaccurate from our vantage point. But this isn't mere mockery; it illuminates the very nature of scientific progress.

If you harbor any lingering notions of paleontology as a dry recitation of species names and geological strata, "Dinosaurs at the Dinner Party" will shatter them with gusto. This book is as much about the thrill of discovery as it is a testament to the human capacity for embracing a universe far more expansive and strange than ever imagined. I would highly recommend it to the discerning reader – although one word of caution: you might find yourself craving a roast iguanodon after turning the final page.

2 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Just Completed "Dinosaurs at the Dinner Party" by Edward Dolnick (Original Post) hotellanai1986 Mar 6 OP
I would love this! Blue Dawn Mar 6 #1
I'm finding that most modern historical writers NanaCat Mar 9 #2

NanaCat

(1,167 posts)
2. I'm finding that most modern historical writers
Sat Mar 9, 2024, 12:34 PM
Mar 9

Are not as dry as historians of old. They're finding new and more engaging ways to get the history across, without making it feel like a lecture.

Barbara Tuchman, David McCullough, Lauren Hillenbrand, Ron Chernow, Erik Larson, David Gran, Jack Weatherford, Tracy Borman, Allison Weir (who's both a novelist and nonfiction writer), Jon Meacham, Taylor Branch--

All of these writers have changed how to write history now. They've sort of borrowed techniques from historical fiction and the true crime genre to make the history come alive. Some of them even slip in the odd bit of humour here and there. Or that's how the books I've read of late have presented history.

Maybe I've been lucky with my history reading, though.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Non-Fiction»Just Completed "Dinosaurs...