Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Silent3

(15,211 posts)
Fri May 4, 2012, 06:21 PM May 2012

When you lose weight, how primarily does the excess mass leave your body?

I've been looking online for an answer to this question, and the search itself has been interesting.

For one thing, a lot of people obviously don't understand the principle of conservation of mass, or if they do, they have a blind spot about applying it to the human body. It turns out that until some pioneering medical research was done in the 1800s by Wilbur Olin Atwater, even many scientists were inclined to think of the human body as something special and different to which the known laws of physics might not necessarily apply.

In discussion forums where this topic came up many people were happy to simply say that your excess weight is "burned away" or "turned into energy", as if saying that was enough to answer the question of how excess mass leaves your body. Once something is "burned" or "turned into energy", of course, it's mass doesn't just magically disappear.

(While it's true that mass can be converted into energy via the famous E = mc², for bodily chemical reactions the effect is insignificant -- unless perhaps you've had your intestines replaced by a small, portable nuclear reactor.)

The answer to my question apparently lies in a combination of biological processes like the citric acid cycle, AKA the Krebs cycle, which, along with a few other steps, means that the proteins, fats, and carbohydrates you consume are, one way or another, reduced to glucose, and then (at least in the aerobic part of your metabolism, which is the largest part of your metabolism) oxygen is combined with glucose, and carbon dioxide and water are produced.

Since the main byproducts of our metabolism are carbon dioxide and water, it would then follow that exhalation and urination and perhaps perspiration would be the primary ways stored fat leaves your body when consumed. When you consider that the oxygen component of the C0₂ and H₂0 isn't stored in your body fat, but obtained from the air as needed, and that hydrogen weighs much less than the carbon, the greatest mass is going to leave your body as C0₂, with the C part of that being what used to be your body fat.

It would follow that when you lose weight, you primarily exhale the weight away. It's odd to think of breathing away pounds!

I'd love to find a more thorough and more detailed accounting for how what goes into our bodies eventually comes out of our bodies, something that takes into account other waste products, the contributions of anaerobic metabolism, etc.

18 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
When you lose weight, how primarily does the excess mass leave your body? (Original Post) Silent3 May 2012 OP
for us gals it seems to leave our boobs first Skittles May 2012 #1
In my case, no HockeyMom May 2012 #5
Just think of it this way... Silent3 May 2012 #9
If it makes you feel any better... GaYellowDawg May 2012 #15
Toenail clippings. Scuba May 2012 #2
I always assumed thru poop? Cooley Hurd May 2012 #3
I thought it was through the liposuction tube??? Yavapai May 2012 #7
very interesting question! n/t grasswire May 2012 #4
Makes sense RobertEarl May 2012 #6
Very interesting. Speck Tater May 2012 #8
What made me think about this is some of the crazy diet claims... Silent3 May 2012 #13
So, if I tried breathing faster could I lose weight? Skinner May 2012 #10
LOL I was thinking the same thing !!!!!!!! Marrah_G May 2012 #11
technically, isn't breathing faster called aerobic exercise? provis99 May 2012 #12
CO2 in our breath, everything else in our urine. Odin2005 May 2012 #14
Makes sense Trees build themselves from the air. n/t Gore1FL May 2012 #16
Heat and motion would be my guess. moroni May 2012 #17
Body heat and bodily motion don't directly carry away any body mass Silent3 May 2012 #18
 

HockeyMom

(14,337 posts)
5. In my case, no
Fri May 4, 2012, 06:52 PM
May 2012

I am back down to my pre-menopausal, pre-pregnant weight of 100 lbs. in my 20s, yet I am up to a DD cup. Same band size but over 40 years from a C to a DD. Combination of breastfeeding and menopause. It never went away with the 10 lb. weight loss.

GaYellowDawg

(4,447 posts)
15. If it makes you feel any better...
Sat May 5, 2012, 02:54 PM
May 2012

For us guys who have been way overweight and trying to lose it, it leaves our boobs (and gut) last. That way, we get to maintain that delightful apple figure for way longer than we should have to.

 

RobertEarl

(13,685 posts)
6. Makes sense
Fri May 4, 2012, 07:06 PM
May 2012

I always wondered how it is that people gained so much weight?
They don't quit breathing.

 

Speck Tater

(10,618 posts)
8. Very interesting.
Fri May 4, 2012, 08:10 PM
May 2012

I've been trying to lose a few excess pounds myself, and I wondered about that, but never thought to try to figure it out. I just chalked it up to "one of life's great mysteries."

Silent3

(15,211 posts)
13. What made me think about this is some of the crazy diet claims...
Fri May 4, 2012, 08:55 PM
May 2012

...I see while standing in the supermarket checkout lines.

In order to believe some of those diet claims, you'd have to believe body mass just magically disappears from your body.

 

provis99

(13,062 posts)
12. technically, isn't breathing faster called aerobic exercise?
Fri May 4, 2012, 08:53 PM
May 2012

breath your way to a size 28 waist!

Odin2005

(53,521 posts)
14. CO2 in our breath, everything else in our urine.
Fri May 4, 2012, 09:13 PM
May 2012

When you metabolize carbs and fats they end up as CO2 you get rid of when you breath out. The nitrogen in proteins ends up in the urea in your urine.

Silent3

(15,211 posts)
18. Body heat and bodily motion don't directly carry away any body mass
Mon May 7, 2012, 02:57 PM
May 2012

Generating body heat and bodily motion can, of course, help you lose weight, but the weight doesn't just magically turn into or disappear into "heat and motion".

Burning food and stored body fat for energy, although it involves a very sophisticated chemical dance, in the end turns out to be very much like burning a log to produce heat. A burned log doesn't just vanish into "heat", it mostly turns into carbon dioxide and water vapor. If you carefully collect all of the ashes, all of gasses given off by the fire, all of the soot thrown into the air, and weigh it, it will all weigh just as much as the original log, save a probably immeasurably small loss of mass in accord with E=mc² (probably well under a picogram, to take a wild guess, definitely far, far less than even a single gram).

Loss of mass from the production of energy does not become significant until nuclear reactions are involved.

I said in my OP, "For one thing, a lot of people obviously don't understand the principle of conservation of mass, or if they do, they have a blind spot about applying it to the human body." Not to pick on you, but your guess appears to make you one of those people.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Science»When you lose weight, how...