Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: The Navy Says Those UFO Videos Are Real [View all]jayfish
(10,325 posts)105. Please don't tell me what I do or do not know or believe.
I have not ascribed anything to you or any motive. I'm just going to leave it at this.
The following is a transcript from an episode of "The Fighter Pilot Podcast featuring USN Commander David Fravor:
VA: Yeah, youre welcome. So, it was November of 2004. You and I and all of our air wing bubbas were on the USS Nimitz, off the coast of Mexico, south of San Diego. And we were doing what we call workups, which are just exercises at sea to prepare ourselves for deployment. Which ended up being the 2005 deployment that was chronicled in the PBS, Carrier special. And we are out flying on a beautiful day. We have the USS Princeton cruiser, operating with us as an air intercept, control provider. Or, air defense commander, I suppose, you would call it. And so, you launch on a mission and just, if you would, give us a quick summary of what happened that day that then blew up on you earlier this year and caused so much attention from the press.
DF: Okay, so, 2004, were in one of the early gos. I think we were actually the first go. Were gonna do an air defense exercise. Not only were gonna get training cause were gonna be the good guys. The Marines are gonna take off. Theyre gonna be the bad guys. And were gonna actually work with the controllers on the Princeton to do the air defense of the carrier battle group.
VA: Okay, so its a 2 v 2, out over the ocean
DF: Yep. So we launch. We join up. Were in, obviously VFA-41. Were flying Fs. So I have a wizzo (WSO or Weapon Systems Officer ~Joe) in my back seat. And the other pilot and the other wizzo are in the other jet. So they join up were driving out. We hear a little comm on the radio as were checking through all you know going through strike, getting all checked in. And all of a sudden, the Princeton comes up and says, Fast Eagle. Hey, say your load out. (laughs) And I actually laughed. I said, Well I got a CATM-9, and with a sledgehammer, you can get it off the airplane. Cause you know how theyre locked on. Its just a big its a hollow tube. Its no real motor but it does have a real seeker head and its for training only. And they said, Well, were gonna cancel the air defense exercise training right now, we have real world tasking. And we were to proceed to about forty miles south of the carrier. So you were right on, so if you draw if you look at a map and go from San Diego down to Ensenada, were kind of working around that area. Closer to Ensenada than San Diego.
So, we start pressing out and they give us a vector of 270, at about sixty miles. So we start driving out towards the west. Im the lead, so my wingman, the other airplane, gets on my lefthand side. So theyre sitting to the south. So, Ill start referencing a clock cause it makes it easier to go. So as we start driving out, you know, theyre calling forty miles, thirty miles, twenty miles, ten miles Were not seeing anything on the radar. Were both clean, which means we see nothing. Then, all of a sudden, the cruiser calls Merge Plot, which tells us that now, the blip that they were looking at, and us, are in the same resolution cell. So it just looks like one blob. They cant tell us apart.
VA: Youre in the same vertical column of air.
DF: Thats exactly right. So as were looking out, you know, the heads start coming out cause were looking to see where this thing is at. And as we look down off the right side of the airplane, we see so wed be at the six oclock position of a clock and this object would be in the middle. We look down and what it looks like is something like a sea mount under the water. Because its a no whitecaps, beautiful clear day and theres just this white water. And if youve seen a sea mount which I know you have where the waves come in, they just break over this, in the middle of the ocean. And it tells you theres probably something under the surface. We kind of see this and as were looking, the back-seater in the other airplane, Jim Slaight Clean, goes, Hey skipper, do you And right about when he gets to the do you, Im looking and I see this little white object. Its kind of randomly moving around the disturbance under the water.
Now its important the disturbance, think of it as what we first thought is you know, it looked kind of like a 737 size-wise, pointing to the east. Alright? So it looked like it had kind of wings, you know like shapes like a cross. It was the way the disturbance was set up. And the little, white Tic Tac is what we referred to it as because thats what it looked like was kind of going north, south and then east, west. But it wasnt changing its direction. It was elongated to the north/south. So the longitudinal axis of this thing was pointing north.
So the first thing you think is, oh, its a helicopter, right? So as were looking at it and he goes, Hey, do you see, what the And I go, Yeah, what the hell is that? And were looking.
VA: Whats your altitude at this point?
DF: Uh, were at about 20,000 feet. So were looking down. Theres no rotor wash. Theres no wings. It literally looks like a Tic Tac and its just flopping around, right? So were like, thats kind of weird. So as we remove around towards about the nine oclock position, I decide, Hey, Im going to go check that out. (both laugh).
VA: Of course.
DF: So the other pilot says, Hey, Im gonna stay up high. I said, Thats perfect. Just stay up here. Just mirror us and Ill go down. So were having all this comms. And Im also talking on the intercom to my back-seater. And were both, you know, kind of like, Dude, what is that? And we have no idea. So, at about the nine oclock position we start that slow descent and as we get around to the twelve oclock and were watching this. So this whole evolutions gonna take about five minutes because were only dong around 300 knots. (345 mph ~Joe) Were just kind of saving gas. So we get to about the twelve oclock position and the thing, which had been pointing north/south, basically just turns. So now the longitudinal axis is kind of pointing to the west. And it starts mirroring us. So were in a slow descent, clockwise flow and its coming up the same way. So this things been in a hover, right over the water, with no rotor wash or nothing and then all of a sudden, it goes BOOP, and starts climbing.
So were kind of looking at it and we go around, you know all the way around. So as we approach about that six to eight oclock position actually, were at six and you know, we can watch it, its coming up below us. At about the eight oclock position were at eight oclock and its over towards about two oclock theres probably about, maybe about 3000 feet of altitude between us. So, were probably at about, you know, somewhere around the fifteen-ish thousand and then hes probably around the thing is probably around that eleven/twelve thousand, somewhere around there. So I go, Well, the best way to fix it a two- circle, fight so hes on the opposite side of the circle is cut across the middle of the circle. So I go, nose low, and cut across the circle and pull lead on it. So I, finally at the eight oclock think of it as, I point my nose down Im gonna cut across the bottom. Im gonna make a big scoop out out of the bottom of it. Im going kind of over towards three oclock cause I wanna kind of be over there when he gets there. And as we start pulling nose up, the thing rapidly accelerates like from, just this nice, easy, kind of mirroring our speed to poof, its gone as it crosses our nose. It just disappears.
So were like I go I ask the other airplane, Hey you guys see that? And theyre like, Its gone. Now keep in mind, theyre still above us. So its not like, you know we have different perspectives of the object. And the object, we both see it just take off and disappear. So were like, (laughs) alright, now Im pretty weirded out. So I said, Hey, lets turn around and see what was in the water. Cause were right there. So we basically just turned the airplanes around real quick and theres nothing. Theres no disturbance, theres no whitewater as far as you can see, theres nothing. So we kind of turn and Im like, Well, you know, look at the clock but we gotta get some training done. And, I told my back-seater I said, Dude, Im pretty weirded out. Thats thats odd. So and the controllers hearing all of this, so. I remember telling the controller, I said, Hey, please tell me that you guys are gonna strip the radar tapes. And throughout this, hes been telling us, Hey sir, weve been tracking these things for like two weeks, since we got out here.
VA: Really?
DF: We got here in the beginning of the month. Remember, we got out in the beginning of November. It was a two-month at sea. Remember I was fighting to get home for Thanksgiving?
VA: Yeah.
DF: So, he says, Yeah, weve been tracking these things. Theyve been coming from, basically 80,000 feet or above 80,000 feet, coming straight down and hanging out at like 20,000 feet. And they had been tracking like, up to, you know multiple. You know, I think it was like up to ten. And then they would hang out for a little bit and then they would go back up. And this was the first time that they had had manned airplanes, airborne when these things showed up. Which was, you know, it happens to be us. You know, I dont know if thats lucky or unlucky (both laugh). But, my life would have been just fine if this never happened.
DF: No. This is where it gets At first we thought okay this is, this is kind of odd. Weve got something that we have we cant control. We cant for the performance of it. You know, anything that hovers like that, doesnt not accelerate like you know. And youve seen you know, Ive seen airplanes doing 1.8 going by me doing the high fast like at Top Gun where guys are, you know, you just see the CONS coming. But to see something that literally accelerates. Cause even if you go to Mach II (approximately 1500 mph ~Joe) Think of a rocket that takes off. You watch it and those things accelerate relatively quick but you can watch them for a significant period of time. This thing literally disappeared in a matter of you know, less than a second. It was in front of me and it was gone.
DF: You know, my opinion and its not just my opinion Lue, who did the ran the Pentagon program. Him and I have talked extensively about this. Its just theres an aura in the United States that when you see something like this. You know, normally the dude on TV thats talking about, Hey, I just saw a UFO, he lives out in the middle of nowhere. Immediately, people discredit him. Hes alcoholic. Or, hes kind of crazy. Or, this or that. So theres always this perception that its better just to make fun of it. Because if its not real or we just ignore it, then it will just go away and its not a big deal. And I think now theres a point of cause you dont know where its from. I dont know if it was from China or Russia. And I always joke because, you know, right after we had that workup, I think it was Acani (?) who was out there working up when the sub surfaced in the wake and the whole world was like it was a big deal. And I said, I guess maybe if the Tic Tac would have had like a symbol from a foreign country on it and we saw it, then it would have gotten paid more serious attention then.
Theres a technology there that we cant do much about. Because these things were coming for two weeks at will. And even if you go what were they doing? Monitoring? Watching? Observing? Prepping the battlefield? You know? You dont know what they were doing. But if you look at it and go man for two weeks these things were showing up. They were coming from areas that we cant do and then all of a sudden, theyre disappearing. You might wanna spend a little time to go, God, what is that? What performance would it cost you to be able to do that? I mean were happy right now that Space X can land a rocket motor back on a pad. Well if you had that technology that we saw, it would make everything like that obsolete. It would make almost every propulsion mechanism we have, obsolete.
VA: So, based on that, in your gut, where do you think this thing came from?
DF: I dont think it honestly, I dont believe the technology was developed here. And I mean like
VA: Earth?
DF: on this planet. Im not I dont wanna I dont like to talk about aliens cause I dont know what it was. You dont even know what maybe it was unmanned. I dont know. Because theres also the theories that it accelerated so fast that a normal human, you know, a body
VA: Fluids.
DF: couldnt sustain the force. But, I just dont I dont think I think, honestly if we had that technology, especially now that its been fourteen years since it happened honestly if we had that technology in the last fourteen years, something would have leaked out. To hide that for that long, when it could benefit so many people, you know. Or maybe it wouldnt? You know? I dont know. But if you assume that theyve got some new revolutionary propulsion that works by manipulating gravity, per say, then, I would like to think that thats a game-changer for mankind.
You don't have to believe me but don't be a dick about it.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
167 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Why? They may be exploring for new planets to take over and use . Some natives have welcomed
lunasun
Sep 2019
#53
Nah. They are just here to pick up a few Subs and chips. They don't drink our soda-pop. nt
Blue_true
Sep 2019
#56
We are a species with amnesia of the deep past, sky gods are a racial memory of our creators
Baclava
Sep 2019
#107
No heat signature, no exhaust trail, no wings, no fins. Unidentified indeed.
Midnight Writer
Sep 2019
#43
If aliens chose to be seen knowing that we can do nothing to them and they can
Blue_true
Sep 2019
#91
An open and curious mind requires objective evidence and data to form a valid hypothesis.
LanternWaste
Sep 2019
#45
All I will say is that until you see one, then anything esle anybody has to say on the matter ...
SWBTATTReg
Sep 2019
#28
An Advanced AI In An Advanced Aircraft That Can Defeat A Top Gun Pilot It Has Never Encountered?
jayfish
Sep 2019
#142
I will agree with you when the space shuttle can launch and immediately stop and hover.
Blue_true
Sep 2019
#114
We don't have anything that can go from 25,000 mph to hovering instantly. nt
Blue_true
Sep 2019
#118
Look, you are not going to convince me, nor I you. Let's leave it at that. nt
Blue_true
Sep 2019
#122
There's a Slow Motion Disclosure Going On! Election 2016, Slowed it a bit more...
MartyTheGreek
Sep 2019
#42
I completely agree that the Speed of Light barrier and distance make us alone forever...
Moostache
Sep 2019
#54
The early thought on the G being the highest obtainable is spread throughout early
Blue_true
Sep 2019
#72
It is always possible to posit something unknown, and clearly that is intrinsically non-refutable...
Moostache
Sep 2019
#74
You make a good point. Something unknown is by it's nature difficult to prove
Blue_true
Sep 2019
#95
"The Navy is pointedly not saying the objects are flying saucers or otherwise controlled by aliens."
Iggo
Sep 2019
#70