General Discussion

moondust

(19,956 posts)

37. Banning symbols helped.

Tue Dec 1, 2020, 10:29 AM

Dec 2020

Illegally displaying Nazi symbols in Germany can be punished by three years in jail. The ban broadly exempts art, but which works are allowed to show swastikas, SS sig runes and such is often more a matter of the medium.
~
Germany's confusing rules on swastikas and Nazi symbols

Banning Confederate symbols in the U.S. after the Civil War might have prevented some of the ongoing divisions leading to current radicalization, but I don't know who would have enforced a ban across the large land area that was the Confederate South. Allied troops occupied Germany for decades after WWII and could have quelled any rekindling of Nazism.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

39 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

How did the U.S. reform cult-like, Fascist nations Japan and Germany after WWII? [View all] Yavin4 Nov 2020 OP

Please reframe your q - cilla4progress Nov 2020 #1

... jpak Nov 2020 #2

I changed it. Yavin4 Nov 2020 #3

Yes - got it. cilla4progress Nov 2020 #16

Novice answer... NCDem47 Nov 2020 #4

By imposing military dictatorships Klaralven Nov 2020 #5

We gave them constitutions that are a lot better than ours. WhiskeyGrinder Nov 2020 #6

More specifically, through a deliberate program of Denazification zonemaster Nov 2020 #7

Both nations emerged with constitutions lacking some of the flaws ours has. hunter Nov 2020 #8

+1 n/t theaocp Dec 2020 #34

not a historian RazzleCat Nov 2020 #9

Plus in Germany Dem4Life1102 Nov 2020 #11

Hardly anyone was marched through the concentration camps. Mariana Nov 2020 #15

Essentially, bribes. apnu Nov 2020 #24

Unconditional surrender, money, and executions greenjar_01 Nov 2020 #10

Unconditional surrender followed by occupation and imposition Hortensis Nov 2020 #12

The US didn't reform Germany. Germany reformed Germany. Japan is a completely different culture. Nitram Nov 2020 #13

Agree LeftInTX Nov 2020 #23

Germany rewrote their constitution displacedtexan Nov 2020 #29

Yes. betsuni Dec 2020 #39

The first step was smacking down the former leadership. Chainfire Nov 2020 #14

The Nazis rose because a group of disgruntled Germans LeftInTX Nov 2020 #26

The ONLY good thimg I will say about Hitler is that, dware Nov 2020 #27

Bad history, Left inTX. France punished Germany so severely for WWI that they suffered severe Nitram Dec 2020 #30

Roughly 3% Of GDP! ProfessorGAC Dec 2020 #35

That is a good point Chainfire Dec 2020 #38

step one: hang a bunch of vile m'fers. Voltaire2 Nov 2020 #17

Would it be helpful to also look at cilla4progress Nov 2020 #18

Through the powers of dictatorship. David__77 Nov 2020 #19

Bombed their cities into smithereens and seized power with the military MichMan Nov 2020 #20

In my fevor dreams, I want Biden to send an occupying force to Florida. n/t Yavin4 Nov 2020 #21

First step will be to sarisataka Nov 2020 #22

This could work in South Carolina. Yavin4 Nov 2020 #28

That's been tried (and failed) on numerous occasions over many centuries. I'm assuming your Nitram Dec 2020 #31

Our main purpose in those countries was to stabilize the region LeftInTX Nov 2020 #25

Good points. Our motive was primarily self interest, but it did help the beneficiaries rise above Nitram Dec 2020 #32

We shot a good number of the cultists before the rebuilding began... Volaris Dec 2020 #33

First, we stopped their propaganda broadcasts and publishing doubleplusgood Dec 2020 #36

Banning symbols helped. moondust Dec 2020 #37