Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

PurgedVoter

(2,721 posts)
2. Seperate the work from the writer.
Tue Jun 20, 2023, 07:37 AM
Jun 2023

There are a lot of great reasons to separate the work from the maker of the work. For one thing a writer's subconscious might help them write wisdom their conscious mind is having trouble grasping. Another reason is that art, even great art can be created by horrible, horrible people. Bill Cosby, Michael Jackson, Isaak Asimov, and a lot of others have given us insight and joy, while being less than they should have been or even monsters.
If you want to avoid their making a profit or their estate making a profit, then fine. This may be a good thing. But throwing out Harry Potter with an author who has internal demons, doesn't really help the world.
Niven was a joy, but he always felt a bit on the conservative side. Qanon has shown us how easily twisted the conservative mindset can be. To quote John Greenleaf Whittier, from his poem Icabod, "The tempter has a snare for all, and pitying tears not scorn and wrath befit his fall." https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/45486/ichabod By the way, Ichabod was written by an abolitionist in response to Daniel Webster, a hero of the abolition movement, voting for the Fugitive Slave Bill. https://owlcation.com/humanities/Ichabod-A-poem-on-the-Fugitive-Slave-Bill

Great men with great works have often had issues within those works. Mark Twain's Huckleberry Finn has suffered at times because it was sensitive to racial issues and at other times because it was not sensitive enough.

So while I still love the book, "Protector." I cringe at what foolishness Niven has fallen too. Especially on the issue stated. Truth is, that human health and failings in health care effect us all. If we think letting one person among us go without medical care and train them to fear it, we weaken us all. The anti-VAX people make us all less healthy. A person with a communicable disease that is avoiding or being denied care because of fear, oppression, poverty or politics, makes us all more likely to get sick. Niven is so insanely wrong. But then his ideas on Nuclear Safety have always been cray cray and without compassion.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Uninsured and underinsured white folks? JT45242 Jun 2023 #1
+1 n/t area51 Jun 2023 #20
Seperate the work from the writer. PurgedVoter Jun 2023 #2
A recent disappointment John Ludi Jun 2023 #4
A lot of people lost their minds when/since Obama was elected TwilightZone Jun 2023 #5
I guess the disconcerting thing John Ludi Jun 2023 #7
Agreed. TwilightZone Jun 2023 #9
Although I also enjoyed his earlier music robbob Jun 2023 #6
There was always that John Ludi Jun 2023 #8
Niven was an adviser to Reagan on the Strategic Defense Initiative, better known as "Star Wars" TwilightZone Jun 2023 #3
that guy who wrote the book with a race of non-sentient females? BlueWaveNeverEnd Jun 2023 #10
Yes melm00se Jun 2023 #16
ok... i didn't read that far into the book.. BlueWaveNeverEnd Jun 2023 #23
I knew. ismnotwasm Jun 2023 #11
Orson Scott Card Deep State Witch Jun 2023 #14
Oops--sorry! I better correct that ismnotwasm Jun 2023 #18
Orson Scott Card... hunter Jun 2023 #19
Never liked him. Seemed too impressed with himself. eppur_se_muova Jun 2023 #12
Pournelle was no prize either. hunter Jun 2023 #13
Larry collaborated with Jerry Pournelle for decades, and while I highplainsdem Jun 2023 #15
thank you for the additional (and troubling) information Celerity Jun 2023 #17
Speaking from my own youthful experiences... hunter Jun 2023 #22
I don't know the specifics of what happened, but... Rob H. Jun 2023 #21
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Disillusioned - Larry Niv...»Reply #2