Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

In reply to the discussion: An EV in Every Garage [View all]

Caribbeans

(1,303 posts)
25. Lots of people at TeslaMotorsClub would like to know why their battery didn't last 15-20 years
Tue Sep 5, 2023, 11:07 PM
Sep 2023
Batteries last 15-20 years, longer than most cars.


The engine in most cars built since around 1990 lasts 3-400,000 miles or more, if properly maintained - regardless of the length of time it takes for that vehicle to travel 3-400k miles.

A battery starts dying the instant it comes off the assembly line. Battery degradation is subject to both cycles and time.

This isn't discussed much because companies like Tesla don't want to talk about it. And they damn sure don't want the public talking about it.

Here's a Tesla Owners forum searched for "HV Battery replacement" (HV=High Voltage, the 12v battery goes dead and must be replaced after 1-2 years)

https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/search/7476134/?q=HV+Battery+replacement&o=relevance

Current costs to replace a Tesla HV battery are ~$15,000 remanufactured (junk with a limited warranty) and ~$23,000 for a new one. And no you don't get to keep the dead one. Also, as of a few years ago, recycling of these dead batteries costs ~$3,000 PER BATTERY. Lots of people think they will just hook it up to their house (but they will have to pay core charges!) and turn the dead battery into a house backup system. The problem is that most home insurance companies will either not allow that or insist that that dead battery be inspected and certified. Since these batteries weigh around 1200 pounds it's not like you can throw it into the back of a pickup and cart it off to the inspector.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

An EV in Every Garage [View all] LiberaBlueDem Sep 2023 OP
great idea, but gay texan Sep 2023 #1
EVs are going to replace ICE vehicles liberal N proud Sep 2023 #2
That's not the only hurdle. Angleae Sep 2023 #5
I rented an EV last month, chargers are everywhere liberal N proud Sep 2023 #23
Batteries last 15-20 years, longer than most cars. Meadowoak Sep 2023 #7
They do canetoad Sep 2023 #9
Theoretically maybe madville Sep 2023 #16
Lots of people at TeslaMotorsClub would like to know why their battery didn't last 15-20 years Caribbeans Sep 2023 #25
That is a limiting factor Zeitghost Sep 2023 #26
It wouldn't be a fancy car LiberaBlueDem Sep 2023 #3
I'm retired, and that would be perfect for me. Meadowoak Sep 2023 #10
Many, many people could live their lives with a golf cart... Wounded Bear Sep 2023 #13
We have an electric golf cart Bettie Sep 2023 #21
Retirees and students Zeitghost Sep 2023 #27
I think a EV makes sense for a second car pwb Sep 2023 #4
Title is required House of Roberts Sep 2023 #6
In due time there will be chargers all across the US. LiberaBlueDem Sep 2023 #8
How about rebuilding our cities so that car ownership is unnecessary? hunter Sep 2023 #11
Sounds all ForgedCrank Sep 2023 #12
Sort of a "People's Car"? nt sl8 Sep 2023 #14
$10K in the US will basically get you a golf cart. tinrobot Sep 2023 #15
Ours is a used electric one Bettie Sep 2023 #22
Those are golf cart prices madville Sep 2023 #17
None of the houses on my block have a garage... brooklynite Sep 2023 #18
How about setting and enforcing an average 35 mpg standard for all ICE vehicles? roamer65 Sep 2023 #19
What about people without a garage? madville Sep 2023 #20
The Chinese already have cheap EVs flamingdem Sep 2023 #24
EVs are the future LiberaBlueDem Sep 2023 #28
There is a limited market for EVs LiberaBlueDem Sep 2023 #29
Purchased my first computer the summer of '84 for just under $2500 Torchlight Sep 2023 #30
Public transportation would be better investment. Voltaire2 Sep 2023 #31
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»An EV in Every Garage»Reply #25