General Discussion

John Shaft

(357 posts)

10. One is too many . . .

Reply to ExciteBike66 (Original post)

Mon May 13, 2024, 09:42 AM

May 13

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

86 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

UN says only 7000 kids have been bombed in gaza... [View all] ExciteBike66 May 13 OP

"Only" no_hypocrisy May 13 #1

Yep, ExciteBike66 May 13 #7

Hope you'll be careful. Crunchy Frog May 13 #18

"Only" does not explicitly carry any judgements or minimizations Bad Thoughts May 13 #24

Beat me to it. marble falls May 13 #27

Tempted to get sarcastic. SarahD May 13 #33

Some surviving with a lifetime of pain and scars. LakeArenal May 13 #51

And disease, epidemics caused by bad sanitation. AloeVera May 13 #59

That is the number that they were able to identify by age. Think. Again. May 13 #2

And who knows how many Bettie May 13 #13

Excellent point... Think. Again. May 13 #44

The Hamas Government Media Office and Palestinian Civil Defense reported that number to the UN. lapucelle May 13 #47

Yes, that is the number the UN is reporting. Think. Again. May 13 #49

It is the number that Hamas is reporting. UN/OCHA transcribes, posts, and disclaims. N/T lapucelle May 13 #50

Yes, the UN is reporting those numbers. Think. Again. May 13 #52

Yes, the UN relays the Hamas numbers with a disclaimer that they are unverified. lapucelle May 13 #63

Don't confuse those buried under rubble ... AloeVera May 13 #58

I see, thank you... Think. Again. May 13 #60

Agree with your last sentence. AloeVera May 13 #62

One is too many malaise May 13 #3

Bingo. marble falls May 13 #28

On THAT Mossfern May 13 #38

It's horrible. I'm very grateful that Biden is president. yardwork May 13 #4

True about hamas ExciteBike66 May 13 #12

I'm not happy about it, either. yardwork May 13 #14

Do not all sides in all wars make the claim of righteousness and justice? Torchlight May 13 #37

Bombing kids is not a good strategy for either side ExciteBike66 May 13 #53

Nor does the focus on one at the expense of the other grant favors. Torchlight May 13 #54

If people can get you engaged in an argument about exact figures, they can RockRaven May 13 #5

I'm not to concerned about the report as such ExciteBike66 May 13 #9

Exacly as Malaise said, one is too many. marble falls May 13 #29

Yup, don't buy into the spin of JP reporter. AloeVera May 13 #36

It's a bad thing. Beastly Boy May 13 #6

Why would i give two ***** about whether or not the UN is 100% right in their numbers ExciteBike66 May 13 #8

If your purpose was not to legitimize UN numbers that they get from Hamas, why bring them up? Beastly Boy May 13 #20

Why are you so upset about ilovegamers43 May 13 #35

I believe you directed this post to me in error. Beastly Boy May 13 #39

Historically the Deaths Hamas reports are correct. Eko May 13 #56

According to your link, 13,000 of the reported deaths were not reported through ministry data. lapucelle May 13 #65

and the rest Eko May 13 #66

Your post touted the past reliability of Gaza Ministry of Health numbers, lapucelle May 13 #67

Of course they were reported by the ministry. Eko May 13 #69

Yes, I know who he is. lapucelle May 13 #70

Ok. Eko May 13 #71

OCHA might think the Gaza Media Office is wrong as well. lapucelle May 13 #73

From may 3rd to may 8th the numbers went up. Eko May 13 #74

Like I said in my post, the UN is no longer using the Gaza Media Office lapucelle May 14 #83

Ok. Eko May 14 #86

One is too many . . . John Shaft May 13 #10

I recall when it was reported 44 babies were beheaded sarisataka May 13 #11

Sure, just like some folks seem satisfied that the UN was wrong. ExciteBike66 May 13 #17

We are in agreement sarisataka May 13 #21

Why did Hamas start this war? Happy Hoosier May 13 #15

So Israel could nuke gaza and it would be hamas's fault, no blame at all for Israel? ExciteBike66 May 13 #19

Why are you putting words in to my mouth? Happy Hoosier May 13 #25

What do you think happened after 911? We invaded Afghanistan and Iraq. We were attacked. Israel was attacked. Demsrule86 May 13 #42

Oops! I think you made a little slip.. SarahD May 14 #82

I know that but it was tied to 9-11. We all know there were other reasons. And I don't disagree that it was wrong. Demsrule86 May 14 #84

I agree it was tied to 911. SarahD May 14 #85

Why did Netenyahu spend decades helping to prop up Hamas? Crunchy Frog May 13 #23

Because he's a right wing nut who wants to perpetuate conflict. Happy Hoosier May 13 #26

Not giving Hamas a pass, but it seems that both sides are responsible for "starting" the war, Crunchy Frog May 13 #32

Netanyahu displayed hubris and negligence LeftInTX May 13 #48

I'm not blaming Bibi alone, I'm suggesting that Crunchy Frog May 13 #57

For political points by bragging "I've got Hamas tamped down so re-elect me!" marble falls May 13 #30

How does the UN know? Have they counted the mass graves, those buried under rubble? brush May 13 #16

I think they follow similar protocols in their counting of deaths in Ukraine. Crunchy Frog May 13 #22

They are not. Beastly Boy May 13 #40

Hamas reports the numbers to the UN, lapucelle May 13 #46

The UN publishes Ukraine casualty reports through its agency, the Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine (HRMMU) lapucelle May 13 #64

The truth is that it's pretty much impossible Crunchy Frog May 13 #75

So Hamas makes up numbers, and you take them as gospel AZSkiffyGeek May 13 #31

Please, I certainly didn't say that. I asked how does the UN know? brush May 13 #45

As long as they can't show their math none died? One dead Gazan child is too many. One dead Israeli child is too many. marble falls May 13 #34

Palestinian children are in the line of fire because Hamas attacked Israel. I don't think Israel right either. Demsrule86 May 13 #41

Children in every war die Darwins_Retriever May 13 #43

Not like this. AloeVera May 13 #61

How many children were killed in Mariupol? Crunchy Frog May 13 #78

Not suggesting that. AloeVera May 13 #79

Of course even one is too many, but then why respond? elias7 May 13 #55

"ONLY seven thousand children bombed"..... DemocraticPatriot May 13 #68

The unofficial DU number is 10 times that. BannonsLiver May 13 #72

That straw dog won't hunt LuvLoogie May 14 #81

There is a lot of convoluted thinking involved Aussie105 May 13 #76

Only 7000. Well that's so much more comforting. AllyCat May 13 #77

One child on either side is too many. lees1975 May 13 #80