Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

jmbar2

(5,813 posts)
Thu Jun 27, 2024, 01:51 PM Jun 27

Pete Buttigeig demonstrates how to handle the "Gish gallop" right wing talkover [View all]

Pete is known for his strong debate skills. Those skills are well-displayed in how he handles the Gish galllop talkover from Scott Perry.

For those unfamiliar with the term

The Gish gallop (/ˈɡɪʃ ˈɡæləp/) is a rhetorical technique in which a person in a debate attempts to overwhelm their opponent by providing an excessive number of arguments with no regard for the accuracy or strength of those arguments.

British journalist Mehdi Hasan suggests using these three steps to beat the Gish gallop:[7]

--Because there are too many falsehoods to address, it is wise to choose one as an example. Choose the weakest, dumbest, most ludicrous argument that your opponent has presented and tear this argument to shreds (also known as the weak point rebuttal).

--Do not budge from the issue. Don't move on until you have decisively destroyed the nonsense and clearly made your point.

-- Call it out: name the strategy. "This is a strategy called the 'Gish Gallop'. Do not be fooled by the flood of nonsense you have just heard."


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop#:~:text=The%20Gish%20gallop%20(%2Fˈɡ,or%20strength%20of%20those%20arguments.

Pete does it exceptionally well in this interaction with Scott Perry.

40 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
He's good! I hope Biden channels Pete ALBliberal Jun 27 #1
He's WONDERFUL! elleng Jun 27 #2
I love him. Think. Again. Jun 27 #3
He is tremendous... hlthe2b Jun 27 #4
He would make a wonderful POTUS. Diamond_Dog Jun 27 #5
I was just thinking that! CTyankee Jun 27 #19
Absolutely! ShazzieB Jun 27 #25
Absolutely. dalton99a Jun 27 #29
K&R Blue Owl Jun 27 #6
He is so good... Mike Nelson Jun 27 #7
The Gish talkover is such a rightwing staple, I hope more people will learn to counter it. jmbar2 Jun 27 #8
Beautiful. yonder Jun 27 #9
Fox News probably edited it so it looks like Perry gets the last word and wins the exchange. TheRickles Jun 27 #23
Pete is an absolute master communicator Jilly_in_VA Jun 27 #10
Insisting on the facts is key. oasis Jun 27 #11
Indeed... jmbar2 Jun 27 #12
Yet another reason I would be unfit for such an office: I'd out-yell the RWNJ or leave. Hermit-The-Prog Jun 27 #13
Facts have a liberal bias Warpy Jun 27 #14
Touche! Well played, Mr. Buttigeig, as usual. Timeflyer Jun 27 #15
"Since time is limited I'm just going to comment on your errors" is basic HS debate Prairie Gates Jun 27 #16
Hey, Scottie... rubbersole Jun 27 #17
You heard it first here. multigraincracker Jun 27 #18
As he is not a MI native (he recently moved there) Governor is a tougher hill to climb than a Senate run. Celerity Jun 27 #34
Good points, I'm mostly wishful thinking. multigraincracker Jun 27 #36
Bravo, Secretary Buttigeig! CrispyQ Jun 27 #20
Perry must have needed a thousand stitches after that slicing n dicing. NoMoreRepugs Jun 27 #21
Pete for prez! brakester Jun 27 #22
"I would imagine most people are aware of that" hibbing Jun 27 #24
This is SO SATIFYING!!! LAS14 Jun 27 #26
If so much of this country... appmanga Jun 27 #27
Well said. Escurumbele Jun 27 #32
Kick dalton99a Jun 27 #28
Leagues apart malaise Jun 27 #30
I bet they think they are going to grab Pete by the throat with their wise questions and discussions to find out their Escurumbele Jun 27 #31
Is this the same Perry who is complicit in attempting the overthrow of the United States? AZ8theist Jun 27 #33
Giddy-up, Goober czarjak Jun 27 #35
Pete is a treasure. James48 Jun 28 #37
I love Pete - he is so incredibly smart and a decent person. nt TBF Jun 28 #38
I would vote for Pete Buttigieg for President pinkstarburst Jun 28 #39
Secretary Pete is so smooth, and trying to argue just about anything... 3catwoman3 Jun 28 #40
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Pete Buttigeig demonstrat...