Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Jarqui

(10,521 posts)
24. That's not a good or fair thing
Thu Aug 8, 2024, 09:01 AM
Aug 2024

It is too broad brushed

There are different layers of competency.

One common split is between an individual's ability to manage their property and their ability to make decisions relating to personal care. When they cannot do one of those things, they might appoint (or appoint in the event their ability changes) a power of attorney to fulfil that role for them.

There is a different (arguably lower) level of competency for a person's ability to sign a will or name a power of attorney.

I'm not sure what the answer is as I haven't given it broad thought. But I can say this much having been down this road with PoA and guardianship with family and friends: to disqualify a person from voting merely because they have some sort of guardianship is WAY wrong. I have known Alzheimer's victims who, for example, adored Obama for 90-95% of their illness - towards the end, they were out of it. But before then, even when they were were child-like, we helped them get their vote cast - it was important to them. In caring for them, you fight for them to retain as much dignity as you reasonably can.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I don't see anything wrong with your post. TurboDem Aug 2024 #1
If I were to hazard a guess melm00se Aug 2024 #8
But that's an important point arlyellowdog Aug 2024 #15
Unfortunately, if someone has a legal guardian, they are declared "legally incompetent" and thus LisaL Aug 2024 #2
It doesn't have to be that way arlyellowdog Aug 2024 #16
It depends on the state I think geardaddy Aug 2024 #23
That's not a good or fair thing Jarqui Aug 2024 #24
This is not true in Ohio. Ms. Toad Aug 2024 #40
State specific, according to this; in CA, ME, MD, NV, NM, and WA, right to vote is retained by default lostnfound Aug 2024 #53
Hugs to you. AllyCat Aug 2024 #3
Thank you for posting this. We had to get a guardianship on my MIL MaryMagdaline Aug 2024 #4
That option doesn't exist in our county. LisaL Aug 2024 #5
I'm so sorry. MaryMagdaline Aug 2024 #9
I recall my most contentious PoliSci class from college nuxvomica Aug 2024 #6
Exactly. MaryMagdaline Aug 2024 #10
Virginia is the same AverageOldGuy Aug 2024 #7
Why focus on empathy from Democrats specifically? live love laugh Aug 2024 #11
There's even a word for that mahina Aug 2024 #13
That doesn't answer a valid question. I'm asking about something needed from EVERYONE. live love laugh Aug 2024 #17
Very valid question. wordstroken Aug 2024 #20
I am avoiding your question because I wanted to bring light to the issue arlyellowdog Aug 2024 #26
You're implying that Democrats don't have empathy. Why? live love laugh Aug 2024 #34
You're trying to get me in trouble arlyellowdog Aug 2024 #37
It's an unusual conversation, and memorable. mahina Aug 2024 #38
And still you don't answer why. live love laugh Aug 2024 #41
Because of a DU post mocking disabled people arlyellowdog Aug 2024 #42
How would anyone know whether compassion is or if is not asked elsewhere? mahina Aug 2024 #36
That's not part of this conversation. This is about what's posted here. live love laugh Aug 2024 #44
It's directly responding to you asking why empathy isn't being asked of others mahina Aug 2024 #45
Ad hominems are indicative of an inability to argue. live love laugh Aug 2024 #48
Please specify what I said that was an ad hominem attack. mahina Aug 2024 #49
Non sequitur mahina Aug 2024 #50
Because we know that the 'r's" demonstrate that they are not capable niyad Aug 2024 #22
Exactly. In addition if all of Democratic Party members don't fully support the right to vote, how can one expect others Wonder Why Aug 2024 #25
Who said Democrats don't support the right to vote? live love laugh Aug 2024 #32
Your statement suggested it: Wonder Why Aug 2024 #35
What??? "If no Democrats did not support it, then why was it brought up?" live love laugh Aug 2024 #43
They are incapable but that doesn't mean we aren't capable. So why call us out on this? live love laugh Aug 2024 #33
When I put an alert on a post making fun of "mentally disabled" people arlyellowdog Aug 2024 #39
Thank you for sharing your fight for your son's rights. Fla Dem Aug 2024 #12
In New Jersey Rocknation Aug 2024 #14
Same thing happened with our son hauckeye Aug 2024 #18
It just kills your soul doesn't it? arlyellowdog Aug 2024 #28
We are guardians for our granddaughter (autistic) Scalded Nun Aug 2024 #19
Do the laws in your state prohibit him from voting? Ms. Toad Aug 2024 #21
So are you saying by entering a group home, he lost his right to vote? Bev54 Aug 2024 #27
To clarify: we petitioned the court for guardianship arlyellowdog Aug 2024 #29
OK so the act of gaining guardianship was the trigger. My sister got guardianship of my brother when my Bev54 Aug 2024 #30
I'm very sorry about that. My daughter is developmentally disabled, although not intellectually disabled...but since deurbano Aug 2024 #31
I can see on one level why people who can't take care of their own affairs dsc Aug 2024 #46
It must be separate. No one else has to prove they can vote arlyellowdog Aug 2024 #51
I'm so sorry! Bluesaph Aug 2024 #47
Have you tried contacting your Rep or Senator? nt. druidity33 Aug 2024 #52
What state are you in? There's some good information in these two documents lostnfound Aug 2024 #54
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»My 47 year old son lost t...»Reply #24