Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

jmowreader

(51,113 posts)
Sat Aug 10, 2024, 09:58 PM Aug 10

What Vance is hoping you don't know: CSM Walz COULDN'T have deployed in the first place [View all]

Let's talk about the Military Physical Profile Serial System for a minute.

The military likes quick and easy ways to describe things, and one of the things they need to describe is a troop's physical condition. To this they have developed a six-channel system they call PULHES.

P = overall Physical condition
U = Upper body - everything from the waist to the top of the head
L = Lower body - everything from the waist to the floor
H = Hearing and ears, including the organs controlling balance that are found there
E = Eyes and vision
S = pSychiatric and mental health

For each channel, there are ratings from 1, completely fit for duty, to 4, so limiting that you really need to be studied by the Medical Evaluation Board to see if you can even be in the Army at all. These profiles can be permanent or temporary; a soldier who breaks her arm while doing her missions will receive a temporary 3 in the U channel, and when it heals she'll go back to having a 1 there. Most troops join the military with all 1s unless they need glasses, and then they receive a P2 in the Eyes channel. My own PULHES was 111121. Since the Army issues glasses - ones so ugly the troops call them "birth control glasses" but glasses nonetheless - they don't see having a P2 for Eyes as a huge problem. However, it WILL keep you from being accepted as a pilot, something I really wanted to do during my time in service. (This is what they'd give Trump these days: "S-4. Diagnosis or treatment results in high to extremely high risk to the military or patient due to potential impairment of duty function, risk to the mission or ability to maintain security clearance and which has already undergone an MEB (Medical Evaluation Board).&quot

Tim Walz served as an artilleryman. Artillery soldiers use weapons like howitzers and multiple rocket launchers, which are extremely loud when fired - and when they're fired you don't shoot once, you shoot as many times as you have to in order to kill all the enemy. Lots of cannoneers carry P3 and P4 profiles for Hearing, and that group includes CSM Walz. From what I've seen online he was so incredibly deaf they had to perform a surgery to replace the three small bones in his ears that transmit sound from the eardrum to the auditory nerve with 3-d printed ones to fix his ears. If you have this kind of operation the Army isn't going to let you in the same grid square as a firing battery. They'd probably be hesitant about even letting you go to the motor pool on Monday morning to check the oil in your howitzer's engine.

Now...here's the thing. Any P3 or P4 in your PULHES profile renders you non-deployable. If you can't hear, see or walk you can't fight wars. Even if he would have known about the deployment and stayed in because of it..."sorry sarge, you're deaf as a post, you're going to stay home."

TL R fuck JD Vance and fuck all his enablers.

61 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Thank you for an interesting and illuminating post, jmow!! Leghorn21 Aug 10 #1
That is a 3auld6phart Aug 11 #42
You are saying Walz is "deaf as a post"? former9thward Aug 10 #2
To the Army having a P3 for hearing is just as good as "deaf as a post" jmowreader Aug 10 #3
Didn't know Rebl2 Aug 11 #46
In the British Army "flat feet" definitely did disqualify you. mwooldri Aug 11 #54
Its really a moot point. He had already announced for Congress. oldsoftie Aug 11 #39
That is because that was not the reason for him not deploying, he had already made the decision to retire and Bev54 Aug 11 #55
I doubt he had that hearing loss. former9thward Aug 11 #56
He has hearing loss and that was known and public before all this bullshit came out. Bev54 Aug 11 #57
Everyone his age has hearing loss. former9thward Aug 11 #58
Do some research before you make these statements. He had an operation for it in 2005 Bev54 Aug 11 #59
Everyone is posting statements without links. former9thward Aug 11 #60
Maybe you should do your own research and not rely on others. He retired in 2005, so his age now Bev54 Aug 11 #61
Thank you for this info. It's very interesting. My only question is, where is this information available liberalla Aug 10 #4
It's best to go straight to the source jmowreader Aug 10 #5
Thank you for the link but I wasn't aware of his hearing difficulties, and liberalla Aug 10 #8
This is why I like du NJCher Aug 11 #20
My husband only started to read DU after he realized how many times I knew about stories before he did. CrispyQ Aug 11 #26
That's how my wife, son, and his wife became lurkers on DU! Hermit-The-Prog Aug 11 #31
Thank you! evolves Aug 10 #6
His rank is Sergeant Major iemanja Aug 10 #7
There are two sergeant major ranks in the Army jmowreader Aug 11 #21
The campaign says they were mistaken when they initially called him command sergeant major iemanja Aug 11 #25
Thank you! Really interesting information! electric_blue68 Aug 10 #9
The 3 bones are the malleus, incus... 3catwoman3 Aug 11 #17
Ty electric_blue68 Aug 11 #28
or more generic-hammer, anvil and stirrup et tu Aug 11 #41
You can get knee replacements using 3D printed knee parts oldsoftie Aug 11 #40
The other part of this is grumpyduck Aug 10 #10
Your colorful characterization has me... 3catwoman3 Aug 11 #19
Your colorful language has got me thinking ... willamette Aug 11 #34
Tell us how you really feel about Weido Jr. sarge43 Aug 11 #49
Thanks for the post, lots I didn't know. CanonRay Aug 10 #11
My dad was a WW-2 arty officer .. Bo Zarts Aug 10 #12
It was an absurd stupid remark by a dimwit being fed Klarkashton Aug 11 #13
that's "pudgy weird beard with black eyeliner." That's so fun! CTyankee Aug 11 #29
Yeah, but did he have bonespurs? Orrex Aug 11 #14
The Donald had to have Pearl Harbor explained to him. czarjak Aug 11 #15
Thank you canetoad Aug 11 #16
Very informative. Thanks. 3catwoman3 Aug 11 #18
That and people that high up in rank Zoomie1986 Aug 11 #22
On a more serious note Zoomie1986 Aug 11 #23
Before adding this, for clarity I'm outraged by this attack on Walz Jarqui Aug 11 #24
My Dad was allowed to enlist in the Navy during WWII, but was required to do daily exercise to strengthen his Martin68 Aug 11 #33
Thank you for this useful information Wild blueberry Aug 11 #27
I saw a video right before he was chosen as VP MsLeopard Aug 11 #30
He mentioned being able to finally hear his daughter Hope ''wake up singing every morning'' ... Donkees Aug 11 #51
That's the video! MsLeopard Aug 11 #52
"Hope wakes up singing every morning" is also a powerful message Donkees Aug 11 #53
Thanks for the information. This should be more widely disseminated. Martin68 Aug 11 #32
HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!! Charmin One Aug 11 #35
The gop is up to the same old tricks again. I'm sure they have some boring old thing planned for Oct. C Moon Aug 11 #36
Working flight lines and flight decks is another way troops lose their hearing sarge43 Aug 11 #37
Signals intelligence soldiers are usually also stone deaf jmowreader Aug 11 #48
Something fishy here jujubeets Aug 11 #38
you're being sarcastic? NJCher Aug 11 #43
Weird, eh. twodogsbarking Aug 11 #45
When you have hearing loss your brain will try to figure out what you did not hear twodogsbarking Aug 11 #44
Rec! I also heard Pelosi today say Walz stayed extra because of 9/11. Nixie Aug 11 #47
My brother in law was artillery in the NG Javaman Aug 11 #50
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»What Vance is hoping you ...