Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)Martial Law is coming. Here is a likely playbook of what happens next [View all]
https://www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/openforum/article/trump-insurrection-act-april-20-20269810.php On Jan. 20, Trump issued an executive order tasking the secretaries of the Department of Defense and Department of Homeland Security to submit a joint report, within 90 days, recommending whether to invoke the Insurrection Act. The deadline for that report is April 20.
He also replaced the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs with a CPAC-darling who endeared himself to Trump by wearing a MAGA hat. And he fired the Judge Advocate Generals for the Army, Navy and Air Force the top uniformed lawyers responsible for reviewing the orders from the commander-in-chief and defense secretary to determine whether theyre legal. Trumps defense secretary explained this action was taken preemptively to prevent the JAGs from blocking orders that are given by a commander in chief. Clearing the way, among other things, for the White House to begin consolidating federal law enforcement under military leadership. The Secretary of the Army, for example, in a move consistent with preparing for martial law, was just placed in charge of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF), with surprisingly little push back.
Lets be clear what this adds up to: The man who promised to declare martial law on day one has wasted no time taking actions designed to subvert the military to meet this end.
Yet despite Trumps fondness for blasting through norms, there is one norm upon which his apparent plan, and political survival, depends: the military recognizing him as their commander-in-chief and obeying his orders.
That norm is no more carved in stone than any other.
He also replaced the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs with a CPAC-darling who endeared himself to Trump by wearing a MAGA hat. And he fired the Judge Advocate Generals for the Army, Navy and Air Force the top uniformed lawyers responsible for reviewing the orders from the commander-in-chief and defense secretary to determine whether theyre legal. Trumps defense secretary explained this action was taken preemptively to prevent the JAGs from blocking orders that are given by a commander in chief. Clearing the way, among other things, for the White House to begin consolidating federal law enforcement under military leadership. The Secretary of the Army, for example, in a move consistent with preparing for martial law, was just placed in charge of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF), with surprisingly little push back.
Lets be clear what this adds up to: The man who promised to declare martial law on day one has wasted no time taking actions designed to subvert the military to meet this end.
Yet despite Trumps fondness for blasting through norms, there is one norm upon which his apparent plan, and political survival, depends: the military recognizing him as their commander-in-chief and obeying his orders.
That norm is no more carved in stone than any other.
More at the link but essentially, once Trump issues an order to use the military against the civilian population or any other illegal order, the military, as coded into military law, can remove any executive, including the President, who would violate the Constitution. Ultimately, declaring Martial Law may backfire on Trump. Our only hope, if he does, is that the Military removes him.
85 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Martial Law is coming. Here is a likely playbook of what happens next [View all]
Mr.WeRP
Apr 2025
OP
Coincidentally, the next national rally against this criminal regime is Saturday, April 19th
OMGWTF
Apr 2025
#42
"...the military...can remove any executive, including the President, who would violate the Constitution."
LudwigPastorius
Apr 2025
#2
The Commander in Chief is not a member of the military and is not bound by military law.
LudwigPastorius
Apr 2025
#6
You are right of course. Not that it will deter the fear mongers spreading misinformation
onenote
Apr 2025
#10
According to the article, once he declares Martial Law, he becomes a member of the military, as does his 2nd in command
Native
Apr 2025
#46
I don't know? The corrupt SCOTUS 6's ruling giving him immunity for 'official acts'...
brush
Apr 2025
#62
Yes very sad so many federal officers are thrilled to act like Hitler's Gestapo.
Irish_Dem
Apr 2025
#9
So if he declares that the military is in charge of trash collection, that too is martial law?
onenote
Apr 2025
#22
And the supremes have to decide what martial law is. It is what they say it is.
LiberalArkie
Apr 2025
#58
I do not think anyone but Stephen Miller knows what will be done with Trumps signature
LiberalArkie
Apr 2025
#71
Politifact: Insurrection Act vs. martial law: What power applies to Trump's April 20 deadline
sl8
Apr 2025
#14
Yeah, paraphrasing, they basically said "... but it's Trump, so who knows what he'll try" nt
sl8
Apr 2025
#19
Thanks. Of course it won't satisfy the folks who claim otherwise, facts be damned.
onenote
Apr 2025
#23
"Legal experts said they don't see a clear path for Trump to lawfully implement martial law . . . "
AverageOldGuy
Apr 2025
#43
Do you think he will shut down civilian courts and replace them with military tribunals?
onenote
Apr 2025
#69
"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State..."
CaptainTruth
Apr 2025
#44
Maybe they figure the Democrats will not notice it, if the do it on international pot smoking day?
LiberalArkie
Apr 2025
#61