Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

In reply to the discussion: Enrolling in Medicare [View all]

W_HAMILTON

(10,449 posts)
28. I know what Medicare Advantage is and I would never recommend it to anyone.
Tue Oct 14, 2025, 03:37 PM
Oct 2025

I will admit that I don't know the ins and outs of how Medicare interplays with Medicaid, but even that doesn't sound quite right because if you qualify for Medicaid, usually Medicare is the primary payer with Medicaid being the second payer (rather than a Medigap plan, if you do not qualify for Medicaid) -- Medicare Advantage doesn't even have to come into the picture.

And, yes, all the benefits you list are straight out of a Medicare Advantage commercial, but what they don't tell you is you are at the whim of a for-profit insurance company that will very much act like one. Medicare Advantage is great -- until you get really sick, which you almost assuredly will at some point when you are aged 65+. Then a loved one will have to spend what could be their final weeks/months with you fighting with a private insurance company whose AI says it's time you get discharged home even though you just had a stroke less than three weeks ago and can no longer care for yourself. Then your loved one is thrust into the role of a unprepared and inexperienced 24/7 caregiver.

Moral of the story: as I said previously, seek out a local, reputable, and highly recommended Medicare broker to help you navigate through these things.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Enrolling in Medicare [View all] mwmisses4289 Oct 2025 OP
Not familiar with them, but don't trust them. W_HAMILTON Oct 2025 #1
Message auto-removed Name removed Oct 2025 #16
I know what Medicare Advantage is and I would never recommend it to anyone. W_HAMILTON Oct 2025 #28
Post removed Post removed Oct 2025 #30
My wife went through this a few months ago Shrek Oct 2025 #2
It's really not difficult. Don't pay anyone to help you. NewHendoLib Oct 2025 #3
One of my law partners introduced me to a member of our Temple who helped me LetMyPeopleVote Oct 2025 #4
Thank you for your replies. mwmisses4289 Oct 2025 #5
Call your local senior center & the Council on Aging SheltieLover Oct 2025 #6
THIS! bluestarone Oct 2025 #7
In Washington State, we have the volunteer RSVP program. cilla4progress Oct 2025 #8
Wish I still lived in Washington state, loved it and consider it home. mwmisses4289 Oct 2025 #12
oh no ! cilla4progress Oct 2025 #17
If you can, stay away from Advantage plans. Emile Oct 2025 #9
Not good advice. Sogo Oct 2025 #14
We buried my older brother in April because his Emile Oct 2025 #19
I'm so sorry for your loss. area51 Oct 2025 #45
Thank you Emile Oct 2025 #47
Supplemental plans have caps, as well, Ms. Toad Oct 2025 #20
Supplemental plans can have very expensive monthly premiums, and Sogo Oct 2025 #21
Less expensive than $9000+ in medical expenses every year. Ms. Toad Oct 2025 #22
When my 95-year-old mother died in 2010, she was paying $548 per month in supplemental insurance; that's $6576 annually. Sogo Oct 2025 #24
States have nothing to do with Medicare SickOfTheOnePct Oct 2025 #37
Yes, they do. Ms. Toad Oct 2025 #38
I'm talking about Medicare itself... SickOfTheOnePct Oct 2025 #39
You were responding to my post, which explicitly specified Medicare + Supplement. An Ms. Toad Oct 2025 #41
I was responding to this statement SickOfTheOnePct Oct 2025 #42
What do you think the parenthetical comment means? Ms. Toad Oct 2025 #43
My mom had a catastrophic medical condition (stroke). W_HAMILTON Oct 2025 #31
Advantage plans spend a ton of money on advertising and paid telephone calls LetMyPeopleVote Oct 2025 #34
+1. And an army of salespeople in every grocery store who get a commission and revenue stream from Advantage policies dalton99a Oct 2025 #48
Start your sign-up now Nigrum Cattus Oct 2025 #10
Just communicate directly with Medicare. The will give you all the information you need. enough Oct 2025 #11
That is what we did. murielm99 Oct 2025 #33
I did that last year. Has to enroll to keep my Tricare for life haele Oct 2025 #13
Medicare Choices and Medicareschool.com djtexas Oct 2025 #15
if you don't sign up for medicare part D at 65, you will be penalized Emile Oct 2025 #18
Yes, you have to be careful about that Shrek Oct 2025 #40
The state SHIP office is a good resource. Ms. Toad Oct 2025 #23
Just go get it from the source hunter Oct 2025 #25
I enrolled online Skittles Oct 2025 #26
My husband retired from his job that provided health care. kimbutgar Oct 2025 #27
Free Medicare Advice: Chapter 706-312-8635 Nictuku Oct 2025 #29
I can only speak to my experiance Wifes husband Oct 2025 #32
I don't know Rebl2 Oct 2025 #35
My doctor's office recommended a specific insurance agent & gave me a card BlueSpot Oct 2025 #36
There is no penalty for delaying enrollment in parts B and D, if ... JustABozoOnThisBus Oct 2025 #44
In Oregon, I went to an independent insurance agent MurrayDelph Oct 2025 #46
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Enrolling in Medicare»Reply #28