Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ForgedCrank

(3,101 posts)
9. I can
Fri Nov 21, 2025, 05:24 PM
Nov 2025

respect that especially since you achieved what most never do and that is remain civil with me even though we disagree, at least sort-of.
Like I mentioned, I don't disagree with any of the content of the video or it's message. I do disagree with them releasing it though, it's an appeal to people who see them as meddling politicians, regardless that they once served. Enlisted want no part of outsiders agitating their ecosystem, they take offense to being used like this. You already know since you were there before. Enlisted can sit in the lounge and argue about it all night amongst themselves, but opinions from politicians are quite unwelcome. In other words, I can fight my brother all day, but no one else better even think about laying a finger on him. They have enough people telling them what to do, especially on the critically taboo subject of considering disobeying a direct order from a superior. That is the road leading to hell and they need no reminders of that.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

knr UTUSN Nov 2025 #1
Kick MustLoveBeagles Nov 2025 #2
Here is the line crud Nov 2025 #3
I have ForgedCrank Nov 2025 #4
As a veteran (non-combat) liberalgunwilltravel Nov 2025 #5
I can ForgedCrank Nov 2025 #9
Disagree 100%. James48 Nov 2025 #6
So, you polled how this is being received in the enlisted ranks? maxrandb Nov 2025 #7
Twenty-two years active duty in the Navy. dsvajda Nov 2025 #15
Why didn't you slap him under Article 88? Grins Nov 2025 #16
You repeated ForgedCrank Nov 2025 #17
"Some guys say EVERYONE on the base" maxrandb Nov 2025 #19
Im relaying ForgedCrank Nov 2025 #22
We Are Way Past Worrying About Hurt Feelings MissouriDem47 Nov 2025 #11
Call me ForgedCrank Nov 2025 #18
I saw it the first Tuesday this November maxrandb Nov 2025 #21
I don't care about their "hurt feelings". NotHardly Nov 2025 #12
Seriously! If our current troops are getting "butt hurt" by this maxrandb Nov 2025 #28
What does the law say about legal and illegal? Iggo Nov 2025 #8
Gen Mark Hertling (ret) about illegal orders evilhime Nov 2025 #10
This law firm deal with a lot of military cases. AverageOldGuy Nov 2025 #13
Not only was this message correct, but it was well timed. patphil Nov 2025 #14
Soldiers aren't equipped to know the law. WarGamer Nov 2025 #20
Personality cultists really hate being reminded about any legal limits Warpy Nov 2025 #23
Illegal orders do not come with a big yellow sign. kiri Nov 2025 #24
Get real. upacreek Nov 2025 #25
Death sentence for stating a simple, lawful truth The Blue Flower Nov 2025 #26
Inductees need a class on the US Constitution Glass City Nov 2025 #27
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»What the military oath of...»Reply #9