Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

sarisataka

(22,598 posts)
15. Kharg Island is at the northern end of the Persian Gulf.
Fri Mar 13, 2026, 07:54 PM
10 hrs ago

And Amphib Group would have to pass the Strait and travel 300 miles through restricted waters to land on Kharg. Iran would throw everything they had at the ARG.

5k Marines is not enough to hold the coast around the Strait. AT best they could allow some traffic through for a few days, but would need massive reinforcement to keep control of the Strait

ETA> this administration might not care about those factors and do such attacks anyway. It wouldn't be the first time Marines were put in position to be sacrifices.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

They'll be sitting ducks on that island. RandySF 11 hrs ago #1
Exactly it seemed like that would be an insane move oldmanlynn 6 hrs ago #51
Nonsense. It does not pass the sniff test. drray23 11 hrs ago #2
Trump announced it Johnny2X2X 9 hrs ago #31
LOL Prairie Gates 11 hrs ago #3
We'll see. orangecrush 11 hrs ago #7
I think you guys answered your own questions. ABC123Easy 11 hrs ago #4
Kharg is far from Hormuz. JCMach1 11 hrs ago #6
Yes Celerity 5 hrs ago #54
I think orangecrush 11 hrs ago #9
That would makes sense except sarisataka 11 hrs ago #10
Turns out you are not that far off orangecrush 10 hrs ago #12
Yes, that graphic is very scary MorbidButterflyTat 6 hrs ago #49
JFC!!! electric_blue68 11 hrs ago #5
My reaction exactly orangecrush 11 hrs ago #8
Ridiculous conjecture sarisataka 10 hrs ago #11
Check out post 12 orangecrush 10 hrs ago #13
Kharg Island is at the northern end of the Persian Gulf. sarisataka 10 hrs ago #15
He's not saying Marines are going to Kharg orangecrush 10 hrs ago #19
". It wouldn't be the first time Marines were put in position to be sacrifices" orangecrush 9 hrs ago #24
My mind went to Guadalcanal but this works too Arazi 7 hrs ago #43
... orangecrush 7 hrs ago #44
The bigger the font used in a YouTube video ad the higher probablility of bullshit. WarGamer 10 hrs ago #14
Cappy is far from bullshit. orangecrush 10 hrs ago #16
I don't trust ANY analysis with political spin. WarGamer 10 hrs ago #18
Thanks for the link orangecrush 10 hrs ago #20
EXCELLENT source! orangecrush 10 hrs ago #22
you're welcome! WarGamer 9 hrs ago #32
Outstanding reference orangecrush 9 hrs ago #33
But on Call of Duty, that's not a problem. haele 10 hrs ago #17
This sure as fuck ain't COD orangecrush 10 hrs ago #21
This is not a game. Dan 9 hrs ago #23
That seems to be the consensus orangecrush 9 hrs ago #26
With Israel as a partner, the long range goal in Iran wnylib 9 hrs ago #25
Boots on the ground in a place where they have been planning on this... Hugin 9 hrs ago #27
A USMC MEU is a very formidable force. However, the Iranians are likely dug in as well as the Imperial Japanese were artemisia1 9 hrs ago #28
The commentator did say orangecrush 9 hrs ago #29
Yes. I should clarify that I meant a full division in addition to 5,000 MEU members. Even that won't do it, imho. artemisia1 8 hrs ago #35
Thanks orangecrush 8 hrs ago #38
Kharg rso 9 hrs ago #30
They already attacked it. LeftInTX 8 hrs ago #34
... orangecrush 8 hrs ago #37
I think he announced that he was gonna do it after it already happened. LeftInTX 8 hrs ago #40
Very likely orangecrush 8 hrs ago #41
I'm not an expert by any stretch but blue-wave 8 hrs ago #36
95% of Iranian oil flies though the island because orangecrush 8 hrs ago #39
OK, but if the strait is blue-wave 8 hrs ago #42
The Iranians from what I'm seeing orangecrush 7 hrs ago #45
And this... orangecrush 7 hrs ago #46
And the MAGAts go wild! UTUSN 7 hrs ago #47
I don't think Kharg is the target for the US... WarGamer 6 hrs ago #48
That looks ridiculous MorbidButterflyTat 6 hrs ago #50
Huge screw-up. GP6971 6 hrs ago #52
I fear for them. It's going to be raining drones. yourout 6 hrs ago #53
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Delta Force Prepares to C...»Reply #15