Seriously, no one is defending anyone, but no one is discussing that both sides agree civilian death (Reply #28)

In the discussion thread: CNN launches Argumentum ad hominem attack (argument directed at the person) at Hamas leader. [View all]

Response to Iamthetruth (Reply #26)

Tue Aug 5, 2014, 12:55 PM

Fred Sanders (23,946 posts)

28. Seriously, no one is defending anyone, but no one is discussing that both sides agree civilian death

is just the price of war and we should accept civilian deaths without remorse.

When did warfare become a contest to see how many innocents can be killed? When do the warriors become the ones who suffer the least? When did we accept that?

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

44 replies	Author	Time	Post
CNN launches Argumentum ad hominem attack (argument directed at the person) at Hamas leader. [View all]	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	OP
Lets see what Osama Hamdan has said over the past couple of years.	hack89	Aug 2014	#1
You posted the words I refused to....interesting.	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#2
Because you refuse to accept the implications of such words from such people	hack89	Aug 2014	#5
I think propaganda stinks, I have a good nose for stink. My burden.	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#6
Do you deny that Hamdan said what is in my post? nt	hack89	Aug 2014	#7
Indeed, Sir: Holding A Man To Account For His Previous Words Is Not Argumentm Ad Hominem	The Magistrate	Aug 2014	#13
Holding him up falsely as anyone of importance is not propaganda? Attacking the person to segue	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#15
Why Do You Insult Mr. Hamdan By Insisting He Is Un-Important, Sir?	The Magistrate	Aug 2014	#20
Did you really just compare	Iamthetruth	Aug 2014	#27
Have Some Coffee Before You Post, Sir	The Magistrate	Aug 2014	#31
With you there...	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#34
He is the Hamas representative in Lebanon, Hamas was elected government of Palestine.	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#32
Nice To See You Can Google, Sir, And That You Acknowledge The Man's Significance	The Magistrate	Aug 2014	#36
Like Sarah Palin and Ted Cruz? Snark in a Magistrate is not good form.	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#39
You Will Have Your Little Joke, Sir....	The Magistrate	Aug 2014	#41
I didn't see this morning's panel show but I saw the interview of Hamden by wolf yesterday	aint_no_life_nowhere	Aug 2014	#24
I just do not think the amplified hate of one not vital to the process man should hold up peace.	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#25
So DU has vapors when an obsure American blogger posts on the Times of Israel site	hack89	Aug 2014	#30
I doubt that peace will be held up as a result of a Wolf Blitzer interview	aint_no_life_nowhere	Aug 2014	#35
Then why amplify his voice? The whole piece had to be seen to put this in context, the context of	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#37
It is complex, I know. Takes a wee bit of study. For those that can keep pace:	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#3
Because nothing of the sort was directed at Netanyahu.	WinkyDink	Aug 2014	#4
.	MohRokTah	Aug 2014	#8
Clearly you missed the hack on The Cycle yesterday	malaise	Aug 2014	#9
Why do people not see through the obvious propaganda, malaise, why are people so intent on	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#10
Laziness and indifference	malaise	Aug 2014	#11
When children are killed, piled up like cordwood, they still remain lazy and indifferent..I may hurl	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#12
As long as it's not their children	malaise	Aug 2014	#14
That Was Not An Accident, Ma'am: That Was a Crime	The Magistrate	Aug 2014	#16
We know that	malaise	Aug 2014	#17
I Understand That, Ma'am	The Magistrate	Aug 2014	#21
You stated it very well Sir	malaise	Aug 2014	#22
This message was self-deleted by its author	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#18
Your words should be copied and put into the war crime indictment for this act of terror.	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#19
Correct Sir, and thank you for saying it.	bemildred	Aug 2014	#23
And In This Context, Sir 'Not Giving a Shit' Is Low Enough And then Some....	The Magistrate	Aug 2014	#38
Quite enough, on both sides, yes.	bemildred	Aug 2014	#40
Seriously	Iamthetruth	Aug 2014	#26
Seriously, no one is defending anyone, but no one is discussing that both sides agree civilian death	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#28
Hamas lover!	Capt. Obvious	Aug 2014	#33
You're defending not only Hamas but the age-old slander of the blood libel. You're sick. nt	Nuclear Unicorn	Aug 2014	#29
I guess it would be "fair and balanced" if they also had this woman on their show	arikara	Aug 2014	#42
I strongly disagree.	GeorgeGist	Aug 2014	#43
I liked how they brought out Dan Rather, complained about how they, CNN were ever so being	Fred Sanders	Aug 2014	#44

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.