Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

Archae

(46,363 posts)
Sat Jun 2, 2012, 02:53 PM Jun 2012

Why do I consider chiropractic to be quackery? [View all]

I went to a chiropractor years ago, and stopped when I got fed up with the guy constantly pushing vitamins and other supplements that he was selling.

He also did absolutely nothing for my headaches.

The entire premise behind chiropractic is faulty to begin with.

(From Wikipedia)

"Traditional chiropractic assumes that a vertebral subluxation interferes with the body's innate intelligence, a vitalistic notion ridiculed by the scientific and healthcare communities."

I'm looking at an ad, that was in our local giveaway newspaper, "The Shoreline Chronicle."

These are in the ad for a chiropractic workshop in Appleton:

"Discover how electro-magnetic fields can adversely affect you!"

"Learn the testing and nutrition necessary to achieve MAXIMUM HEALING!"

"Find out if your dental work is having an adverse effect on your health!"

"Discover the ancient healing of using mud packs to help detoxify your system!"

"Learn if emotions are slowing your healing process!"

"Find out why some nutritional products could actually make you worse instead of better!"

"Discover which SUPER FOODS you should be eating to help you heal!"

Pure, unadulterated bullshit. Quackery.

Oh I know, the chiropractic phanbois will jump all over me, with their testimonials.
Testimonials are worthless when it comes to medicines.
"I took sugar pills for my backaches and now I feel great!"

Chiropractic couldn't get medical certifications, so they went the political route.
And people die from these quacks.

126 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I agree and disagree.... ohheckyeah Jun 2012 #1
I tend to agree with you. Curmudgeoness Jun 2012 #2
Gee, I had a bad doctor that told me straight out that if I lived it would be in a wheelchair. Egalitarian Thug Jun 2012 #3
Wow, lame logic there! Logical Jun 2012 #30
Same process as in the OP. Egalitarian Thug Jun 2012 #50
No, the OP has lame logic, this person is just mocking it adigal Jun 2012 #92
No such thing as allopathic MattBaggins Jun 2012 #55
Merrriam Webster disagrees. And gave myself away? Egalitarian Thug Jun 2012 #58
Allopathic is a made up term whether or not you found it in Websters MattBaggins Jun 2012 #96
Uh huh. And would you care to list some words that were not made up? Egalitarian Thug Jun 2012 #99
A few points involved there MattBaggins Jun 2012 #102
As I said. stupid post. My doctor didn't "make a mistake", he saw a patient with means Egalitarian Thug Jun 2012 #106
Chiroprators are better trained if you believe the data they put out. MattBaggins Jun 2012 #122
Chiropractic is only about 95% BS. Jim Lane Jun 2012 #4
Don't disqualify the placebo effect, it's the power of the mind to heal. crunch60 Jun 2012 #81
Absolutely...and how do we know if reiki is real?? It uses energy in the universe adigal Jun 2012 #94
Except we can test and measure all those other energies you listed MattBaggins Jun 2012 #103
They can measure brainwave changes, and mathematicians are adigal Jun 2012 #124
That is interesting but sounds like creationists who latch on to the laws of thermodynamics MattBaggins Jun 2012 #125
There is no discussing with one whose mind is not open adigal Jun 2012 #126
CHIROPRACTIC by H.L. Mencken 1924 DanteSr. Jun 2012 #5
Do you know how many people die from the poisonous drugs crunch60 Jun 2012 #79
Big Pharma? MattBaggins Jun 2012 #104
Thanks, I'll take my chiropractor and my one a day vitamin over big Pharma crunch60 Jun 2012 #114
I am sorry but you are completely wrong about "Big Pharma" vitamin D MattBaggins Jun 2012 #121
Penn and Teller - Alternative Medicine (Full Episode) Johnny Rico Jun 2012 #6
What do you call a failed physical therapist? A chiropractor. Odin2005 Jun 2012 #7
I agree Life Long Dem Jun 2012 #8
When anyone starts talking about amuse bouche Jun 2012 #27
chiropractors don't "crack" anything Scout Jun 2012 #41
I'm 'biased' because amuse bouche Jun 2012 #68
you obviously are not educated about chiropractic Scout Jun 2012 #69
but to the anti-chiros, that doesn't count WolverineDG Jun 2012 #71
And chiropractor that doesn't do x-rays or MRI's first Sheepshank Jun 2012 #93
Oldest joke in med school, Egalitarian Thug Jun 2012 #110
"you obviously are not educated about chiropractic" amuse bouche Jun 2012 #115
I also both agree and disagree. richmwill Jun 2012 #9
That happened to my husband nadine_mn Jun 2012 #56
Post removed Post removed Jun 2012 #10
Nope...when my neck starts radiating pain and my doc says to use anti-inflammatories one stop dkf Jun 2012 #11
Same with me. Couldn't do without him. Trust him more than crunch60 Jun 2012 #78
I went to a chiropractor a few years ago... RevStPatrick Jun 2012 #12
May as well Godwin it right away: Hitler was a man, therefore all men... WriteWrong Jun 2012 #13
At least chiropractors manipulate the body aint_no_life_nowhere Jun 2012 #14
I thought I was familiar with with most pseudoscientific gibberish... Johnny Rico Jun 2012 #16
because you haven't gone to a real chiropractor? Scout Jun 2012 #15
Exactly... whistler162 Jun 2012 #18
Almost the same exact story for me. underseasurveyor Jun 2012 #75
"any good chiropractor will tell you that chiropractics can't fix everything" Scout Jun 2012 #82
I started as an early twenty something underseasurveyor Jun 2012 #84
They address emotional needs and they touch you mainer Jun 2012 #17
Sometimes, it's all about stress.. dadchef Jun 2012 #65
all medical folks are a crap shoot imo. spanone Jun 2012 #19
Here's how it usually works: Nevernose Jun 2012 #20
when did you get your degree? Scout Jun 2012 #21
I guess you're not most people, are you? Nevernose Jun 2012 #54
Sorry, but you are so wrong. crunch60 Jun 2012 #80
I see a chiro, but not for headaches. Ruby the Liberal Jun 2012 #22
I spent my early years in MA amuse bouche Jun 2012 #23
if it doesn't work for you, try something else noiretextatique Jun 2012 #24
I don't see chiropracty as quackery. unreadierLizard Jun 2012 #25
Accredited by whom? MattBaggins Jun 2012 #57
Actually, the provincial government. unreadierLizard Jun 2012 #59
Guess you consider it quackery because it didn't help you - lynne Jun 2012 #26
The things in your list are not chiropractic things, but I believe most of them are true. Honeycombe8 Jun 2012 #28
My chiropractor is actually pretty good TrogL Jun 2012 #29
Don't know what kind of crappy chiropractor easttexaslefty Jun 2012 #31
All because you think it will! But glad it works! Logical Jun 2012 #33
yeah, i just THINK my vertebra were twisted... Scout Jun 2012 #35
No. Not because I THINK it will. easttexaslefty Jun 2012 #38
My back goes out now and then..... Logical Jun 2012 #32
I agree madokie Jun 2012 #34
When I was 2 yrs. old, I was accidentally dropped on my head by a 16 yr. old shraby Jun 2012 #36
People have been crippled for life by them. UnrepentantLiberal Jun 2012 #37
They sure did help me ArcticFox Jun 2012 #39
So an MD would have just pulled out a scalpel and Vicodin? midnight armadillo Jun 2012 #61
Because it is...nt SidDithers Jun 2012 #40
yes, and your fellow DUers posting here Scout Jun 2012 #42
Totally Agree DustyJoe Jun 2012 #43
Here's some from C0nc0rdance: sakabatou Jun 2012 #44
Thanks. Going to watch Part 2 now. frogmarch Jun 2012 #108
Like any medical profession, there's good and bad practitioners. jeff47 Jun 2012 #45
I love how the local chiropractic commercial here JonLP24 Jun 2012 #46
. Go Vols Jun 2012 #47
There is a huge amount of woo-woo in chiropracty. backscatter712 Jun 2012 #48
physiotherapists aren't much better. laundry_queen Jun 2012 #49
Too true. I had one who was a rip-off flamingdem Jun 2012 #64
My wife swears by her chiropractor. Kablooie Jun 2012 #51
I was doubled up with pain in my lower back... meaculpa2011 Jun 2012 #52
Yep. A good chiropractor easttexaslefty Jun 2012 #53
My testimonial: panader0 Jun 2012 #60
We have sport horses and they are regularly attended to by a chiropractor riderinthestorm Jun 2012 #62
The main scam is that they're not trained flamingdem Jun 2012 #63
I hate being in the position of defending what is a profession rife with Egalitarian Thug Jun 2012 #91
Not just one, they were all psychopaths flamingdem Jun 2012 #95
He was probably hoping for a new mercedes. n/t cynatnite Jun 2012 #101
Very likely. This seems to present itself everywhere in America today. Egalitarian Thug Jun 2012 #107
Are you on the west coast perchance? I can give you the name of one of the best Egalitarian Thug Jun 2012 #109
Patient had a stroke due to a chiropractor... cynatnite Jun 2012 #66
Patient had a heart attack due to a 3-way... stlsaxman Jun 2012 #86
I worked at neuro wing and cared for the patient... cynatnite Jun 2012 #90
Med school isn't that strong a filter. jeff47 Jun 2012 #97
With any field you're going to have your bad apples... cynatnite Jun 2012 #100
I've spent some time under the care of one while in the service MrScorpio Jun 2012 #67
I went to a chiro & got relief from neck & shoulder pain WolverineDG Jun 2012 #70
That's about as an uninformed OP underseasurveyor Jun 2012 #72
I almost lost a cousin to chiropracty LibertyLover Jun 2012 #73
My niece's husband is a chiropractor derby378 Jun 2012 #74
Give me good physical therapists who have a complete xchrom Jun 2012 #76
I've never had a chiropractor try to sell me supplements Marrah_G Jun 2012 #77
I wouldn't condemn the entire field Digit Jun 2012 #83
There is also a passive adjustment technique Ilsa Jun 2012 #85
Try living with a dislocated thoracic rib for a couple of days B2G Jun 2012 #87
Who Died? How Many? otohara Jun 2012 #88
Google MattBaggins Jun 2012 #105
No idea what kind of chiro you've been to ceile Jun 2012 #89
I consulted a chiro once on the advice of a close friend Mairead Jun 2012 #98
I started practicing yoga amuse bouche Jun 2012 #119
There are quacks and non-quacks in chiropractic jmowreader Jun 2012 #111
Osteopaths are quacks too, frogmarch Jun 2012 #112
There is no science to it at all. alarimer Jun 2012 #113
lol @ "no science to it" Go Vols Jun 2012 #117
I must agree though I try not to use the word quackery amuse bouche Jun 2012 #118
It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out B2G Jun 2012 #123
Many people die from the horrible side effects of chemo and other FDA approved crunch60 Jun 2012 #116
My chiropractor is awesome Matariki Jun 2012 #120
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Why do I consider chiropr...