General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Girl has Sex With 25 Guys But It is Not A "Whore" Problem; It is A Mental Health Problem [View all]Orrex
(63,396 posts)In reply #113 you claimed that sex at age 15 can't be consensual, implying that it's automatically rape.
I then asked the ages of the boys, and you didn't answer. Instead, you shifted the discussion and pointed out the profoundly obvious truth that there are some 18 year olds in high school, a fact that no one disputes.
When I pointed out the equally obvious truth that there are also non-18 year olds in high school, you shifted the discussion again to make a claim about child porn, still without having answered the first question.
What if she willingly consented to the act with a 15 year old boy? Would he be guilty of statutory rape, since you claim she can't consent? Would she be guilty of statutory rape, because by your logic the boy can't consent either?
Also, I don't accept that you really believe a 15 year old is unable to give consent, but let's find out: what if she gets pregnant? Does she have legal standing, in your opinion, to give consent to an abortion? If she does, then by what standard do you determine when a 15 year old is or is not legally able to give consent?