Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Demanding uncritical fealty to a media personality [View all]BainsBane
(57,528 posts)78. Russian intervention is all "speculation," you insist.
To suggest that nothing has yet been proven about the stories of Russian interference in the 2016 election is not to deny the possibility, it merely states that absent actual evidence, this is all speculation.
To suggest that nothing has been proven is a lie, a blatant and malicious lie. There has been extensive testimony before congress by dozens of intelligence officials. Government reports have been issues. There has been extensive reporting about hacking into state elections rolls and deleting voter registrations. There have been grand juries impaneled, search warrants and subpoenas. You come to this site every day. Tell me how you managed to avoid hundreds if not thousands of articles on Russian intervention, detailing Trump administration officials involvement? Why do you think the GOP Senate has been holding hearings on the matter? Why are they and Robert Mueller investigating obstruction of Justice and collusion with Russia? If Russia did not intervene, how can there been investigations into collusion? Why does every single intelligence official in this country and intelligence agencies abroad all concur there is no doubt that Russia intervened?
I am appalled, absolutely appalled that you would make such a claim. The only people who deny Russian involvement in the election are Trump, Putin, the most stupid of the Trump supporters (not even all or most of them) and the fascist collaborators of JPR and their ilk. The commonality between all of them is a determination to prop up Trump and ensure the spread of White Nationalism through the West. It is a posture based on intense, all consuming hatred of immigrants, people of color, women, Democrats, and anyone who opposes authoritarianism. There is NO ONE with any integrity or honesty that adopts such a position. Trump and Putin know full well the Russians intervened. They were actively involved in it. The rest seek are engaged in a pernicious agenda to promote them.
Even Fox and the alt-right media no longer deny the Russian interference or the collusion. They have moved on to argue that collusion with Russia isn't so bad after all. Yet for some reason you think it acceptable to willfully ignore the last several months of Senate testimony and press exposes, even the emails released by Trump Jr himself documenting intervention and collusion, to pretend none of that exist.
No one does that out of concern for evidence. They do it out of contempt for evidence and truth.
So far you have gone around this site insisting women need to give up reproductive rights so that YOU and can "win' (not us, since women are to be excluded the body politic). Evidence for the claim that subjugating half the population to second-class citizenship is a "winning" strategy didn't concern you in the slightest, nor did all of the evidence showing the connection between denial of reproductive rights and increased poverty and high death rates. Evidence wasn't a concern for the fascist collaboration on JPR when it came to blaming Clinton for Seth Rich's death or running a pedophile ring out of pizza shop.
But when it comes to something that is the subject of dozens of investigations by the Senate, House, FBI, the Treasury Department, Counter Terrorism, etc..., that has produced documentation, hours and hours of testimony, all of which is evidence that you deny exists.
Clearly evidence isn't a concern in terms of undermining abortion rights because those advocating it want to see women reduced to second class citizenship. When it comes to Russian intervention in the elections, no evidence is sufficient and will ever be sufficient because those justifying it are more concerned with validating Trump's victory than their own intellectual honesty. There is no conceivable reason any Democrat, progressive, liberal, or even moderate would engage in such an agenda.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
82 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
I'm seeing weird stuff like "If you disagree w Mr X on statement Y, you clearly hate Unions!"
emulatorloo
Aug 2017
#1
"Hartman's statements justifying Russian interference in elections in the West demonstrate as much."
NurseJackie
Aug 2017
#2
I have listened to Thom Hartman for about 10 years now and I always thought of him as being
world wide wally
Aug 2017
#8
Our Constitutional democracy. With all its flaws, we've never had a Presidential election
pnwmom
Aug 2017
#58
"The idea that Hartmann is some kind of double agent propagandist for Putin is absurd. "
emulatorloo
Aug 2017
#34
"The Big Picture with Thom Hartmann is filmed live and broadcast from the RT America studios
ucrdem
Aug 2017
#69
I have read similar things about The Nation, and similar suggestions of a fealty to Russia.
guillaumeb
Aug 2017
#30
First, if you insist on the allegation regarding Clinton, how can I take your
guillaumeb
Aug 2017
#82
They say that Hartmann doesn't post here anymore, but I wonder if that's true? Maybe he just.....
Tarheel_Dem
Aug 2017
#53
Just because someone managed to get a show on RT does not mean they are Russian shills or pro-Trump
LiberalLovinLug
Aug 2017
#56
It means they are lending their name, and helping to validate as a news source, RT.
pnwmom
Aug 2017
#59
"Everyone" does NOT know that. Till last year, people here frequently posted things by RT,
pnwmom
Aug 2017
#61
All I saw from your link is someone expousing a reason, not an excuse, why Russia has felt betrayed
LiberalLovinLug
Aug 2017
#65
Yes! I saw Hartmann's show on YouTube - does that mean that YouTube is in bed with Russia now?
diva77
Aug 2017
#72
HE's TEEVEE star + he's rich. so he MUST be shmart! he sounds JUST LIKE RAYGUN!
pansypoo53219
Aug 2017
#79