General Discussion

longship

(40,416 posts)

66. Idiotic Texas sharpshooter fallacy!

Reply to arely staircase (Original post)

Fri Jul 20, 2012, 10:00 PM

Jul 2012

No intent here for any pun. It is what this logical fallacy is known as. In the Texas Sharpshooter fallacy, a cowboy aims his gun at the side of a barn, and then walks over to the barn and draws a bullseye around the bullet hole.

This is a type of a more general fallacy called the Post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy (after this, therefore because of this).

All told, the claim of the OP is refuted without a connecting statistic, because otherwise there would be any number of data points that connect Holmes to this horrible event.

Most importantly is the plausibility that a crazy guy wanted to make a big splash, so he chose a premier of a largely promoted film, the attendance of which would be large. Given that fact, William of Okham's razor gives OP idea a big shave. If Aurora had hosted the Superbowl last night and Holmes shot up the stadium, would the original poster claim that football was to blame?

Silly! Fucking silly, fallacious logic.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

74 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Boycott Dark Knight? [View all] arely staircase Jul 2012 OP

I'm in. nt Comrade_McKenzie Jul 2012 #1

I don't think that's a good idea. CaliforniaPeggy Jul 2012 #2

But the staunch conservative Politicalboi Jul 2012 #5

well, chick fil a's owner's statements aren't the sandwiches's fault nt arely staircase Jul 2012 #7

Yes boycott that fucking bastard's work!!! gopiscrap Jul 2012 #3

Wait, the writer of Dark Knight, or the creator of batman? Curtland1015 Jul 2012 #4

the writer. nt arely staircase Jul 2012 #14

No offense F. Kafka Jul 2012 #6

Chuck Dixon, the current writer of Batman, is conservative. randome Jul 2012 #9

Who created Bane. OK. F. Kafka Jul 2012 #16

I don't think he had anything to do with the movie. randome Jul 2012 #17

didn't have anything to do with it? arely staircase Jul 2012 #21

I doubt it. DC probably owns the characters. randome Jul 2012 #23

Moore is really good. I also like Alan Grant a lot as well. white_wolf Jul 2012 #26

Grant Morrison's Doom Patrol is my all time favorite series. randome Jul 2012 #32

I'll have to check that one out. white_wolf Jul 2012 #34

Moore is great. sabrina 1 Jul 2012 #70

He isn't the current writer. He is the creator of Bane. white_wolf Jul 2012 #18

but surely he is getting a cut from the movie arely staircase Jul 2012 #22

He is. white_wolf Jul 2012 #25

No. F. Kafka Jul 2012 #27

I loved Year One, but I hate Miller. Such an asshole. n/t white_wolf Jul 2012 #28

Year One is gorgeous. F. Kafka Jul 2012 #29

Year One was so much better than Dark Knight Returns. white_wolf Jul 2012 #31

Because it was such a shock for the time, I think. F. Kafka Jul 2012 #37

I recently watched the Year One animated movie online. white_wolf Jul 2012 #39

sorry, the writer arely staircase Jul 2012 #12

Just like a conservative's narrow world view. randome Jul 2012 #19

When Mitt Romney risks his life and fortune for others he can claim to be Wayne. white_wolf Jul 2012 #30

Hey the Romney family has dedicated a lot of time to national service mythology Jul 2012 #65

Ahh. I see. F. Kafka Jul 2012 #20

Just got home from seeing the 9:40 a.m. ChazII Jul 2012 #74

Why? OverseaVisitor Jul 2012 #8

Fuck Batman, the producer, Ann Romney, and the Horse. NYC_SKP Jul 2012 #10

This message was self-deleted by its author GarroHorus Jul 2012 #11

So much wrong with this. RedStateLiberal Jul 2012 #13

I'd boycott it because it has no message other than violence. Manifestor_of_Light Jul 2012 #15

I would not call my actions a boycott since I am not a comic book fan. Dawson Leery Jul 2012 #24

Yeah, if you didn't grow up on this stuff, I can see why it would not have much appeal. randome Jul 2012 #35

I actually only recently got into comics. white_wolf Jul 2012 #40

Avengers have had ups and downs. I have some of the 'ups'. randome Jul 2012 #42

my batman fanaticism arely staircase Jul 2012 #46

The writer of a Batman comic book series boxman15 Jul 2012 #33

So? He's just a writer. Incitatus Jul 2012 #36

Boycott Dark Knight? RebelOne Jul 2012 #38

my op has nothing to do with the killings nt arely staircase Jul 2012 #51

Uh..no thanks nt SunsetDreams Jul 2012 #41

Another thread whatchamacallit Jul 2012 #43

We can't afford to go out to movies anyway rurallib Jul 2012 #44

i'm with you BOG PERSON Jul 2012 #48

No. This knee jerk authoritarian thing...... Edweird Jul 2012 #45

whatever, i wasnt going to see it anyway BOG PERSON Jul 2012 #47

Boycott, my ass! Nolan's trilogy is a masterpiece. DerekG Jul 2012 #49

Chuck Dixon is the Creator of Bane chrisau214 Jul 2012 #50

you are almost certainly right arely staircase Jul 2012 #52

Wait a minute! You're saying Patrick Leahy was created by a Batman writer? randome Jul 2012 #54

Morgan Freeman too, I still can't understand how he could prostitute himself hughee99 Jul 2012 #62

Wasn't going in any event treestar Jul 2012 #53

Conservative, delusional. What's the diff? randome Jul 2012 #55

Dark Knight kalisto2010 Jul 2012 #56

Not to mention his strict stance against the death penalty. white_wolf Jul 2012 #64

Too late. demosincebirth Jul 2012 #57

Sounds like a good reason to boycott. ananda Jul 2012 #58

I disagree. white_wolf Jul 2012 #67

You could edit your post and then we could read the original version if we wanted. randome Jul 2012 #71

I didn't think of that, I'll just do that in this post. Read the original post for spoilers. white_wolf Jul 2012 #72

The Movie Doesn't Send Out a False Message About OWS chrisau214 Jul 2012 #69

I shall boycott the boycott as soon as I can get around to it. 4th law of robotics Jul 2012 #59

To boycott this is silly DonCoquixote Jul 2012 #60

I'm in. Iggo Jul 2012 #61

me too BOG PERSON Jul 2012 #73

I intend to see it. AsahinaKimi Jul 2012 #63

Idiotic Texas sharpshooter fallacy! longship Jul 2012 #66

Fine with me, do not want to help enrich a Right Winger who thinks that Romney is sabrina 1 Jul 2012 #68