Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Behind the Aegis

(56,102 posts)
17. It doesn't mean you are from another country.
Sat Sep 29, 2012, 03:03 AM
Sep 2012

It is, however, a demographic. In an article about gays, it wouldn't be uncommon to see "Gay Americans." The hyphenation often refers to "Jews" as an 'ethnic' group, like Native American, Mexican-American, and the like. It might have been better, way on back in the day, if the ethnic group remained to be called Israeli or Hebrews, but it didn't. So, it isn't "PC bullshit crap" (a bit redundant, don't you think?).

The problem does exist though, that there are those who do treat us as if we are from another country or are more loyal to Israel. This form of anti-Semitism has existed since the early Greeks dominated the region. Our loyalties are often called into question and our voting habits constantly scrutinized. The politicians and the media re-enforce this time and time again, and many gulp down the kool-aid, no questions asked. The most recent event that really stick out for me as an example of this is the Weiner recall election. Pop back over to DU and look at some of the articles posted, and the comments. While some of the worst were deleted, there are more than a few nasty comments still there. Many tried to claim it was all about the votes of the Jews (not true) or their feelings on Israel (really not true). That is why articles like this are akin to reports that "water is wet" to me.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

No, what is really important for people HERE to notice is this: Behind the Aegis Sep 2012 #1
That's never been a question, really. Scootaloo Sep 2012 #7
It is questioned here all the time. Behind the Aegis Sep 2012 #10
I must be missing it, then Scootaloo Sep 2012 #11
You must be. It is quite common. Behind the Aegis Sep 2012 #12
It's still there, even if it's cooled somewhat Posteritatis Sep 2012 #14
I was here in the summer of 2006 and I really do not remember seeing much of what you claim azurnoir Sep 2012 #31
I saw quite a bit of it Posteritatis Sep 2012 #39
You are correct. Behind the Aegis Sep 2012 #38
Yeah, I kinda didn't hang out here much, six years ago... Scootaloo Sep 2012 #50
See post #43 Behind the Aegis Sep 2012 #44
Seems to be saying Israel doesn't much care about the situation... Scootaloo Sep 2012 #46
In a thread about Jewish voters? Do you really not get it? Behind the Aegis Sep 2012 #47
Actually, I do; my reading derp Scootaloo Sep 2012 #48
Good to hear. Behind the Aegis Sep 2012 #49
I think by and large people here do know that however if azurnoir Sep 2012 #25
Or imagining all Israelis think like Likud BainsBane Sep 2012 #40
very true in fact Likud came in second in the last Israeli election azurnoir Sep 2012 #42
I never had any doubt that Jewish voters would vote democratic in the end. hrmjustin Sep 2012 #2
What is "Jewish-American?" begin_within Sep 2012 #3
In the case of Jews, people seem to confuse religion with race. OnlinePoker Sep 2012 #4
But Jews in America share a common culture. Chorophyll Sep 2012 #6
Culture isn't something created by "being kicked around." 11cents Sep 2012 #8
Well, I'm Jewish-American. Chorophyll Sep 2012 #9
I'm Jewish too. 11cents Sep 2012 #16
My first comment might have come out the way it did because Chorophyll Sep 2012 #22
It's a TRIBAL identity. immoderate Sep 2012 #27
Your mother is a smart lady. zellie Sep 2012 #30
Thanks. That's something I never doubted, though we disagreed a lot. immoderate Sep 2012 #32
My bad....I'm sure you inherited her strength and wisdom. zellie Sep 2012 #35
I'd be happy with half of it. immoderate Sep 2012 #37
No bad. I answered myself by mistake. immoderate Sep 2012 #45
That is an excellent and short explanation!! meti57b Sep 2012 #41
It is the culture of a people that has chosen to define itself Ghost Dog Sep 2012 #18
Yeah we do. nt Walk away Sep 2012 #5
When politically convenient, yeah Posteritatis Sep 2012 #15
I never realized being Jewish meant I was from another country. Do we say Catholic-Americans Suji to Seoul Sep 2012 #13
It doesn't mean you are from another country. Behind the Aegis Sep 2012 #17
well with regard to the Weiner recall election it could on the surface appear that way azurnoir Sep 2012 #23
Obama got 78 percent of the Jewish vote in 2008 oberliner Sep 2012 #19
If you look at the polling at this time in 2008 to this time 2012 aaaaaa5a Sep 2012 #20
2008 Jewish Vote for Obama Exceeds All Expectations oberliner Sep 2012 #21
The numbers come from the equivalent poll last time muriel_volestrangler Sep 2012 #26
Good point oberliner Sep 2012 #34
Interesting post pointing out how much Jewish support for Obama has fallen on a thread that states azurnoir Sep 2012 #24
More work is needed oberliner Sep 2012 #28
No we cannot be complacent about the election on any front azurnoir Sep 2012 #29
Hope you're right oberliner Sep 2012 #52
How can that be? I thought Bibi said vote for Mittwit? treestar Sep 2012 #33
This totally confuses the RWingers. DCBob Sep 2012 #36
Who Cares elbloggoZY27 Sep 2012 #43
And yet another "American Jews are really Israelis" post. (nt) Posteritatis Sep 2012 #51
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Jewish-American voters no...»Reply #17