Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

cab67

(3,240 posts)
32. This is actually a form of bigotry.
Sat Oct 5, 2024, 02:37 PM
Oct 5

And not in the way most people would think.

The King James Version is preferred by several Protestant communities - the more conservative ones in particular - in part because it was written not long after the Reformation and during a time when Catholic vs Protestant was a thing all over the European continent.

The KJV is sometimes seen as not just sufficiently pure, but also sufficiently anti-Catholic.

By insisting on this version, the bowsers who came up with this policy aren't just pushing Christianity - they're pushing a version of evangelical Protestantism that is inherently anti-Catholic.

I gave up Catholicism for Lent a while back, and it kinda stuck. I'm not even remotely happy with the way American conservative Catholics have inserted themselves into politics in this country* - indeed, it's one of the reasons I've distanced myself - but I also know they don't speak for every Catholic in the country. I still have many fond memories of my time involved with the Catholic student centers at my undergrad and graduate schools, and I find real beauty in how Catholics are expected to treat the poor and downtrodden. For this reason, the thought of requiring a version of the Bible that came from an explicitly anti-Catholic mindset really bothers me.

I actually would support a course on Biblical history at the high school level. But I don't mean teaching the Bible as history. Rather, I mean teaching the history of the Bible, which is seriously fascinating stuff.


*I will take bishops' threats to Catholic politicians who support women's reproductive rights seriously when they start issuing the same threats to Catholic judges, prosecutors, jurors, and prison officials who take part in executions. Official Catholic doctrine opposes both for the very same reason.

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

of course , the donald trump bible would fill the bill. AllaN01Bear Oct 4 #1
Just to be clear, The Bill of Rights and the Constitution are the same document Cheezoholic Oct 4 #2
Exactly. The Bill of Rights are just the first ten Amendments to the Constitution. SunSeeker Oct 4 #6
They'd know that if they read their bible JoseBalow Oct 4 #10
And not the complete document. cab67 Oct 5 #30
Think of all the money the school could save by NOT breaking the wall of separation sakabatou Oct 4 #3
That amounts to a gift of public funds and an illegal campaign contribution. SunSeeker Oct 4 #4
A gift/grift of taxpayer money to Trump. keithbvadu2 Oct 4 #8
I would pull my child out bluestarone Oct 4 #5
Oh, for the love of dogs and cats and little green lizards! ShazzieB Oct 4 #7
Is that the only difference between t's bibles and others? That the slightlv Oct 4 #13
Yes, this is just a reglar KJV Bible with a few added extras. ShazzieB Oct 4 #17
Dear gods! Gag me with a spoon! /nt slightlv Oct 4 #20
I would think they'd have banned the Declaration of Independence: All men are created equal, and such. Jim__ Oct 4 #9
This sounds Linda ladeewolf Oct 4 #11
i don't know...stupid ass tina peterson is doing nine years for it prodigitalson Oct 5 #34
Yes, Linda ladeewolf Oct 6 #40
These things are all true, but I think the Okie Ayatollah's days are numbered in terms of getting caught too prodigitalson Oct 6 #41
Agree Linda ladeewolf Oct 6 #42
Is ...separation of church and state...gone? happy feet Oct 4 #12
Back in the late 70's, slightlv Oct 4 #14
How sickening. Oklahoman children will be mystically manipulated dolts when they get through with them. mdbl Oct 4 #15
The state of Oklahoma ranks 4th !! Ah.....4th worst state. chouchou Oct 4 #16
Ryan Walters.... remember this guy? IcyPeas Oct 4 #18
Oh, lovely ArkansasDemocrat1 Oct 4 #19
Put in the dicarded parts of the Bible, like women's sexuality! GreenWave Oct 4 #21
Does the book have to be physical? mwooldri Oct 5 #22
Is this same book required in private schools? I will bet it isn't- Stargazer99 Oct 5 #23
That Walters guy is one shady f6cker wolfie001 Oct 5 #24
they will all be spitball targets samnsara Oct 5 #25
It's worth noting that the King James Version is so archaic, it's a confusing joke. jaxexpat Oct 5 #26
Check out the website that sells Chick Tracts. cab67 Oct 5 #31
As Mrs. Drysdale would say, "Oh, those dreadful hillbillies". jaxexpat Oct 5 #33
I just recently discovered those are still a thing prodigitalson Oct 5 #36
yeah, but this one has a lee greenwood song prodigitalson Oct 5 #35
THAT'S RIGHT OKLAHOMA, SHOVE THOSE BIG THICK BIBLES YoshidaYui Oct 5 #27
I remember when a radio station recited the Declaration of Independence on-air Mysterian Oct 5 #28
and you get a lee greenwood song that you also didn't ask for prodigitalson Oct 5 #37
Trump "approved" book he's never read. Fucking ridiculous. AZ8theist Oct 5 #29
I bet he's never read Art of the Deal cover to cover prodigitalson Oct 5 #38
This is actually a form of bigotry. cab67 Oct 5 #32
From the Oklahoma Bible prodigitalson Oct 5 #39
After Trump's upcoming loss this November 5th, these bibles will be for sale on eBay in February 2025. SupportSanity Oct 6 #43
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Oklahoma's school chief r...»Reply #32