Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Bill USA

(6,436 posts)
17. your act is not fooling anybody. If you have specific cases and charges, then be upfront about it
Sat Nov 15, 2014, 04:38 PM
Nov 2014

Last edited Sat Nov 15, 2014, 05:50 PM - Edit history (1)



... and make them.

I have found Conservatives put almost no importance on the legitimacy of their generalizations based the data they site. Usually you are content to make a case on the basis of one observation (i.e. an anecdote).

Your assertion (implied) is that the "caliber of thinking" you "encounter on DU way too much" is markedly inferior to the thinking you've encountered... where? ... in the general population, on other internet web-sites?? -- or on Conservative web-sites (which of course you do not spend most of your time on).

The logic I've seen on DU (I have more than 220 posts) compares quite favorably to the logic I have encountered from virtually any GOP politician, propagandist or apologists - whatever the medium.

If you are trying to make an implied case that the logic exhibited on DU is inferior to that offered by Conservatives -- well, your going to have to make that case - explicitly - not by implication.

..And start by coming up with some cases - or no Democrat will take your rhetoric as honest discourse but rather will correctly identify it as casuistry.

Ramble on, as you no doubt will, without specific cases, but don't expect anybody to be fooled.


Try being upfront with your arguments Mr. '200 posts'.







Dont just look at the post, Eko Nov 2014 #1
But DO look at any post you respond to. Jim Lane Nov 2014 #10
All men are Hari Seldon Nov 2014 #2
The founders had wigs, Eko Nov 2014 #3
and they wore yoga pants yurbud Nov 2014 #41
C'mon, there has to be more of us out there? Eko Nov 2014 #4
Using science and logic on the ebola outbreak meant folks had to abandon their firmly held fears.... Fred Sanders Nov 2014 #5
"Are we going to let posts that are premised on a logical fallacies become the normal?" unrepentant progress Nov 2014 #6
aren't 'we' being a bit transparent? Bill USA Nov 2014 #11
No, Eko Nov 2014 #15
your act is not fooling anybody. If you have specific cases and charges, then be upfront about it Bill USA Nov 2014 #17
You are doing a nice job of making my case for me. Eko Nov 2014 #18
So I will use you as a specific case. Eko Nov 2014 #20
I teach university logic Doctor_J Nov 2014 #7
One thing I've noticed is that accusing someone of a logical fallacy cbayer Nov 2014 #8
Could you explain that? Eko Nov 2014 #14
It's the "calling someone's argument a logical fallacy" logical fallacy. cbayer Nov 2014 #16
couldnt seem to find that one Eko Nov 2014 #19
The Fallacy Fallacy. It's akin to a straw man. cbayer Nov 2014 #21
Learned something new. Eko Nov 2014 #22
You, sir, are technically correct. cbayer Nov 2014 #23
The original point can be a logical fallacy. Eko Nov 2014 #24
This hurts my brain. cbayer Nov 2014 #29
A point can be a logical fallacy Eko Nov 2014 #37
I understand that, I think. cbayer Nov 2014 #38
If the original thought Eko Nov 2014 #40
An example. Eko Nov 2014 #39
When you use a logical fallacy as your main argument Eko Nov 2014 #25
Are logical fallacies the same as false equivalents? Baitball Blogger Nov 2014 #9
Thanks for the reminder. nilesobek Nov 2014 #12
Two useful tools in understanding logical fallacies and how people think... CBHagman Nov 2014 #13
For those who need a picture drawn for them.... Scootaloo Nov 2014 #26
This does explain how those who blast liberals who do not support Hillary as purists, can also djean111 Nov 2014 #27
Form over substance - TBF Nov 2014 #28
Maybe this will help you some. Eko Nov 2014 #30
I also have a piece that TBF Nov 2014 #31
If you have something to say, say it. Eko Nov 2014 #32
We come to political discussion TBF Nov 2014 #33
Politics is about ideas, Eko Nov 2014 #34
I am not discussing it with you TBF Nov 2014 #35
I think that is somewhat fair, Eko Nov 2014 #36
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Editorials & Other Articles»List of Logical Fallacies...»Reply #17