Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Demeter

(85,373 posts)
53. The Trouble with Money
Sat Apr 28, 2012, 05:17 PM
Apr 2012

Recently I was asked by a high school teacher if I had any ideas about why students today seem so apathetic when it comes to engaging with the world around them. I waggishly responded, "Probably because they're smart."

In my opinion, we're asking our young adults to step into a story that doesn't make any sense....Sure, we can grow the earth's population to 9 billion (and probably will), and sure, we can extract our natural gas and oil resources as fast as possible, and sure, we can continue to pile on official debts at a staggering pace -- but why are we doing all this? Even more troubling, what do we say to our youth when they ask what role they should play in this story -- a story with a plot line they didn't get to write?

So far, the narrative we're asking them to step into sounds a lot like this: Study hard, go to college, maybe graduate school. And when you get out, not only will you be indebted to your education loans and your mortgage, but you'll be asked to help pay back trillions and trillions of debt to cover the decisions of those who came before you. All while operating within a crumbling, substandard infrastructure. Oh, and by the way, the government and corporate sector appear to have no real interest in your long-term future; you're on your own there.

Yeah, I happen to think apathy is a perfectly sane response to that story. Thanks, but no thanks.

Money Is Not Wealth

Money is just a marker for real things. As long as you can exchange your money for real things, your money represents value. Because we tend to conduct all of our most meaningful transactions using money, our perspective can become warped to the point that we think it is the money itself that has value.

The economy is measured in these units, these markers, which we call "money." But money is not the same thing as the economy. Far from it. And money has no value on its own, but only in relation to the things we can exchange it for. The economy consists of real needs and wants being fulfilled. On one end of the spectrum, we have the basics like food, water, shelter, medical care, and other necessities. On the other end of the spectrum, we have 15-minute neck massages at the airport. Everything else lies in between

Money, on the other hand, is simply a facilitator of exchanges....MORE AT LINK

http://www.chrismartenson.com/blog/trouble-money/73469?utm_source=newsletter_2012-04-21&utm_medium=email_newsletter&utm_content=node_teaser_73469&utm_campaign=weekly_newsletter_67

JACKPOT! 4 BANKS DOWN AT 6:30 PM EDT Demeter Apr 2012 #1
ONE MORE BANK BRINGS IT TO FIVE FOR THE WEEKEND Demeter Apr 2012 #16
$272.6M FOR THE WEEKEND Demeter Apr 2012 #17
Death of a Fairy Tale By PAUL KRUGMAN Demeter Apr 2012 #2
Cue The Confidence Fairy! FROM Monday, April 04, 2011 Demeter Apr 2012 #3
Monti hits at eurozone austerity push Demeter Apr 2012 #7
Key US states face slow job growth Demeter Apr 2012 #4
Obama courts the ‘angry white men’ Demeter Apr 2012 #5
S&P downgrades Spain to triple B plus Demeter Apr 2012 #6
BoJ expands asset purchase programme Demeter Apr 2012 #8
FUKUSHIMA: The ‘Japanese Chernobyl’ - A Year Later and Politics Still ‘Trump’ Safety Demeter Apr 2012 #9
Halfway Through the Lost Decade By Robert Scheer Demeter Apr 2012 #10
Is There Room for Accountability in a Society Plagued by Everyday Corruption? Demeter Apr 2012 #11
LET'S MAKE SOME MAGIC! Demeter Apr 2012 #12
Excellent topic! DemReadingDU Apr 2012 #13
Musical Interlude hamerfan Apr 2012 #14
Nice piece of music....who is she? Demeter Apr 2012 #19
Heart, the band. hamerfan Apr 2012 #60
Video Interlude hamerfan Apr 2012 #15
I never saw that one Demeter Apr 2012 #20
That looks scary, I don't recall that movie at all DemReadingDU Apr 2012 #27
wakey - wakey -- eggs and bac-ey xchrom Apr 2012 #18
You read my mind...or stomach Demeter Apr 2012 #21
good for you -- it's not something i do often xchrom Apr 2012 #22
Ah, Life Looks Better After Breakfast Demeter Apr 2012 #26
I felt like going out for breakfast this morning. Fuddnik Apr 2012 #28
Shareholder Rage at Bank Pay Reaches Tipping Point xchrom Apr 2012 #23
The 2% Catastrophe: How One Number Explains the Miserable Economy xchrom Apr 2012 #24
“We’re getting absolutely killed in social media..." (ALEC) bread_and_roses Apr 2012 #25
When Half a Million Americans Died and Nobody Noticed By Alexander Cockburn Demeter Apr 2012 #29
Harry Houdini: An Escape Artist- National History Day Demeter Apr 2012 #30
Notable escapes Demeter Apr 2012 #31
GOP’s Death Wish: Why They Can’t Stop Pissing Off Hispanics, Women, and Young People By Robert Reich Demeter Apr 2012 #32
America's Mad Cow Crisis Demeter Apr 2012 #33
The Corruption Law That Scares the Bejesus Out of Corporate America Demeter Apr 2012 #34
Demonstrators Confront Wells Fargo Shareholders Demeter Apr 2012 #35
One Of Our Favorite Market Indicators Is Plunging, And Just Went Negative xchrom Apr 2012 #36
ATTENTION WEEKENDERS! DEMETER ESCAPES! Demeter Apr 2012 #37
I'll kick it off IF - bread_and_roses Apr 2012 #39
Okay! You're IT! Demeter Apr 2012 #42
Government shutdown on the horizon? (AGAIN? BUT THAT TRICK NEVER WORKS!) Demeter Apr 2012 #38
Paul Daniels - Rabbit from a Hat (SCREAMINGLY FUNNY) Demeter Apr 2012 #40
Easily the funniest magic trick i've ever seen - penn and teller Demeter Apr 2012 #41
Why Hasn't the Euro Fallen More in the Crisis? Demeter Apr 2012 #43
Ben Bernanke vs. Paul Krugman Posted by Ezra Klein Demeter Apr 2012 #44
Higher Taxes and a Loss in Europe Hurt Ford Profit Demeter Apr 2012 #45
What Detroit’s Resurgence Says About The Auto Bailout Demeter Apr 2012 #57
Stunned Home Buyers Find the Bidding Wars Are Back Demeter Apr 2012 #46
Obama to Sign Executive Order to Keep for-Profit Colleges From Defrauding Military Families Demeter Apr 2012 #47
Burden of Proof: Geithner, Obama, and Wall Street’s Unpunished Crimes By Richard (RJ) Eskow Demeter Apr 2012 #48
My Faith-Based Retirement By JOE NOCERA Demeter Apr 2012 #49
New 'Get The F**k Outta The Road' Program Aims To Increase Pedestrian Safety Demeter Apr 2012 #50
Lehman Bros. pay report brings calls for reform Demeter Apr 2012 #51
CISPA--THEY NEVER STOP TRYING TO PUSH THE ENVELOPE ON FASCISM Demeter Apr 2012 #52
The Trouble with Money Demeter Apr 2012 #53
Get Ready for 'Hot' Inflation Demeter Apr 2012 #54
Movie career Demeter Apr 2012 #55
Golden Eye of Hurricane By Jim Willie Demeter Apr 2012 #56
27 Reasons The European Sovereign Debt Bubble Is About To Burst Michael Snyder Demeter Apr 2012 #58
Simon Johnson on Debt and Deficit Demeter Apr 2012 #59
Why the Eurozone Crisis Is Getting Worse By Nouriel Roubini Demeter Apr 2012 #61
The “Likelihood of a Criminal Prosecution” in MF Global Case Has Grown By Charlie Gasparino Demeter Apr 2012 #62
It keeps growing more insane by the day. Hotler Apr 2012 #75
Where there's life, there's hope, Hotler Demeter Apr 2012 #81
morning... xchrom Apr 2012 #63
Nice Shot! Is that from a film? Demeter Apr 2012 #65
i don't know -- i just googled morning images. xchrom Apr 2012 #66
Brain Drain Feared as German Jobs Lure Southern Europeans xchrom Apr 2012 #64
The End of Growth in the United States Demeter Apr 2012 #67
Martin D. Weiss: To Make Money In This Bubble-and-Bust World, You MUST Be A Contrarian Demeter Apr 2012 #68
Rochelle Riley: Detroit's budget too tight to run November election? Demeter Apr 2012 #69
Debunking spiritualists Demeter Apr 2012 #70
Artifacts/Libraries/Museums Demeter Apr 2012 #71
Death Demeter Apr 2012 #72
Folks, I'm Going to Stop There Demeter Apr 2012 #73
How Apple Sidesteps Billions in Taxes hamerfan Apr 2012 #74
The Apple is riddled with worms Demeter Apr 2012 #83
Thank you Mrs. Demeter for WEE, another good read. n/t Hotler Apr 2012 #76
It's just Demeter, and yes, I'm available but picky Demeter Apr 2012 #82
Is it too early to start drinking?? I found a really good tequila the other day.... Hotler Apr 2012 #77
Never! Fuddnik Apr 2012 #78
Musical Interlude hamerfan Apr 2012 #79
I like that "Magic, Escapes, and Fraud Mediums Exposed" bread_and_roses Apr 2012 #80
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Economy»Weekend Economists Examin...»Reply #53