Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Demeter

(85,373 posts)
28. 10 Reasons Countries Fall Apart
Mon Jul 2, 2012, 07:24 AM
Jul 2012
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2012/06/18/10_reasons_countries_fall_apart?page=full


States don't fail overnight. The seeds of of their destruction are sown deep within their political institutions...I'M SURE SOME DO, THEY JUST DON'T LAST LONG ENOUGH TO COUNT...Some countries fail spectacularly, with a total collapse of all state institutions, as in Afghanistan after the Soviet withdrawal and the hanging of President Mohammad Najibullah from a lamppost, or during the decade-long civil war in Sierra Leone, where the government ceased to exist altogether. Most countries that fall apart, however, do so not with a bang but with a whimper. They fail not in an explosion of war and violence but by being utterly unable to take advantage of their society's huge potential for growth, condemning their citizens to a lifetime of poverty. This type of slow, grinding failure leaves many countries in sub-Saharan Africa, Asia, and Latin America with living standards far, far below those in the West....AND THEN, THERE ARE COUNTRIES LIKE OURS, RAPIDLY APPROACHING THOSE SAME CONDITIONS...

What's tragic is that this failure is by design. These states collapse because they are ruled by what we call "extractive" economic institutions, which destroy incentives, discourage innovation, and sap the talent of their citizens by creating a tilted playing field and robbing them of opportunities. These institutions are not in place by mistake but on purpose. They're there for the benefit of elites who gain much from the extraction -- whether in the form of valuable minerals, forced labor, or protected monopolies -- at the expense of society. Of course, such elites benefit from rigged political institutions too, wielding their power to tilt the system for their benefit. But states built on exploitation inevitably fail, taking an entire corrupt system down with them and often leading to immense suffering. Each year the Failed States Index charts the tragic stats of state failure. Here's our guide to 10 ways it happens:

1. North Korea: Lack of property rights

2. Uzbekistan: Forced labor

3. South Africa: A tilted playing field

4. Egypt: The big men get greedy

5. Austria and Russia: Elites block new technologies

6. Somalia: No law and order

7. Colombia: A weak central government

8. Peru: Bad public services

9. Bolivia: Political exploitation

10. Sierra Leone: Fighting over the spoils


11. USA: ALL OF THE ABOVE, PLUS A SLEEPING CITIZENRY
And the 'toon: Of course they could always just Tansy_Gold Jul 2012 #1
What she said Demeter Jul 2012 #2
Arrr, Somalia, where a real man can become a pirate and live on his own terms, Ayn Rand's heaven, tclambert Jul 2012 #3
So how much can guvmint save Po_d Mainiac Jul 2012 #10
I see I should have bought gas Sunday.... Demeter Jul 2012 #4
Sanctions May Squeeze Iran ... And Raise Oil Prices Demeter Jul 2012 #7
Would'ya look at that green candle on the far right of the crude chart! Hugin Jul 2012 #11
That's called a fuse n/t Po_d Mainiac Jul 2012 #12
"IF ISRAEL GETS ITS SHOOTING WAR" - your anti-Semitism is showing, Demeter wordpix Jul 2012 #58
I'm anti-crazy Demeter Jul 2012 #59
Still $3.03 near me. Quite surprised it hasn't even gone up a penny. Roland99 Jul 2012 #45
Down to $2.96 here yesterday. Fuddnik Jul 2012 #49
$3.27 at Sam's Club this morning Demeter Jul 2012 #60
And Now Everyone's Up a Quarter Demeter Jul 2012 #66
Stung by Recession, Many Young Voters Looking Past Obama (THE YOUNG AREN'T THE ONLY ONES) Demeter Jul 2012 #5
Barclays chairman to step down Demeter Jul 2012 #6
The Libor Scandal and the Price of Prosperity Demeter Jul 2012 #31
Skimmers by Atrios Demeter Jul 2012 #32
Vince Cable calls for criminal investigation into Barclays bankers Demeter Jul 2012 #34
Pricewaterhouse Coopers Sushi_lover Jul 2012 #56
Ask Eric Holder, that's a good question for him Demeter Jul 2012 #61
Africa on the Rise By NICHOLAS D. KRISTOF Demeter Jul 2012 #8
Going to bed--see you Monday Demeter Jul 2012 #9
Well, We Got Our Humidity and Jet Stream Back Demeter Jul 2012 #13
aka ACA Roundup (Stuff I couldn't bear to post earlier) Demeter Jul 2012 #14
Fla. Gov.: We won't comply with health care law Demeter Jul 2012 #23
As Court Affirms Patchwork U.S. Healthcare System, Vermont Pushes Ahead with Single Payer Demeter Jul 2012 #25
More nuanced view of Roberts after health care law Demeter Jul 2012 #15
Show Me Your Papers By BILL KELLER Demeter Jul 2012 #18
Financial Giants Are Moving Jobs Off Wall Street By NELSON D. SCHWARTZ Demeter Jul 2012 #16
77% of JP Morgan’s Net Income Comes from Government Subsidies Demeter Jul 2012 #20
Big Banks Have Criminally Conspired Since 2005 to Rig $800 Trillion Dollar Market (LIBOR) Demeter Jul 2012 #21
Europe’s Great Illusion By PAUL KRUGMAN Demeter Jul 2012 #17
Israel sought $1 billion IMF loan for Palestinians Demeter Jul 2012 #19
Devalue the Euro? by Bruce Krasting Demeter Jul 2012 #22
morning! xchrom Jul 2012 #24
Virtually every SMW regular has been saying the same thing, Dr. Chang Tansy_Gold Jul 2012 #37
Markets Are Rallying After Big String Of Ugly Data xchrom Jul 2012 #26
WOLFGANG MÜNCHAU: Nothing Has Changed In Europe, And Merkel Is Still Winning xchrom Jul 2012 #27
10 Reasons Countries Fall Apart Demeter Jul 2012 #28
The revolution will be organized By Hugo Dixon Demeter Jul 2012 #29
Update: Recovery Measures by Bill McBride Demeter Jul 2012 #30
Eurozone Unemployment Hits A Brand New High Of 11.1% xchrom Jul 2012 #33
European Manufacturing Contracts For 11th Consecutive Month As Unemployment Hits Record Roland99 Jul 2012 #41
I'm starving. See you after breakfast Demeter Jul 2012 #35
just downed mine Roland99 Jul 2012 #43
Yep, the size of the package, is the serving! DemReadingDU Jul 2012 #47
Hellz yeah! Roland99 Jul 2012 #52
So I figured, it's still relatively cool out Demeter Jul 2012 #62
China manufacturing growth slows to a seven-month low xchrom Jul 2012 #36
Eurozone unemployment rises to fresh record high in May xchrom Jul 2012 #38
Mexico's Enrique Pena Nieto 'wins' presidential poll xchrom Jul 2012 #39
June Global PMI Summary: Euro Area Slowdown Is Beginning To Impact The Rest Of The World Roland99 Jul 2012 #40
Ashes, ashes, we all fall down! Demeter Jul 2012 #63
EU bar on Iranian oil now fully enforced xchrom Jul 2012 #42
France 'facing austerity measures' xchrom Jul 2012 #44
(fwiw) 2011 Theme Park Attendance Report Roland99 Jul 2012 #46
Here in Ohio, people go to Kings Island DemReadingDU Jul 2012 #48
had season passes several years ago to King's Island Roland99 Jul 2012 #51
Universal Studios Orlando--Home of the Harry Potter Theme Park Demeter Jul 2012 #64
Love the cartoon :). Need a bumper sticker with that on it! mother earth Jul 2012 #50
Today's Reports (June PMI) >>>> (ruh roh) Roland99 Jul 2012 #53
more detail >>>> Roland99 Jul 2012 #54
U.S. Manufacturing Drops Sharply Viva_La_Revolution Jul 2012 #55
what do we expect when the jobs and manufacturing are outsourced? wordpix Jul 2012 #57
Fighting over Claims Rajiv Sethi Demeter Jul 2012 #65
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Economy»STOCK MARKET WATCH -- Mon...»Reply #28