Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Demeter

(85,373 posts)
58. Where Did All the Workers Go? 60 Years of Economic Change in 1 Graph
Mon Jan 30, 2012, 10:20 AM
Jan 2012

LONG TIME PASSING...

http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/01/where-did-all-the-workers-go-60-years-of-economic-change-in-1-graph/252018/

President Obama's State of the Union speech was surprisingly bullish on reviving manufacturing, prompting one very clever person on Twitter to say something along the lines of: "Democrats want the economy of the 1950s, while Republicans just want to live there."

It got me thinking: What did the economy look like in the 1950s? If you could organize all the jobs into buckets and compare the paper-shuffling professional services bucket to the manufacturing bucket, what would they look like around 1950, and how has the picture changed in the last 60 years?

National Journal addressed just this topic in its special report on the rise and fall and rise of manufacturing. The spectacular graphic compares employment by sector in 1947 and 2007 and its most important lesson is a whopper. Manufacturing and agriculture employed one in three workers just after World War II. Today, those sectors employ only one in eight.



.......MORE.....

Update: I should have made this point more clearly: Manufacturing jobs have declined as a share of the economy. But manufacturing hasn't declined as an industry. It's grown. By a lot. Here's total industrial production (manufacturing, utilities, and mining output) indexed to 1945. Output has sextupled.



IT DOESN'T SAY, BUT I THINK THAT'S IN DOLLARS...AND IF THEY AREN'T CONSTANT DOLLARS, GIVEN OUR INFLATION HISTORY, THAT STILL REPRESENTS A DECLINE IN MANUFACTURING...STAY TUNED FOR MORE INVESTIGATIVE RESULTS

IT'S NOT CLEAR IF "GOVERNMENT" INCLUDES THE MILITARY, WHICH SHOULD BE SEPARATE FROM "GOVERNMENT", ANYWAY. ALTHOUGH MERCENARIES COULD BE THROWN IN WITH MILITARY...

AND WHAT ABOUT CRIMINALS...THOSE NOT GAINFULLY EMPLOYED BY CORPORATIONS?

WHAT ABOUT RELATION TO THE GROWING OR SHRINKING WORKFORCE? THIS GRAPH IS TELLING IN WHAT IT DOESN'T TELL.

'Twas exhausting but worthwhile Tansy_Gold Jan 2012 #1
good show!! that is good news Tuesday Afternoon Jan 2012 #2
Congrats! Demeter Jan 2012 #3
Great! DemReadingDU Jan 2012 #18
... xchrom Jan 2012 #22
Good job! Loge23 Jan 2012 #54
Tansy_Gold will be responsible for saving the Q1 GDP! Roland99 Jan 2012 #60
That is wonderful..... AnneD Jan 2012 #81
Asian Shares Fall Ahead Of EU Summit Ghost Dog Jan 2012 #4
Most Emerging-Market Stocks Decline on Chinese Policy Caution, Europe Debt Ghost Dog Jan 2012 #9
DJIA Futures Down 75 at 6:30 AM EST Demeter Jan 2012 #10
And it's a lovely 14F outside Demeter Jan 2012 #12
This is my last week enjoying a balmy daytime 22ºC Ghost Dog Jan 2012 #23
Between the weather and the food... AnneD Jan 2012 #82
I can't speak for the others Tansy_Gold Jan 2012 #90
U.S. stock futures lower amid fresh Greece worries Demeter Jan 2012 #25
European Stocks Fall Before EU Summit Ghost Dog Jan 2012 #5
Greek Debt Talks Risk Derailing EU Summit Plan Ghost Dog Jan 2012 #8
Greek fury at plan for EU budget control Demeter Jan 2012 #30
UK market falls Ghost Dog Jan 2012 #53
Made in the World By THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN HE'S BEING AN IDIOT, AS USUAL Demeter Jan 2012 #6
And by the way, the "returns" or profits, go to he who steals the best Demeter Jan 2012 #7
China to make Shanghai global yuan hub by 2015 Ghost Dog Jan 2012 #11
UK Financial crime hits record levels as fraudsters net £3.5bn Ghost Dog Jan 2012 #13
Federal mortgage fraud task force subpoenas 11 banks SCHNEIDERMAN STARTS WITH BANG Demeter Jan 2012 #14
WEEKEND REPOST: Banking Wasn’t Meant to Be Like This Demeter Jan 2012 #15
Economic collapse in the Western nations-On the Edge with Max Keiser-01-27-2012 Demeter Jan 2012 #16
Spam deleted by Violet_Crumble (MIR Team) Miko052 May 2012 #91
I'm back on Firefox Demeter Jan 2012 #17
Freddie Mac Betting Against Struggling Homeowners DemReadingDU Jan 2012 #19
morning xchrom Jan 2012 #20
demeter...this one is for you -- i fixed the link xchrom Jan 2012 #21
Thanks, x! Demeter Jan 2012 #27
so far so good. i hope it's the same for you... xchrom Jan 2012 #29
Well, the Kid is Sick Demeter Jan 2012 #61
here's hoping she gets well soon -- and you get a warmer weather. nt xchrom Jan 2012 #62
THIS IS A MUST-READ ARTICLE! Demeter Jan 2012 #28
And to prove POTUS is serious Po_d Mainiac Jan 2012 #43
... xchrom Jan 2012 #46
Industrial property leases jumped nationally in 2011 xchrom Jan 2012 #24
Freddie Mac Betting Against Struggling Homeowners Demeter Jan 2012 #26
Hester agrees to give up £1m bonus Demeter Jan 2012 #31
TODAY'S HUMOR: Banks warn rule change will hurt recovery Demeter Jan 2012 #32
All Thoroughbreds Have Same Ancestor Demeter Jan 2012 #33
very cool. thanks for that. xchrom Jan 2012 #35
I have always had a soft spot Tansy_Gold Jan 2012 #50
i remember that! -- i had forgotten. xchrom Jan 2012 #57
I grew up a mile from Arlington Park Tansy_Gold Jan 2012 #67
god, so beautiful! xchrom Jan 2012 #70
Secretariat.... AnneD Jan 2012 #85
The Austerians Attack! xchrom Jan 2012 #34
7 Signs the Corporatocracy is Losing its Legitimacy--and 7 Tools to Help Shut it Down xchrom Jan 2012 #36
Missing money from MF Global, VAPORIZED DemReadingDU Jan 2012 #37
phasers on vaporise! nt xchrom Jan 2012 #38
Poof it's gone! DemReadingDU Jan 2012 #41
poof -- it's gone! xchrom Jan 2012 #48
Obama Recovery Proves No Morning in America Yet xchrom Jan 2012 #39
DELUGE FROM DAVOS Demeter Jan 2012 #40
Pandit Does Davos, 0.1% Gloat, Madness Reigns: Jonathan Weil Demeter Jan 2012 #42
Moses Naim: The slippery slope down from Davos Demeter Jan 2012 #45
Vladimir Putin - Russia needs more technology and less corruption Demeter Jan 2012 #44
Some Banks Hang On to Bailout Billions Demeter Jan 2012 #47
Money From MF Global Feared Gone Demeter Jan 2012 #49
U.S. Tax Evasion Case Touches Julius Baer Demeter Jan 2012 #51
Oil Falls a Second Day on Speculation EU Talks May Fail to Resolve Crisis xchrom Jan 2012 #52
Japan Warns Of Grim Population Decline Demeter Jan 2012 #55
Consumer spending fizzles in December, savings up Demeter Jan 2012 #56
Where Did All the Workers Go? 60 Years of Economic Change in 1 Graph Demeter Jan 2012 #58
Greek Debt Talks Risk Derailing EU Summit xchrom Jan 2012 #59
8:30am report wrap-up Roland99 Jan 2012 #63
Baltic Dry Index Signals Renewed Market Decline Roland99 Jan 2012 #64
DJIA -100 only 4 min. into today's trading Roland99 Jan 2012 #65
Mario Draghi, the Latin Bloc’s monetarist avenger Ghost Dog Jan 2012 #66
And I Once Thought There Would Never Be Another War in Europe Demeter Jan 2012 #73
A modern Pecora Commission could right Wall Street wrongs Barry Ritholtz Demeter Jan 2012 #68
Morning Marketeers.... AnneD Jan 2012 #69
morning Miss AnneD xchrom Jan 2012 #72
So, You Defragged Your Mental Disk Drive! Demeter Jan 2012 #74
That is exactly the term..... AnneD Jan 2012 #80
Well, Not Alone Demeter Jan 2012 #83
OOOH, I like that! DemReadingDU Jan 2012 #89
EU leaders struggle to reconcile austerity, growth xchrom Jan 2012 #71
That's Easy--Kill the Zombies Demeter Jan 2012 #84
Wall Street execs are major Obama fundraisers Demeter Jan 2012 #75
We’ve Gone from a Nation of Laws to a Nation of Powerful Men Making Laws in Secret Demeter Jan 2012 #76
Deutsche Bank Faces a Series of Damaging Lawsuits xchrom Jan 2012 #77
In an 'Age of Austerity,' How Scarce Resources Could Shape U.S. Politics {polarization} xchrom Jan 2012 #78
Pakistan central bank issues deficit warning xchrom Jan 2012 #79
The PPT Diligently Erasing Reality Again Demeter Jan 2012 #86
Meanwhile, this peon must go out and face reality Demeter Jan 2012 #87
U.S. banks back off lending to European banks Roland99 Jan 2012 #88
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Economy»STOCK MARKET WATCH -- Mon...»Reply #58