In the discussion thread: Hillary WILL NOT Lobby Against The TPP [View all]
Response to Persondem (Reply #158)
Wed Nov 11, 2015, 02:48 PM
Jack Rabbit (45,984 posts)
172. I don't want a way for artificial persons to make an end run around democatic governments
and cry to an unelected panel of corporate shysters when they don't realize expected profits (a benefit it could reasonably have expected to accrue to it . . . is being nullified or impaired as a result of the application of a measure of another Party that is not inconsistent with this Agreement). That is the gist of Chapter 28.
The other matters can be addressed without this horsepucky. What would Adam Smith say about a corporation suing for "expected" profits? There must be an earthquake in the vicinity of his resting place. A corporation is not a human being. It has a charter from the state, not a birth certificate. It has what rights we give them. It is not entitled to human rights. If a corporation wants a profit, it has every right to manufacture a safe product and put it on the market at a reasonable price in competition with other similar manufactured goods made in the market or even some that are as radically different as a solar panel is to a barrel of oil that accomplish the same thing. By a safe product, I mean one that that doesn't harm the end user if used as directed, either as an individual or as a member of society or the biosphere. Yes, that means the state has the right to ban the use of tobacco products or even petroleum products, and that the poisoners at Philip Morris or the polluters at ExxonMobil should not be able to have a a private system of justice at its disposal in order to seek a more favorable judgment than one it might get in a real court. I also don't think it proper for politicians who are guilty of taking [strike]bribes[/strike] generous campaign contributions from corporate officers and high ranking corporate employees, even acting in the fictitious name of the corporation itself, to pass judgment on a radical document that upsets the world's political and legal order by granting artificial persons the right to realize expected profits, something that no reasonable person would expect to find in a state of nature. The majority of our congressmen, who punitively represent us, are bought and paid for by the very legal entities who stand to benefit from a document which they negotiated among themselves. If that sounds corrupt, there's a good reason for it. Yes, I am calling for mass civil disobedience in response to the passage of the TPP and its sinister sister trade deals, TTIP and TISA. I think that would be the just and proper response. Moreover, I call for civil disobedience worldwide and maintain that very few will benefit from these deals and most of us will just be fucked over. Having said that, there is a little matter I need some help me with. I have read parts of the TPP and perused over others, so I may have missed something that you seem to think is there. So persuade me that I'm all wet. Here's your assignment: Please tell us how Dred Scott could have brought his complaint before an ISDS panel. Could he have gotten a better judgment there than he got from the Supreme Court in 1857. If Mr. Scott could not have appealed to the ISDS, what provision in the TPP could Mr. Scott have used to argue that he should be set free, how a result in his favor might have been arrived at and how this decision would be enforced under the TPP. Thank you in advance. |
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
![]() |
Author | Time | Post |
Segami | Nov 2015 | OP | |
TM99 | Nov 2015 | #1 | |
Segami | Nov 2015 | #6 | |
erronis | Nov 2015 | #44 | |
INdemo | Nov 2015 | #67 | |
lewebley3 | Nov 2015 | #169 | |
TM99 | Nov 2015 | #173 | |
lewebley3 | Nov 2015 | #194 | |
TM99 | Nov 2015 | #197 | |
lewebley3 | Nov 2015 | #198 | |
kacekwl | Nov 2015 | #52 | |
acuity24 | Nov 2015 | #159 | |
InAbLuEsTaTe | Nov 2015 | #163 | |
roguevalley | Nov 2015 | #77 | |
imthevicar | Nov 2015 | #135 | |
lewebley3 | Nov 2015 | #168 | |
TM99 | Nov 2015 | #171 | |
lewebley3 | Nov 2015 | #196 | |
TM99 | Nov 2015 | #199 | |
lewebley3 | Nov 2015 | #200 | |
TM99 | Nov 2015 | #201 | |
lewebley3 | Nov 2015 | #202 | |
Jester Messiah | Nov 2015 | #204 | |
lewebley3 | Nov 2015 | #205 | |
Jester Messiah | Nov 2015 | #206 | |
Cassiopeia | Nov 2015 | #2 | |
tecelote | Nov 2015 | #19 | |
Fast Walker 52 | Nov 2015 | #41 | |
Cassiopeia | Nov 2015 | #92 | |
99th_Monkey | Nov 2015 | #121 | |
BeanMusical | Nov 2015 | #136 | |
Plucketeer | Nov 2015 | #83 | |
pangaia | Nov 2015 | #3 | |
erronis | Nov 2015 | #46 | |
stillwaiting | Nov 2015 | #4 | |
UglyGreed | Nov 2015 | #5 | |
virtualobserver | Nov 2015 | #7 | |
R. Daneel Olivaw | Nov 2015 | #59 | |
Kelvin Mace | Nov 2015 | #8 | |
Buzz cook | Nov 2015 | #9 | |
ruffburr | Nov 2015 | #10 | |
Aerows | Nov 2015 | #11 | |
restorefreedom | Nov 2015 | #13 | |
restorefreedom | Nov 2015 | #12 | |
Autumn | Nov 2015 | #14 | |
Paka | Nov 2015 | #97 | |
AzDar | Nov 2015 | #15 | |
Segami | Nov 2015 | #16 | |
AzDar | Nov 2015 | #18 | |
840high | Nov 2015 | #68 | |
roguevalley | Nov 2015 | #78 | |
BeanMusical | Nov 2015 | #137 | |
tex-wyo-dem | Nov 2015 | #89 | |
Paka | Nov 2015 | #105 | |
MrMickeysMom | Nov 2015 | #17 | |
Art_from_Ark | Nov 2015 | #147 | |
SoapBox | Nov 2015 | #20 | |
tecelote | Nov 2015 | #21 | |
bahrbearian | Nov 2015 | #23 | |
Ed Suspicious | Nov 2015 | #38 | |
rhett o rick | Nov 2015 | #126 | |
hopemountain | Nov 2015 | #133 | |
willvotesdem | Nov 2015 | #156 | |
ConservativeDemocrat | Nov 2015 | #164 | |
rhett o rick | Nov 2015 | #166 | |
blackspade | Nov 2015 | #175 | |
ConservativeDemocrat | Nov 2015 | #182 | |
blackspade | Nov 2015 | #184 | |
ConservativeDemocrat | Nov 2015 | #185 | |
blackspade | Nov 2015 | #187 | |
ConservativeDemocrat | Nov 2015 | #192 | |
blackspade | Nov 2015 | #193 | |
ConservativeDemocrat | Nov 2015 | #195 | |
blackspade | Nov 2015 | #210 | |
ConservativeDemocrat | Nov 2015 | #213 | |
blackspade | Nov 2015 | #215 | |
LiberalLovinLug | Nov 2015 | #179 | |
ConservativeDemocrat | Nov 2015 | #183 | |
LiberalLovinLug | Nov 2015 | #211 | |
ConservativeDemocrat | Nov 2015 | #214 | |
LiberalLovinLug | Nov 2015 | #216 | |
ConservativeDemocrat | Nov 2015 | #218 | |
LiberalLovinLug | Nov 2015 | #219 | |
ConservativeDemocrat | Nov 2015 | #220 | |
hopemountain | Nov 2015 | #186 | |
AlbertCat | Nov 2015 | #58 | |
R. Daneel Olivaw | Nov 2015 | #64 | |
R. Daneel Olivaw | Nov 2015 | #63 | |
rhett o rick | Nov 2015 | #117 | |
BeanMusical | Nov 2015 | #142 | |
rhett o rick | Nov 2015 | #165 | |
William769 | Nov 2015 | #217 | |
BeanMusical | Nov 2015 | #221 | |
wilsonbooks | Nov 2015 | #39 | |
rhett o rick | Nov 2015 | #113 | |
SheilaT | Nov 2015 | #22 | |
rhett o rick | Nov 2015 | #116 | |
a2liberal | Nov 2015 | #144 | |
rhett o rick | Nov 2015 | #162 | |
George II | Nov 2015 | #24 | |
Bryce Butler | Nov 2015 | #27 | |
LiberalArkie | Nov 2015 | #28 | |
guillaumeb | Nov 2015 | #30 | |
roguevalley | Nov 2015 | #81 | |
George II | Nov 2015 | #99 | |
BeanMusical | Nov 2015 | #143 | |
polly7 | Nov 2015 | #150 | |
BeanMusical | Nov 2015 | #153 | |
polly7 | Nov 2015 | #154 | |
BeanMusical | Nov 2015 | #155 | |
PowerToThePeople | Nov 2015 | #25 | |
SammyWinstonJack | Nov 2015 | #26 | |
yallerdawg | Nov 2015 | #29 | |
Jack Rabbit | Nov 2015 | #31 | |
SusanCalvin | Nov 2015 | #42 | |
Jack Rabbit | Nov 2015 | #74 | |
Android3.14 | Nov 2015 | #32 | |
KansDem | Nov 2015 | #33 | |
dorkzilla | Nov 2015 | #62 | |
hughee99 | Nov 2015 | #76 | |
lame54 | Nov 2015 | #34 | |
tex-wyo-dem | Nov 2015 | #93 | |
coyote | Nov 2015 | #127 | |
lame54 | Nov 2015 | #160 | |
coyote | Nov 2015 | #188 | |
mmonk | Nov 2015 | #35 | |
Persondem | Nov 2015 | #36 | |
GoneFishin | Nov 2015 | #40 | |
SusanCalvin | Nov 2015 | #43 | |
GoneFishin | Nov 2015 | #49 | |
SusanCalvin | Nov 2015 | #54 | |
DhhD | Nov 2015 | #181 | |
Persondem | Nov 2015 | #47 | |
GoneFishin | Nov 2015 | #51 | |
Persondem | Nov 2015 | #56 | |
GoneFishin | Nov 2015 | #69 | |
Persondem | Nov 2015 | #91 | |
Jack Rabbit | Nov 2015 | #98 | |
GoneFishin | Nov 2015 | #103 | |
Jack Rabbit | Nov 2015 | #109 | |
Persondem | Nov 2015 | #120 | |
Jack Rabbit | Nov 2015 | #124 | |
Persondem | Nov 2015 | #158 | |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Jack Rabbit | Nov 2015 | #172 |
rhett o rick | Nov 2015 | #118 | |
Persondem | Nov 2015 | #119 | |
BeanMusical | Nov 2015 | #145 | |
Persondem | Nov 2015 | #157 | |
GoneFishin | Nov 2015 | #37 | |
darkangel218 | Nov 2015 | #45 | |
Major Hogwash | Nov 2015 | #132 | |
GoneFishin | Nov 2015 | #139 | |
think | Nov 2015 | #48 | |
SusanCalvin | Nov 2015 | #55 | |
GoneFishin | Nov 2015 | #140 | |
silenttigersong | Nov 2015 | #50 | |
d_legendary1 | Nov 2015 | #53 | |
davidpdx | Nov 2015 | #134 | |
GoneFishin | Nov 2015 | #141 | |
davidpdx | Nov 2015 | #146 | |
GoneFishin | Nov 2015 | #167 | |
GeorgeGist | Nov 2015 | #189 | |
R. Daneel Olivaw | Nov 2015 | #57 | |
whatchamacallit | Nov 2015 | #60 | |
R. Daneel Olivaw | Nov 2015 | #70 | |
whatchamacallit | Nov 2015 | #82 | |
GoneFishin | Nov 2015 | #106 | |
Art_from_Ark | Nov 2015 | #151 | |
sadoldgirl | Nov 2015 | #61 | |
Name removed | Nov 2015 | #65 | |
AzDar | Nov 2015 | #72 | |
ColesCountyDem | Nov 2015 | #75 | |
tex-wyo-dem | Nov 2015 | #96 | |
Paka | Nov 2015 | #110 | |
INdemo | Nov 2015 | #66 | |
Historic NY | Nov 2015 | #71 | |
jeff47 | Nov 2015 | #112 | |
GeorgeGist | Nov 2015 | #190 | |
stupidicus | Nov 2015 | #73 | |
SmittynMo | Nov 2015 | #79 | |
Truprogressive85 | Nov 2015 | #80 | |
Phlem | Nov 2015 | #84 | |
Puglover | Nov 2015 | #88 | |
Phlem | Nov 2015 | #104 | |
Puglover | Nov 2015 | #85 | |
YOHABLO | Nov 2015 | #86 | |
floriduck | Nov 2015 | #87 | |
PatrickforO | Nov 2015 | #90 | |
Populist_Prole | Nov 2015 | #125 | |
kelliekat44 | Nov 2015 | #94 | |
floriduck | Nov 2015 | #95 | |
kelliekat44 | Nov 2015 | #100 | |
Dawgs | Nov 2015 | #212 | |
cantbeserious | Nov 2015 | #101 | |
WillyT | Nov 2015 | #102 | |
azmom | Nov 2015 | #107 | |
senz | Nov 2015 | #108 | |
BeanMusical | Nov 2015 | #148 | |
Faryn Balyncd | Nov 2015 | #111 | |
JEB | Nov 2015 | #114 | |
whereisjustice | Nov 2015 | #115 | |
philly_bob | Nov 2015 | #122 | |
jfern | Nov 2015 | #123 | |
BeanMusical | Nov 2015 | #149 | |
JDPriestly | Nov 2015 | #128 | |
Major Hogwash | Nov 2015 | #131 | |
Unknown Beatle | Nov 2015 | #129 | |
BeanMusical | Nov 2015 | #152 | |
Betty Karlson | Nov 2015 | #130 | |
Fairgo | Nov 2015 | #138 | |
monicaangela | Nov 2015 | #161 | |
retrowire | Nov 2015 | #170 | |
blackspade | Nov 2015 | #174 | |
I hate liars | Nov 2015 | #176 | |
bvar22 | Nov 2015 | #177 | |
Faux pas | Nov 2015 | #178 | |
jkbRN | Nov 2015 | #180 | |
Freddie Stubbs | Nov 2015 | #191 | |
Jester Messiah | Nov 2015 | #203 | |
Tierra_y_Libertad | Nov 2015 | #207 | |
sabrina 1 | Nov 2015 | #208 | |
EndElectoral | Nov 2015 | #209 |
Edit History
Please login to view edit histories.