Reply #130: Right about the time Mike Nifong was made the judge in the case... [View All]

[BrownOak]

So it's OK for you to presume guilt based on the statements of the alleged victim and the actions of the DA, yet when someone else presumes a lack of guilt based on the statements of the accused and the reporting of a third party who has seen all, yes all, of the prosecution's evidence released in the discovery you dismiss their opinion.

You can't have it both ways. IndianaGreen's view of the situation is every bit as valid as yours, perhaps even more as his/her opinions are backed by the only documented reports from investigators that have been seen by the public. You can try to discredit all that's been released in those motions as defense spin, but the fact remains that those snippets of reports are more substantial than the comments from the DA who may very well have his own reasons for spinning the case.