Reply #64: ashiebr......instead of remarks...how about answers? [View All]

[pelsar]

I noticed that instead of anwering many of the questions, you tend to make remarks....

when talking about the jews and israel i was refering to it in relation to israel and judaisim...thats what the conversation was about, thats how it got started and thats what my reference point was. And when talking about israel to jews, our past is ever present.

the mitchel commission, what is hard to understand...they admit that they information was tainted, they admit they did no research....what does that make their report for even a pre law student? in the world of facts, its makes it useless....your attempt at using a tainted piece of secondary information as "proof" is at best foolish.
Do you believe it would stand up in a court of law (try answering the question this time)


you should like this:
The Palestine National Authority has accepted the report of the Mitchell Commission on the causes of the Palestinian Intifada, calling the document ?balanced?.

However, the document is only ?balanced? because on most contentious issues it states the positions of both sides in ?balanced? fashion without taking sides.

http://www.mediamonitors.net/michaeljansen2.html

I dont really understand...if one rejects a non violent solution in a violent war...how is the conclusion that you are for violence mistaken? I dont know of any gray area here.

again try answering the question with a understanble answer and not with a remark which really doesnt mean anything......

I also noticed that you kind of skipped over the empericle evidence that showed the intifada II was initially limited to a few select westbank cities, which suggests that it wasnt "spontanous" as was intifada I. I realize your response will be "that proves nothing" and it dosesnt but it does suggest that unlike intifada I, it was organized (the mitchell report seem to deemed this bit of info "not worthy of mentioning...I guess for the usual poiltical reasons, give the character of the report).

this time...really try to keep with questions as opposed to simplistic remarks which really have no value......