Reply #26: The Eight Page Reference in this Article is Not Accurate - [View All]

[Justice]

The eight pages are not eight pages of information that Fitzgerald gave to the Judge. The eight pages are pages from the Judge's concurring opinion in the case. Big difference.

I've read that Fitzgerald provided the judges with BINDERS full of classified information to make their analysis. It was from these BINDERS that the concurring judge did his analysis and wrote the opinion.

Very very important distinction - eight pages of the decision - many many more pages of evidence that Fitzgerald provided.

O'Donnell article gets it right - Judge Tatel wrote a 41 page decision - 8 pages are redacted - in those 8 pages Tatel discusses the materials Fitzgerald presented.


I must say some reporters are hacks. They keep getting the facts wrong - I swear just to create controversy.