Reply #23: It never quite caught on with me. [View All]

[RiDuvessa]

But there were still aspects that I liked.

1. Trip - I loved his character. I totally disagree that he was a bad rip-off of Geordie. I think he played an engineer dealing with new and barely understood technology quite well.

2. Phlox - He was great.

3. Porthos - I'm sorry, I know most people hated this, but it made sense to me. Having a pet on a voyage that was that long would help someone cope. Also, he was just dang cute.

4. The Klingon explanation. - Well Done!

5. The theme song the first season. - I thought it was a nice change from the instrumentals.

On the down side, I hated almost every other Klingon episode, it completely screwed with the timeline, T'pol was extremely annoying and not very Vulcan, and in general, I just didn't like it. The whole Temporal war Sulibon thing just annoyed the piss out of me.