Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

swong19104

(630 posts)
8. Prison isn't the right option for the mother
Fri Jul 7, 2023, 12:30 AM
Jul 2023

Just make sure she's not able to ever have children again. She's no threat to society, so why imprison her? What is punishing her helpful to the rest of society? Is it going to deter other prospective mothers from doing what she did?

Vengeance based on emotions is the worst thing enlightened (I hope!) people can do. Killing all the upper echelon people within the Republican party, yeah, that makes sense, because they are an existential threat to society and the planet. This woman? If she were to become a mother again, for the rest of her life, she might be able to birth 10, 12 children. And if she were to be so negligent as to cause all 12 to die, so what? That's not a threat to any of us.

And lastly, it's none of my business, but in some circumstances (probably not in this case), the mother has to make that rather terrible choice on having to commit infanticide. Other animals do it on a regular basis due to whatever circumstances are occurring. Zebra mothers are known to kick their newborns to death because the bleating of the newborn will signal to predators the whereabouts of the herd. Bears, birds, baboons are also known to commit infanticide. It's nature's way of enabling the fittest to survive. I doubt that is the case here, but I'm not in this mother's head rationalizing on what transpired.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I read the story. It's strange and tragic BlueWaveNeverEnd Jul 2023 #1
another weird one: 18-Month-Old Dies After Being Left in Car Overnight BlueWaveNeverEnd Jul 2023 #2
Meth... Pot.... Booze NowISeetheLight Jul 2023 #3
And drive them home from (nt) Hugh_Lebowski Jul 2023 #4
Stupid aand awful but damn there needs to be an alarm for this lostnfound Jul 2023 #5
New cars have this feature. They alert to check back seat with the slightest weight. SYFROYH Jul 2023 #6
2019 NowISeetheLight Jul 2023 #10
Yes, my Toyota will even send phylny Jul 2023 #13
Proof that some people should be sterilized. dalton99a Jul 2023 #7
Prison isn't the right option for the mother swong19104 Jul 2023 #8
This message was self-deleted by its author ShazzieB Jul 2023 #9
This message was self-deleted by its author MrsCoffee Jul 2023 #11
Prison is perfectly appropriate..... brooklynite Jul 2023 #12
Going on vacation is negligence, swong19104 Jul 2023 #18
Leaving your kid alone when you go out for dinner is negligence... brooklynite Jul 2023 #19
Breivik can still be a threat after his sentence swong19104 Jul 2023 #20
that mother had to know her baby would not survive being alone for 10 days Beaverhausen Jul 2023 #21
There is room for penalty in sentencing. SYFROYH Jul 2023 #14
First of all, the child wasn't a newborn infant. LisaL Jul 2023 #15
And the point of a long (or any) prison sentence is to do what? swong19104 Jul 2023 #17
lol a lot going on in this post WhiskeyGrinder Jul 2023 #16
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Toddler dies after being ...»Reply #8