Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Decoy of Fenris

(1,954 posts)
17. Not "exactly". Not even close.
Mon May 13, 2013, 09:56 AM
May 2013

If the debate was about dead kids and adults, then the rightwing arguments of pools and cars killing more people would hold water. It's not about the deaths, it isn't even about the life; it's about the gun. Gun Control folks who trot out children and make false appeals to emotion -have- no argument, because there is no argument to be made. People die from one cause or another; a gun is a convenient scapegoat upon which to place blame and scorn, and more often than not, those crying the loudest for bans and confiscations are the same people who would never take part in firearm-related activities regardless. To them, it's win/win; they lose nothing while forcing others to lose something. It is arrogant self-righteous mental masturbation in the extreme , and none of it is "for the children".

You want to know why people like me aren't affected by the "Dead children" argument? Because people die. Adults die, elders die, children die, babies die, all from all manner of causes that -aren't- guns, some of which are preventable. I have yet to see anyone give me a reason for gun control that doesn't boil down to the right-wing authoritarian meme of "Think of the children!"

Does that make me cruel and callous? Possibly, but as I mentioned above, I am not beyond reason. Show me a way to easily prevent gun violence and deaths largely without impacting the common everyday gun owner and I'll be on board with financial and physical support in a heartbeat. However, I rather dislike "BAN ALL THE EVERYTHING BECAUSE OMG THE CHILDREN" as a rally call, what with being a progressive Democrat and all.


Let's start small, though. Would you tell me one reason why gun control is a necessity, with one caveat: "People dying" doesn't count as a reason. If you can do that, then we're getting somewhere in an active dialogue.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I mostly post about agriculture subsidies Recursion May 2013 #1
Post removed Post removed May 2013 #3
Have you weighted my post count since DU2? I have. Recursion May 2013 #7
you're saying you mostly do something you haven't done since DU2? CreekDog May 2013 #8
Ooh. You might not be holding your breath, but you'll be holding your tongue. Decoy of Fenris May 2013 #19
This message was self-deleted by its author Recursion May 2013 #20
nothing trumps their paranoia Skittles May 2013 #2
Yep. I think they're in the toils of an addiction... Junkdrawer May 2013 #9
that is a plausible analysis Skittles May 2013 #24
The problem with finding courage in a hunk of hardened steel: The feeling of empowerment fades.... Junkdrawer May 2013 #28
Silly. Kids don't have their own misinterpreted Amendment to hide behind. onehandle May 2013 #4
Have you considered not using dead children and broken families as crutches for your debates? Decoy of Fenris May 2013 #5
Pro Tip: Starting off with an NRAGOPTeahadist talking point is not wise. onehandle May 2013 #11
This debate is 100% about dead kids, dead adults and broken families. Scuba May 2013 #12
Exactly laundry_queen May 2013 #13
Not "exactly". Not even close. Decoy of Fenris May 2013 #17
Do you think if nobody was shot by people with guns, that anyone would still want to control them? jmg257 May 2013 #21
Honestly? Yes. There are always people who wish to control the lives of others. Decoy of Fenris May 2013 #23
I vote this as laundry_queen May 2013 #30
I think that is a valid point. OneGrassRoot May 2013 #6
friends on FB loyalsister May 2013 #27
Some people post about guns a majority of the time because they think aikoaiko May 2013 #10
What the fuck are YOU doing for the children sorefeet May 2013 #14
Great thread pintobean May 2013 #15
Works both ways. Lizzie Poppet May 2013 #16
If you think you're psychic, then you should go get tested by psycop. ZombieHorde May 2013 #18
You need to get out more. rrneck May 2013 #22
I'll believe the same thing about gun control advocates when they... beevul May 2013 #25
Not taking a side here but you could replace gun upaloopa May 2013 #26
So you think Grandma wants to stick a knitting needle in junior? MichiganVote May 2013 #29
No the problem is the OP is a worthless piece of dung upaloopa May 2013 #31
That's not nice. MichiganVote May 2013 #32
The OP insinuates that a whole group of upaloopa May 2013 #33
That's not nice either but have a nice day! MichiganVote May 2013 #34
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I'll believe gun advocate...»Reply #17