Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(128,909 posts)
8. "They can tell this story now with fewer positive white characters"
Sun Nov 10, 2013, 12:07 PM
Nov 2013

There weren't that many "positive white characters" in there and one cannot broad brush to say that no "positive" whites existed. If they didn't, "we" (editorial, and me, specifically - "blacks&quot probably wouldn't be here today, let alone with a Barack H. Obama as President.

IMHO, if they are going to re-do it, they should also do the full thing to include "Roots II: The Next Generations" (which I believe followed Haley's maternal side), as that miniseries covered from the Civil War through to the 1970s and included Reconstruction, Jim Crow, WWI, WWII, and the Civil Rights era.

As FYI, I was in high school when the original aired and I have watched it many times since (and still have it on tape), and although the actors and actresses (back then dubbed part of an "All Star Cast" ) are all now "dated", the material is still pretty vicious and heart-breaking.

If anything, what hadn't been shown before then in any documentary or docu-drama of this subject, was the society and rituals that had evolved in the small villages of African countries like Guinea (including the presence of Islam there). Previously, the only thing that most could conceive about any African country (where most, even today, keep referring to the continent of Africa as if it were a country) was the bullshit shown in the endless movie serial and television series "Tarzan" or the animated "Kimba". But most notably, Roots showed the harrowing "Middle Passage", something that had previously been relegated to display of the same old illustrations of "close pack" and "loose pack" (with respect to how the slaves were loaded and managed in the ship holds) where men and women were chained prone to wooden planks, row after row, and level upon level.

Haley was actively involved in the original and the danger now (although knowing alot of the story was originally "Hollywoodized&quot is trivializing and glossing over the history to soften it - especially in this era of rightwing lunatic ownership of almost all of the media. And as an example, although the original clearly showed African involvement in the trade with respect to Kunta's (and others' capture), there will be those demanding to remove any white involvement whatsover in the transactions and transport. So I expect as this project evolves, it will get quite ugly (although there are many more scholars in African and African-American history out there now to debate it, all of whom have accumulated and published quite a bit of primary research over the past 35 years).

On the Remaking of "Roots" [View all] alphafemale Nov 2013 OP
We were glued to the tv as a family HappyMe Nov 2013 #1
Very doubtful it will even boomersense Nov 2013 #21
I agree! Little Star Nov 2013 #2
I hear the History Channel has bought the rights, and is doing the remake? CatWoman Nov 2013 #3
There were NO postive white characters in enlightenment Nov 2013 #4
...not even close to what the OP said. Cooley Hurd Nov 2013 #5
Really? enlightenment Nov 2013 #12
There were way too many positive white characters penciled in. alphafemale Nov 2013 #6
yes it was so damn convenient CatWoman Nov 2013 #7
Yep, I'm sure in his heart of hearts Jefferson, for example, knew that slavery was wrong. Nye Bevan Nov 2013 #11
Jefferson freed his own children. Sired with a slave. alphafemale Nov 2013 #16
"They can tell this story now with fewer positive white characters" BumRushDaShow Nov 2013 #8
I have a HUGE problem with Africans being depicted as illiterate savages alphafemale Nov 2013 #9
Unfortunately it's still happening BumRushDaShow Nov 2013 #15
There were illiterate savages and developed civilizations on every continent except ... dawg Nov 2013 #18
"illiterate" and "savage" are not synonyms bhikkhu Nov 2013 #24
Yes, I agree with that. dawg Nov 2013 #26
I have my own doubts as to the re-make. Archae Nov 2013 #10
Ice Road Truckers! alphafemale Nov 2013 #13
This is the kind of statement: kiva Nov 2013 #14
Thank you. I agree completely. whathehell Nov 2013 #17
Hide the fuck out of it alphafemale Nov 2013 #23
I'm white and I have no problem with that statement. HappyMe Nov 2013 #25
The Republican version tells the story in reverse. alfredo Nov 2013 #19
Our family watched the original like every other family in America. Dustlawyer Nov 2013 #20
Here's the problem..Instead of holding the limited belief that blacks are the descendants of slaves, HipChick Nov 2013 #22
Agreed. Don't start the story with the slave ships.. alphafemale Nov 2013 #27
A few years back, I travelled to Nubia HipChick Nov 2013 #28
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»On the Remaking of "...»Reply #8