Reply #19: Not a manifesto, but . . . [View All]

[ChicagoRonin]

I do believe that pulp culture is frequently a reflection of how the populace (or sections of the populace) view the state of the world. Even if adapted from an older work (such as an old comic), the tone and execution tends to say a lot about the times.

Some quick thoughts on recent pop films and possible underlying messages.

1) The X-Men movies: fear of prejudice from the general populace, distrust of government agencies and corrupt individuals, also a warning against radical elements on the left (Magneto?).

2) V for Vendetta: Distrust of government, criticism of the use of fear and propaganda to manipulate the population, demand for individuals to take action in the face of corruption.

3) Batman Begins: Fear of encroaching urban decay and crime, distrust of existing bodies (ex: government, law-enforcement) to solve problems. Ultimately, in terms of Batman's vigilante actions, the film actually seems to advocate a right-wing view.

4) 28 Weeks Later: Failure of established bodies (US Military, government, etc.) to adequately deal with large-scale disasters, fear of the effects of disproportionate and indiscriminate application of military force.

Nothing really profound. It's just like the way sci-fi films of the 50s played off of fears of communistic takeover or nuclear war, and 60s and 70s sci-fi and horror had anti-pollution messages.